5 ms·
#1 in volume doesn't always mean #1 in profit. I'm guessing Apple is trying to grab hard onto the market segment that brings in the most profit, while Google i
by bane 16y ago
#1 in volume doesn't always mean #1 in profit.
I'm guessing Apple is trying to grab hard onto the market segment that brings in the most profit, while Google is going for the commodity, high volume, low margin option.
The good news is that both models can coexist in the same market. After all, Nintendo's strategy is a bit like Google's, while Microsoft and Sony's are more like Google's. Nintendo has been quite profitable for a very long time even when they didn't own the entire market.
- rbanffy 16y ago> Apple is trying to grab hard onto the market segment that brings in the most profit, while Google is going for the commodity, high volume, low margin option. Hardly. Google doesn't make phones.
- tesseract 16y agoIf they did, though, it would make sense. Apple's business model is to make money by selling hardware; Google's is to make money by selling advertising.
- rbanffy 16y ago> Google's is to make money by selling advertising. They also collect licensing fees when phone makers use the Android name, Google trademarks and Google's software in the phones. I assume their foray into mobile phones is to fragment the market and prevent any other player from gaining a dominant market share.
- trotsky 16y agoThey also collect licensing fees when phone makers use the Android name, Google trademarks and Google's software in the phones. Is that accurate? Everything I've seen has indicated that if anything money moves the other way - Google sharing revenue on platform ads (and possibly other services) with oems and carriers. I haven't seen anyone claim that oems pay licensing fees to google for google apps and trademarks - I believe they are use granted based on platform spec compliance. I assume their foray into mobile phones is to fragment the market and prevent any other player from gaining a dominant market share. While undoubtedly google doesn't want another player to dominate the market, I believe the primary goals for android were to increase global pageviews, drive mobile adoption, and to avoid large upfront costs of paying for placement as the default search engine.
- foob 16y agoFrom Dan Morrill on the Android Developer Blog (http://android-developers.blogspot.com/2009/09/note-on-google-apps-for-android.html http://android-developers.blogspot.com/2009/09/note-on-googl...): "With a high-quality open platform in hand, we then returned to our goal of making our services available on users’ phones. That’s why we developed Android apps for many of our services like YouTube, Gmail, Google Voice, and so on. These apps are Google’s way of benefiting from Android in the same way that any other developer can, but the apps are not part of the Android platform itself. We make some of these apps available to users of any Android-powered device via Android Market, and others are pre-installed on some phones through business deals." The phrase "pre-installed on some phones through business deals" is at least suggestive that Google is being paid for the inclusion of their apps on phones.
- patio11 16y agoI think rather the opposite: OEMs sell desktop real estate. You think Dell pays for antivirus? I think they get a fat fee upfront for even thinking of you, and then a per-conversion affiliate payout. This is similar to many mobile softwRe arrangements in the pre-iPhone world.
- rbanffy 16y ago> Is that accurate? I have no reason to believe otherwise, since some Android-based devices like the original Nook never use the name Android anywhere. However, I could not find any income statement that details their revenue sources by channel/product line.
- trotsky 16y agoTo qualify for Google branding and to use the Android trademark and ship with the android marketplace a manufacturer has to comply with the "Compatibility Definition Document" - a platform spec document that includes some software behavior and a number of hardware features. including high speed wireless data, an X MP camera, a compass, acelerometer, touch, a standard screen res, etc. The nook if memory serves lacks a camera at least so they didn't qualify. Compatibility Program overview: http://source.android.com/compatibility/overview.html http://source.android.com/compatibility/overview.html Note that this doesn't say you get access to all google apps like navigation - it does appear another agreement is needed for those - I just don't know if that is a pay for access by the oem or some other arrangement.
- calbear81 16y agoIt's also the app store which does over a billion in sales annually not to mention the revshare on subscription services that Apple requires.
- bane 16y agoGoogle "makes" advertising though, the more eyeballs it can get in front of, the better for its model.
- raganwald 16y agoExactly. Google has supplanted Microsoft in the OS business. If you remember, Microsoft's business model was to commoditize PCs. Microsoft won when Dell and HP raced each other to the bottom on margins. Now I see history repeating itself, only this time the handset makers have two people trying to squeeze them into commodity providers competing on price: (1) Google and (2) The Carriers.
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoHas anyone ever taken the time to explain why the apparently scary prospect of people "racing to the bottom" is bad for me as a consumer or member of society? The original usage was about states competing by offering better terms to corporations. These "better terms" were worse for the people living in the state because they got less tax income and less worker protection. But they are the vendors in that analogy, the customer/corporation was very happy with how things worked out. Am I really supposed to shed tears over a corporation's business model being a bit more like operating in a free market?
- raganwald 16y agoYour point is entirely orthogonal to my point, so I am quite comfortable that following your digression does not undermine my comment in any way. What I will say about Android handset makers racing each other to the bottom is that what is good for you as a consumer is when entire products compete against each other. The trouble with looking at handsets is that they aren't really whole and complete products. They need an OS/Ecosystem/Theme Park and they need a carrier's service to complete them. What is best for consumers is when there is competition for all the elements of the stack from top to bottom, either in packages (iOS on iPhone on AT&T vs. Android on Nokia on Sprint) or individually. I don't know how things will play out in the Android "space," but from what I've seen so far, the big nut to crack for consumers is the carriers, not the hardware and not the OS. When text messages are less than a penny each, I will know that the entire stack is competing in a way that is good for consumers.
- guelo 16y ago> #1 in volume doesn't always mean #1 in profit. Unless you're an Apple shareholder why does that matter? As a developer #1 in market share is a very significant milestone.
- bonch 16y ago> As a developer #1 in market share is a very significant milestone. Unless you're Android, which has significantly less apps than iOS and is getting bad press for its malware problems. Additionally, iOS runs on the iPad, so iPhone developers can universally target the #1 tablet in the world. Google makes very little off of Android. They've been following Apple's lead design-wise (look at images of what Android was going to look like before the iPhone came out). As a free operating system that carriers can exert full control over, it's no surprise that it's #1 in marketshare compared to a single phone on two carriers, but if that doesn't actually translate into profits for Google, developers for the platform, or innovation for the industry, does it really matter? The iPhone is still directing the smartphone industry and getting the positive press, and the iPad practically has no competitors to this day.
- kfje4wesdf 16y agoInteresting becuase it is becoming increasingly obvious that Android is aiming wide, yet their userbase are not as automatically app savvy or interested as Apple users.
- gregable 16y ago> Google makes very little off of Android http://www.businessinsider.com/android-revenue-2010-8 http://www.businessinsider.com/android-revenue-2010-8 Title: Google's Android Is Making Boatloads Of Money, Says Schmidt--Way More Than It Costs To Make
- ZeroGravitas 16y agoHere's an image of what Android was going to look like before the iPhone came out: https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/_1IECTAB2-to/TWV9IKxwQOI/AAAAAAAAAmQ/JPM8CJ3LIEk/s288/google-android.jpg https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/_1IECTAB2-to/TWV9IKxwQOI/A... And here's the Samsung Galaxy Pro that was just announced: http://www.eurodroid.com/2011/03/update-product-shot-of-the-samsung-galaxy-pro/ http://www.eurodroid.com/2011/03/update-product-shot-of-the-... It's remarkable the influence Apple has had.