2 ms·
> Lack of evidence? Again, they're holding VPLs to a higher standard. When a language like Ruby appeared, nobody asked for proof. Simply creating something that
by lmm 7y ago
> Lack of evidence? Again, they're holding VPLs to a higher standard. When a language like Ruby appeared, nobody asked for proof. Simply creating something that some programmers liked was sufficient.
If there was a visual programming language with anywhere near the popularity of Ruby, I'd be willing to consider that maybe the idea has some merit.
- dkersten 7y agoI don’t know how many people use Ruby, its certainly not as popular as it was during the Rails hype, so its hard to day, and I don’t have numbers for the visual languages either, but Unreal Engine’s Blueprints has a lot of users. Max/MSP does too, and apparently a lot of artists use tools like Substance Designer to create visual materials and those tools have visual programming too. EDIT: Media Molecules’ Dreams has a lot of users using its visual language to implement game logic! It sold about 8.5 million copies. Obviously not all people who bought it are using its visual language, but I imagine a very large percentage have at least tinkered a bit. I doubt Dreams would be as popular if it required textual programming.
- DonHopkins 7y agoExcel. I could turn your argument around: If Ruby were anywhere near as popular, widely used, and successful as Excel, I'd be willing to consider that maybe the idea that Ruby is a viable programming language has some merit. But I won't, because whether or not something is a visual programming language isn't up to a popularity contest. Can you come up with a plausible definition of visual programming languages that excludes Excel, without being so hopelessly contrived and gerrymandered that it also arbitrarily excludes other visual programming languages?
- lmm 7y ago> I could turn your argument around: If Ruby were anywhere near as popular, widely used, and successful as Excel, I'd be willing to consider that maybe the idea that Ruby is a viable programming language has some merit. How is Excel, as widely used, a programming language? Excel sheets in their widely used form are not instructions or behaviour; you can't run them, only manually edit them. Perhaps there is a way to turn Excel sheets into programs, but I highly doubt such a way of using Excel would be more popular than Ruby. > Can you come up with a plausible definition of visual programming languages that excludes Excel, without being so hopelessly contrived and gerrymandered that it also arbitrarily excludes other visual programming languages? I'd say a visual programming language is a programming language for which the primary way of making changes to the program is visual. Even if we were to consider Excel a programming language, the primary way in which people make changes to Excel sheets - especially advanced users who are doing more programming-like things - is by editing textual formulae, IME.
- DonHopkins 7y agoAre we talking about the same "Excel"? I mean Microsoft Excel, in case there's something else called Excel that I haven't heard of. Microsoft Excel spreadsheets certainly do contain instructions and behavior. That's the whole point of spreadsheets, that distinguish them from plain CSV files! They continuously run every time you make any change to them. And Excel is several orders of magnitude more popular and successful than Ruby: there is no comparison. Excel even supports "Programming by Demonstration" through its macro recorder. Programming by Demonstration happens to be one of Brad Myer's favorite areas of research! Brad wrote the 1989 paper about visual programming that we're discussing, and Visual Programming, Programming by Demonstration, and Programming by Example are closely interrelated topics that he has done a lot of work with and written a lot about. I think it's important to consider some of his and other people's more recent work, before extrapolating on the technological limitations that he wrote about in 1989, without taking into account 31 years of progress, research, and development. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brad_A._Myers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brad_A._Myers "Myers is a leading researcher in the field of programming by demonstration and created the Garnet and Amulet toolkits." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Programming_by_demonstration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Programming_by_demonstration "In computer science, programming by demonstration (PbD) is an end-user development technique for teaching a computer or a robot new behaviors by demonstrating the task to transfer directly instead of programming it through machine commands." Watch What I Do: Programming by Demonstration. Edited by Allen Cypher, Daniel Conrad Halbert, David Kurlander, Henry Lieberman, David Maulsby, Brad A. Myers, and Alan Turransky. https://archive.org/details/watchwhatido00alle https://archive.org/details/watchwhatido00alle http://acypher.com/wwid http://acypher.com/wwid Watch What I Do: Foreword by Alan Kay http://acypher.com/wwid/FrontMatter/ http://acypher.com/wwid/FrontMatter/ >I don't know who first made the parallel between programming a computer and using a tool, but it was certainly implicit in Jack Licklider's thoughts about "man-machine symbiosis" as he set up the ARPA IPTO research projects in the early sixties. In 1962, Ivan Sutherland's Sketchpad became the exemplar to this day for what interactive computing should be like--including having the end-user be able to reshape the tool. [...] Microsoft Excel Macro Programming History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Excel#Macro_programming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Excel#Macro_programm... "History: From its first version Excel supported end-user programming of macros (automation of repetitive tasks) and user-defined functions (extension of Excel's built-in function library). In early versions of Excel, these programs were written in a macro language whose statements had formula syntax and resided in the cells of special-purpose macro sheets (stored with file extension .XLM in Windows.) XLM was the default macro language for Excel through Excel 4.0. Beginning with version 5.0 Excel recorded macros in VBA by default but with version 5.0 XLM recording was still allowed as an option. After version 5.0 that option was discontinued. All versions of Excel, including Excel 2010 are capable of running an XLM macro, though Microsoft discourages their use." >I'd say a visual programming language is a programming language for which the primary way of making changes to the program is visual. Your arbitrarily gerrymandered definition turns C++ into a visual programming language, which it clearly is not. So how is making changes to a C++ program in VI or Emacs not visual, then? People use visual editors to make changes to textual C++ programs all the time. The "V" in "VI" STANDS FOR "Visual", because it is the "visual mode" of the line editor called ex. But the actual structure and syntax of a C++ program that you edit in VI is simply a one-dimensional stream of characters, not a two-dimensional grid of interconnected objects, values, graphical attributes, and formulas, with relative and absolute two-dimensional references, like a spreadsheet. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vi >The original code for vi was written by Bill Joy in 1976, as the visual mode for a line editor called ex that Joy had written with Chuck Haley.[3] Bill Joy's ex 1.1 was released as part of the first Berkeley Software Distribution (BSD) Unix release in March 1978. It was not until version 2.0 of ex, released as part of Second BSD in May 1979 that the editor was installed under the name "vi" (which took users straight into ex's visual mode),[4] and the name by which it is known today. Some current implementations of vi can trace their source code ancestry to Bill Joy; others are completely new, largely compatible reimplementations. >The name "vi" is derived from the shortest unambiguous abbreviation for the ex command visual, which switches the ex line editor to visual mode. The name is pronounced /ˈviːˈaɪ/ (the English letters v and i).[5][6]