11 ms·
Google will require proof of identity from all advertisers
- Proven 7y agoCan't say it affects me in any way - don't advertise, don't see Google ads... But I sure hope this cuts into their revenue.
- dclusin 7y agoThis will probably be about as effective as requiring ID cards has been to combat underage drinking.
- xwdv 7y agoSo very.
- SilasX 7y agoExactly. It's a big fallacy to think, "this security measure can be circumvented by a sufficiently capable and motivated attacker, therefore it is pointless."
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoAnother huge aspect, and this is why EV certificates are not only a good thing, but should be forced on PKI, not deprecated out: It adds burden and expense to acting fraudulently which makes it more prohibitive to do at scale. If there's one thing to me that discredits security expertise, it's the suggestion that things like EV certs and other forms of KYC are wholly ineffective because it's technically possible to trick them. In turn, it makes efforts to police fraud more effective, because the cost each time a fraudulent actor's credentials are burned higher.
- nogabebop23 7y agoThis is actually a really good point for a different reason: if google can add verification that depends on other infrastructure/parties, this will shift the attack vector from just google to other players. So say they require some paperwork or organizational registration, now the badies focus on "how do we generate fake credentials at scale" - which means less work for google.
- tialaramex 7y agoNo EV is largely pointless because it relies on humans and it's fascinating how few people understand that. For every single HTTPS transaction (and there may be dozens involved in even fairly mundane seeming activities) the browser is able to compare the SAN dnsName (or rarely ipAddress) to the host named in the HTTPS URL. It does this unblinkingly every single time, and if it fails then (in the best case) the transaction just fails entirely or (in the less good legacy case) there's some sort of "Oops, something bad happened, don't trust this" behaviour. But whereas SAN dnsNames and ipAddresses are something a machine can compare to the host in a URL, the EV identity is something only humans have opinions about and humans don't want to make dozens of such decisions when they click on a funny video of a cat. Is it OK that this funny cat video is from "Alphabet Inc." ? How about "XXVI Holdings Inc." ? Why is that OK but "Funny Cat Videos Ltd." isn't? How about "You Tube" of Austin, Texas, is that OK? How do I know? More importantly why is it suddenly my problem when the computer was previously able to get this stuff right? One of the most obvious things to do if you suppose that well, any fool can get the DV certificate for realbank.example but that's fine because only the Real Bank can get an EV certificate for Real Bank and that'll protect you is this: Mallory gets an account with Real Bank and watches protocol flow. They don't care about most actions but are very interested in login timing. Mallory obtains one of these certs for realbank.example but for an organisation name they control like "Mallory Inc." Now Mallory MITMs a valuable customer of Real Bank. During login they passively pass back and forth every step until the POST where the customer's password and OTP code are supplied. For that POST Mallory interposes supplying that Mallory Inc. certificate. The browser has no idea what "Real Bank" is but it can see this is a realbank.example certificate, so that's fine, the password and OTP code are delivered to Mallory. Probably this works seamlessly, and Mallory steals the customer's money with no evidence of how it happened. BUT if the customer was really trying hard to obey this crazy "Check EV because that's secure" they will see this - but only when their page renders, which is after their password and OTP code were delivered to Mallory. They get to excitedly tell their bank that they've detected a successful attack - after it worked. If they're lucky the bank might even give them the money back, but probably not because it looks exactly like they're committing fraud.
- ocdtrekkie 7y ago"Relying on humans" is the only way real security is ever going to work. Because humans are the people using computers, and the people who mistype the site in their browser or click on a malicious Google ad at the top of the page that "looks right". Anything that doesn't depend on humans is just as usable by malicious actors as real ones. Let's Encrypt may be just as happy to issue a microsfht.com cert as a microsoft.com one: An EV cert is going to be a lot more challenging to achieve, and even if you get a EV cert for microsfht, it's going to cost a lot more effort, which you have to start over when your site gets banned and you need to spin up micoshft.com and a cert for it. Security based solely on automation will continue to fail and lead to exploit after exploit because it ignores the human factor, despite that being the primary place security breaks down. It's refreshing to see proof of identity requirements finally coming to ads, and hopefully it will lead to a change in understanding, that PKI is also useless without EV. The honest truth that people seem to fail to understand is that security doesn't scale. The more you scale, the worse your security is, and that will always continue to be true. The more manual, the more humans required in a process, the safer it will be.
- seibelj 7y agoThis is like “Know Your Customer” (KYC) rules required by banks and financial companies. So many online providers ask for it, and it’s so stupidly easy to bypass through stolen documents it’s meaningless. I’ve even seen customers setup booths where they pay people in slums for their documents and go through a “live” KYC in-app process to generate more accounts. Security Theater, just like everything.
