6 ms·
Finland has mandatory military service for males. So every year you most of the young men (mostly age 18 to 20) into a controlled environment and go through sta
by nabla9 7y ago
Finland has mandatory military service for males. So every year you most of the young men (mostly age 18 to 20) into a controlled environment and go through standardized testing and observation.
- Physical fitness has gone down, overweight goes up.
- Intelligence peaked among those who were born in 70's and has been in slight decline last 18 years. Similar results can be seen in other developed countries.
- Anxiety disorders and depression have increased.
- Social skills have gone up. Young men are more social and better at working together than any time before.
- At the same time there is small but growing group of young men with almost no social skills. They can't get friends or maintain friendships or work in a group.
- 101404 7y ago> Finland has mandatory military service for males. How is that kind of institutionalized sexism still legal?
- nabla9 7y agoBecause there is a law for mandatory service, and nobody wants to extend it to women. Women can volunteer and some of them do.
- jandrese 7y agoFinland has a history of needing to fight off a much larger expansionist neighbor. One who has recently (a few years ago) annexed more territory while the rest of the world sat around and did nothing. Or are you asking why they don't extend the mandatory service to women? The reasons for that are somewhat historic and very _biotruth_. A country that fights a devastating war that wipes out 90% of the men but keeps the women can recover. A country that has 90% of the women wiped out but leaves the men is completely screwed.
- allannienhuis 7y agoBut those aren't the two options. If loss of life were equal due to equal participation, you'd get 45% loss of each sex (using your 90% of men figure as the potential loss), which (while still devastating) isn't the same argument for losing the breeding capacity of the country. The reality is that those sorts of rules are very much based on culture tradition ('historic'). It takes a long time for parts of our culture to change. Only a few countries have mandatory service for women (Finland's neighbors Norway and Sweden among them). Israel does as well, but has a large exception on religious grounds. Also, mandatory service doesn't necessarily mean mandatory combat service, although I don't know how those countries just mentioned manage that.
- magicsmoke 7y agoScenario A: 100 women, 100 men. 100 men go off to war, 10 men return. But with polygamy, 100 women have 100 children for the next generation. Scenario B: 100 women, 100 men. 50 women and 50 men go off to war, 5 men and 5 women return. You have 55 women left in the population and 55 children for the next generation. The limiting factor in human population growth is the number of women that can have children. The cold calculus might be distasteful, but it is there.
- allannienhuis 7y agoby adding polygamy into the mix, you're moving the goalposts of what is really just an intellectual exercise here. The reality is that these sorts of laws are put in place based on what the lawmakers feel is culturally acceptable (tradition). Pretty confident the people arguing for male-only conscription aren't putting much weight on polygamy in their thinking. What they're really thinking is that they need male soldiers to win their war or defend their country...
- jandrese 7y agoIt's not even official polygamy, it's just people being people and life finding a way. Lots of single mother households raising a bunch of kids. The balance is mostly restored in the next generation.
- LanceH 7y agoYou do have another 45 men who aren't dead. They appreciate that a lot. You left that out...like it's always left out.
- take_a_breath 7y agoPoor men, always being left out. Maybe 2020 is the year we finally get a male President in the US. We can dream.
- as1mov 7y ago
- GhostVII 7y agoIf there was ever a situation where there was a genuine risk of a significant portion of the military being killed, it would not be difficult to withdraw all women from the military at that point. And I do not think there has been a single country in modern history that was at a genuine risk of being wiped out due to combat deaths, even if all of those combat deaths had been men instead of women. To me this incredibly small risk does not seem to be worth holding one gender back over another, increasing the gender gap for no reason. Forcing someone to work just because of their gender seems very wrong to me.
- privateprofile 7y agoIsrael has mandatory service for women and men, and has presently one of the most advanced armed forces.
- sergiotapia 7y agoThey can thank the US for footing the bill for all those war toys.
- FrojoS 7y agoAFAIK, in Israel women serve less time and in less dangerous roles. The only culture that I know of, which seems to have somewhat equal burden of war fighting are the Peshmerga/Kurds.
- itronitron 7y agoSo, the strategic planning was done by Dr. Strangelove?
- Chris2048 7y agoWhat kind of situation wipes out the army, then leaves the country alone to recover?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jandrese 7y agoThe kind where you are conquered but the population survives as a vassal state.
- Benji_San 7y agoJehovas witnesses in Finland were exempt from the military service until last year. Someone took it to court and the ruling was that you can't discrimate certain groups based on their religion. I think it's only a question of time before it is brought up as gender discrimination and the exemption will be removed. There are some political interest in changing in mostly from the youth branches of the political parties but the "real" politicians mostly stick their fingers in their ears. I suppose it is more or less political suicide to try to change the statsu quo as would affect a huge amount of voters negatively.
- _hl_ 7y agoSwitzerland is in the same position. You cannot get a majority for abolishing the draft, so it is here to stay (for now). You also cannot get a majority for extending it to women, for those who support the military tend to also be those who hold more conservative values, and those who seek egalitarianism tend to be those who would want to abolish the draft.
- Mirioron 7y agoThis is the norm almost everywhere that has conscription. There's a map of countries with conscription on Wikipedia (blue, red, and yellow): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscription https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conscription
- as1mov 7y agoTurns out feminists don't want the 'right' to be considered as expendable resources, so they conveniently pretend it doesn't exist.
- golemiprague 7y agoWhen you actually need to defend your country you bring in people who can do the job, it is not a diversity program. Even startups mostly have men, it is not without reason, men are just better at certain things.
