5 ms·
There is no empirical evidence for the US lockdowns
- ColinWright 7y agoEarly in the piece, here is the critical sentence: > I do not find that lockdowns are a more effective way of handling coronavirus than well-done social-distancing measures. Properly done physical-distancing measures will accomplish everything needed. Lockdowns are not needed if people will observe proper, well-executed physical distancing. So why issue instructions for lockdowns? My guess is this: Without strict "by the book", precisely specified, overly prescriptive detailed instructions, many people don't properly practice effective physical distancing. The idea is that the lockdown gives an additional "margin of error" for enforcement and social disapproval to take effect. There are some real idiots out there, and the government guidelines/instructions have to take that into account when they consider enforcement and practice.
- danieltillett 7y agoThis basically boils down to the argument that we don’t need police and courts if we all just obey the law and look out for our fellow man. Anarchism has some junior high level intellectual appeal, but out in the real world...
- celticninja 7y agoit's better to have a lockdown now and graduate to social distancing afterwards. after initially slowing the advance of the infection, we are then better able to study it. if there was no lockdown then infections and deaths are higher and things like studying the actual data get kicked down the road. which makes planning harder to do. we already see that there are idiots out there who will ignore lockdown rules, please say vidiots would ignore social distancing rules but it will be harder to enforce those where is lockdown rules are easier to enforce