- vmception 7y ago> I’ve even seen customers setup booths where they pay people in slums for their documents and here I am with my GPU's heating my apartment with Deep Fake scripts to pass Binance Fake-YC after buying FULLZ off of Empire when I could just be paying people in the tents outside of the ground floor apartments. I always felt like I was getting out of touch after the guy was passing out 'Elitest Tech Scum' collectible pins at Zeitgeist, but I thought it was just ironic until this very moment.
- perl4ever 7y agoWhat's your argument for why it's security theater in the context of banks? It would be an obvious self-serving thing to say, for anyone opposed to similar regulation in other industries, but is it true? Saying a system isn't perfect isn't the same as saying it has little effect overall. If the banking system wasn't well controlled, why would people complain so bitterly and frequently about the effect of sanctions?
- LanceH 7y agoThe government shouldn't lean on a company to throw barriers in the way of speech. I really don't care what people want to pay to say, even if it is the horrible "fake news" which some seem to think is a new invention. Why does anyone need to know who paid for all advertising?
- Dotnaught 7y ago> I really don't care But it's not just about you. Speech, however it gets categorized, affects people and influences society. You can still say what you want (to the extent allowed by ad platform rules and legal limits on commercial speech) but you should also be accountable for what you say.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoSays the guy whose boot is stamping on the human race.
- jliptzin 7y agoYea I kind of agree. The antidote to fake news should be an educated population, not banning fake news.
- blacksmith_tb 7y agoThat's an appealing image, but we can see which of the those is easier to legislate... my instinct is the populace will voluntarily educate themselves only if they can feel the negative effects of 'fake news' in their lives in the short term. Given that we haven't seen much of an uptick in educated discourse online, I would hazard a guess that hasn't happened yet.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoWe already have an educated population.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y ago
- tehjoker 7y agoThere's only one sure way to eliminate fraud in advertising: stop advertising. Google is attempting to make it more difficult for malefactors to use its systems, but this disregards the fact that advertising is not a socially beneficial activity and all advertising is an attempt to psychologically manipulate the public. Therefore, a harm reduction justification is insufficient as it presumes there is some benefit worth the harms being introduced. In fact, there is no benefit and Google is only reducing harm slightly.
- larrysalibra 7y ago> the fact that advertising is not a socially beneficial activity and all advertising is an attempt to psychologically manipulate the public That's not a fact, that's your opinion. Advertising is a form of communication and like most communication, the person originating the communication often has a goal or desired outcome in mind. That you or me might not like their goals or the message that they communicate doesn't mean that no one finds it valuable, nor does it mean that we should ban all communication.
- Nextgrid 7y agoTo be fair, when it comes to being valuable, criminals consider violence like armed robbery and murder valuable because it helps them achieve their goals, and yet we agree that those things are not a benefit to society and created laws to discourage and punish such acts.
- matz1 7y agoCertainly the criminals doesn't agree don't you think ? One side just happen to have more power to forced the other side to comply. There is no agreement. The more powerfull one get to decide what the law is.
- carapace 7y ago> Advertising is a form of communication and like most communication, the person originating the communication often has a goal or desired outcome in mind. So what? It's still "an attempt to psychologically manipulate the public". Advertising is adversarial, it's fundamentally bullshit. Leela : Didn't you have ads in the 21st century?" Fry : Well sure, but not in our dreams. Only on TV and radio, and in magazines, and movies, and at ball games... and on buses and milk cartons and t-shirts, and bananas and written on the sky. But not in dreams, no siree. How is that "a socially beneficial activity"?
- number6 7y agoThis wasn't the case already? I could have run a controversial ad to ruin someone's name?
- cm2187 7y agoOr spread malware through embedded ads
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoSearch ads have been the canonical leading way my clients have ever seen malware. I find Google search ads less regulated and less filtered than spam emails. I'm really glad they're finally doing this, but it still feels way too irresponsibly late considering the amount of damage they've caused.
- dx034 7y agoAnd Google is still one of the least affected markets. If you look at other ad marketplaces, they often tend to have larger amounts of malware spread through their system. Mostly because Google at least has somewhat decent detection algorithms and a large enough team that can take down large scale malware 24x7.
- adam1210 7y agoThis is a massive problem in my experience; even if I report the ads spreading malware to Google they don't ever take them down.
- ggggtez 7y agoYou could have. And that would have been a crime. But contrary to popular opinion, tech companies are not a branch of the police force. So they have no obligation to help the police prosecute people without a warrant.
