4 ms·
The most shocking part of this article was the revelation that the original article was not retracted. The entire conclusion and data were entirely wrong, yet t
by kortilla 7y ago
The most shocking part of this article was the revelation that the original article was not retracted. The entire conclusion and data were entirely wrong, yet the paper still stands. That’s really damning for the journal at least and likely speaks to a pretty bad culture in the wider field.
Kudos to the author for doing the right thing, but the fact that there seems to be no way to remove a paper that is blatantly false because retractions are reserved for deliberate misconduct is horrifying. Not only does this setup long term fucked up incentives (no downside to fraud if you paint it as a whoopsie), but it also harms all work that had cited that work and anyone doing literature reviews not realizing the ground other papers were standing on has dissolved away.
- dwighttk 7y ago>The editor and publisher were understanding and ultimately opted not to retract the paper but to instead publish a revised version of the article, linked to from the original paper, with the results section updated to reflect the true (opposite) results. I don't see what the problem is.
- kortilla 7y agoThe problem is that the old copy is still floating around and by replacing it instead of retracting it, it’s not clear which papers are referencing the bullshit one and which ones are referencing the real results. Not retracting hid the turd from bibliometric tools that could have easily notifies you of poisoned papers.