- pkilgore 7y agoWould love to read more, you have a source(s)?
- cryptonode 7y agoI think the parent is referring to the Flynn Effect. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect?wprov=sfla1 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect?wprov=sfla1
- hanklazard 7y agoThis is fascinating. Do you have a link for where we can read more about the data?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Majestic121 7y agoThat's pretty interesting, do you have any link to read a bit more about all this ? I'm having a hard time finding relevant links on google
- qqssccfftt 7y agoMandatory military service otherwise known as government mandated slavery
- enriquto 7y agoIt depends if you think of your country as an accessory burden or as the ensemble of your fellows. Incidentally, this seems to be an argument towards smaller, culturally homogeneous countries, where it is much easier to feel connected to the whole set of your countrymen.
- pointer_pointer 7y agoI agree. In the 90's my country began to experience deep tensions between imported communities and the historical population. The military service was then abolished (officially for budgetary reasons).
- balnaphone 7y ago> Mandatory military service otherwise known as government mandated slavery >> It depends if you think of your country as an accessory burden or as the ensemble of your fellows. This "depends" clause doesn't logically follow, since the "slavery" label applies in either circumstance. If one's country is an "ensemble of your fellows", then volunteering for military service may logically follow from that; forcing others to do so, does not. In either case, whether one feels connected to one's country or not, being compelled by force to participate in the military can legitimately be seen as a form of slavery -- since the victim is unable to withdraw unilaterally from their compelled service. If one cares deeply about their own countrymen, why would one want to enslave them, and remove their choice and freedom in the matter?
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI think mandatory military service is the only way to get sufficient people interested in participating and educating themselves about current issues to have a functional democracy.
- 7y ago
- _0ffh 7y agoHow are they measuring declining IQ over time? IQ tests are regularly recalibrated to mean=100 and std=15. That opens quite the can of worms for comparabilty in all sorts of ways.
- FabHK 7y agoThe Flynn effect denotes the increase of IQ over time and is well established and documented (not necessarily well understood, though, albeit there are many theories). And the last decade or so has indeed seen a reversal of the Flynn effect. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18956085 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18956085
- nabla9 7y agoIntelligence researchers don't use IQ, they use raw data from testing. As you pointed out, IQ is not usable for research across time or across countries or cultures. You can only compare individuals in the same time and same population.
- 411111111111111 7y agoIts further biased by how many iq tests the testee has done before. Honestly, iq tests are pointless unless you're selecting for people that are willing to invest time into worthless knowledge in order to win in a contest. Which is a valid criteria, considering that these are the most motivated people... Its just not "intelligence", though that itself is just as pointless to measure.
- dodobirdlord 7y agoIQ tests are not pointless, the scores have strong correlation with lifetime achievement and are useful for population statistics about things like educational outcomes and the harms of childhood malnutrition. The meaningfulness of the test score breaks down if someone carries out a campaign of preparation, but that doesn’t make the tests useless. IQ testing gets a lot of flak from people who seem to have an axe to grind, in much the same way that BMI measurements get a lot of flak from people who fall well within the range where it’s useful. Sure, MENSA is stupid and BMI isn’t a useful measurement for professional athletes, but so what?
- faceplanted 7y ago>> - Intelligence peaked among those who were born in 70's and has been in slight decline last 18 years. Similar results can be seen in other developed countries. I always wonder when people post these numbers about IQ going up and down over time, what scales are we talking about here? like is it a difference of like 2 IQ points or is it like a difference of 20? Cause if it's 5 or less I can't imagine it would make any real functional difference to the country.
- jl2718 7y agoFor IQ, the average (mean) is heavily influenced by the number of low performers. It’s not a good indicator of what is going on with the ‘normal’ kids. Some of the observations here might indicate that there is a growing population of kids with social and mental problems. This is probably a much bigger problem than a mild decline of the median.
- dcolkitt 7y agoOne hypothesis to consider is the drastic decline in teen smoking rates. Nicotine is a powerful anti-psychotic. Smoking rates among the schizotypal are nearly double the rest of the population, even when controlling for common explanatory factors. Social isolation, anxiety, depression, mild cognitive impairment and avoidant behavior are all signs of untreated schizophrenia. It's possible in the past that those with sub-clinical schizotypal personalities self-medicated with tobacco. Removing that would result in a sub-segment of the population becoming significantly less functional in a pronounced way.
- asdff 7y agoI wonder how the decline of teen smoking follows the rise of other forms of stimulants, like caffeine, or other forms of nicotine consumption.
- doikor 7y agoNote that the Finnish military uses the intelligence test (P1 test) mainly to compare the men within the same arrival group. More specifically within the same unit to pick who go to leadership/speciality school etc. (together with the P2 "personality test") For us it was done the morning after being on a training exercise in the forest whole weekend with most being lucky if they have gotten more then 3h of sleep per night for the last 2 nights. Also a certain portion answer it badly on purpose (don't want to end in leadership/speciality stuff due to longer service time). But yeah main thing the military is complaining about new recruits is physical fitness being down (a lot) and thus a lot flunking out and maybe again in a couple years (most of these get permanent "not fit for duty during peace time" after a couple rounds with the doctors over a decade or so) Also the P1 test to some extent tests your test taking skills. Specifically the kind where you know how to quickly scan over the questions and pick the easiest ones and answer them first. It has a time limit and more questions then most in general can answer within of.