- slg 7y ago>So they have no legal obligation to help the police prosecute people without a warrant. FTFY. They may not have a legal obligation to help prevent or prosecute crimes, but there is definitely a moral obligation to not knowingly allow your product to become an easy accessory to crime. Lots of tech companies abdicate that moral responsibility.
- zozbot234 7y agoPreviously discussed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22955606 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22955606
- paulpauper 7y ago>The names of the companies or people behind ads, as well as their countries of origin, will begin appearing on Google ads this summer, starting with several thousand advertisers a month in the United States before expanding worldwide. The measure, which could take years to implement, is designed as a defense against businesses and individuals who misrepresent themselves in paid online promotions, Google said. lol so a tiny crypto exchange can req. ID docs but a huge trillion dollar company will take years>
- katmannthree 7y agoA tiny crypto exchange is probably in a position where they can easily get existing employees to manually verify the documents without a significant impact on their business. In addition to needing to verify orders of magnitude more entities, google likely has many layers of both human and technical abstraction to deal with.
- Klinky 7y agoHow was this not already a thing? How does Google not already have a billing address on file for all the advertisers they're accepting money from? It seems like this shouldn't have ever been "voluntary information".
- thebean11 7y agoHaving a billing address is a far cry from identify verification
- Klinky 7y agoIf you really don't trust the the information the person has provided to give you money you probably should not be accepting their money.
- nogabebop23 7y agoTHey have a payment method as well which is definitely identity verification. Don't expect this to filter everyone hiding behind fronts and shell orgs, but it's a step towards that.
- Igelau 7y agoPrediction: It'll be surprisingly difficult for Mom and Pop to provide sufficient proof of identity and surprisingly easy for mega corporations to do so. There will be a way to report suspected abusers that heavily skews in this direction. It'll basically be like IP enforcement on YouTube.
- coffeefirst 7y agoNot likely, but the problem requires context that Google isn't going to share. In the past few years we've seen bad actors basically automate their process. They expect to be banned. They spin up an account, run scams and malware, get blacklisted, rinse and repeat with a new domain, account, and just enough changes to beat the automated filters within an hour later. What this does is add a ton of friction to that game. It doesn't even have to be perfect to make a huge difference, it just needs to be difficult to rotate at scale.
- qwertox 7y agoGood time to buy some Facebook stock then.
- mediascreen 7y agoEvery time I sign up for a service using our company card, with our company address and company email I feel like I'm pretty open about who the buyer is. Wouldn't a some kind of certified bank card be an even better proof of corporate identity than a copy of someones ID? IDs needs to be verified against articles of incorporation. For larger companies it will definitely be a hassle to get the CFO to submit their proof of identity for a purchase that is normally delegated way down in the organisation.
- lonelappde 7y agoIt's covered in the announcement. There's no need for the CFO to get involved. https://www.blog.google/products/ads/advertiser-identity-verification-for-transparency/ https://www.blog.google/products/ads/advertiser-identity-ver...
- foepys 7y agoIs it irrational to be angry that Google got their own .google TLD and then decides to put "www" in front of its second level domain?
- titanomachy 7y agoSeems to redirect to blog.google
- foepys 7y agoNo, Chrome just hides the "www." part, not sure about Firefox.
- mediascreen 7y agoThe announcement provides a short overview, there is a help page that describes the process in more detail [0]. It' only for american companies at this time, but I imagine that it won't get less complicated when it's rolled out for 180 countries with different corporate and legal systems... The document states that you have to show that you are an authorized representative of the company. I am not that familiar with US law, but in many countries that means one of the signatories of the company, usually someone like the CEO or the CFO. My point is that it makes sense that you are able to show that you have the right to act on the company's behalf in this matter. I just think that since the company trusts you with it's credit card and there already are systems in place to authorize expenditures, it would be logical to tie the proof that you represent the company to the card in this case. [0] https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/9703665#700 https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/9703665#700
- buboard 7y agoCongratulations, you just created a secondary market
- qwerty456127 7y agoI bet this isn't going to help. Scams and misleading ads will persist.
- throwaway122378 7y agoAdd your name, address, signature, hair/eye color, picture, and dob to Google’s database. When will this stop
- foo7483838 7y agoThis is Google shifting legal responsibility from itself so it can run political ads without legal actions etc.
- guug 7y agoHow will google verify this proof of identity?
- justlexi93 7y agoThe only ads they give me are either obvious scam or literally the least thing I want. I presume that I'm kinda good at hiding my personal data, but I'm not THAT good Google.
- habanany 7y agoHow do we know google won’t be unfairly arbitrary by giving a pass to those that don’t meet the requirements ? Maybe google would have to show evidence that they did proceeded the right way