5 ms·
I don't know if one can blame the drop in business on the lockdown. Even if the furniture store were open, I doubt a lot of people would see that as a spending
by MattGaiser 7y ago
I don't know if one can blame the drop in business on the lockdown. Even if the furniture store were open, I doubt a lot of people would see that as a spending priority at this time.
Even if they opened, would it really help them?
- jhwang5 7y agoNo. By then, they'd be accustomed to buying furniture off Amazon /s.
- MattGaiser 7y agoWell, my grandmother is getting into Wayfair, so maybe not sarcasm. My point is more whether asking whether any significant number of people are buying furniture at all?
- JoshTriplett 7y agoSome people are finding themselves suddenly in need of home-office furniture. But yes, furniture does seem like the kind of purchase that will get deferred when money is tighter.
- ghaff 7y agoFor me, it's not even the money right now. I have a few purchase/service types of things that I should take care of one of these days but aren't urgent. So I'm holding off on things that would involve trips to stores (if they're even open), home delivery, etc. I'm not totally avoiding leaving the house, but I'm also holding off on things that can't be handled by a quick run into a store at off hours.
- nrb 7y agoMany people are spending lots of time at home, enough to realize they aren't totally happy with their furnishings, and are available to accept deliveries. I would imagine the answer to that is yes.
- davidf560 7y agoCertainly business would be way down, but they'd at least get to try to save their own business. Right now they don't stand a chance as it's entirely out of their control. Given the decline in business, a small furniture store probably wouldn't have a lot of issues with customers maintaining distance. Most furniture stores are not crowded even in normal times. This would probably be true for many other types of retail stores as well. It's not zero risk of course, but nothing in life ever is. Perhaps some shoppers would make a point of shopping to help out, or just aren't that concerned and want to get out, or want to furnish their new house/apartment that they've been in for the past 6 weeks completely empty. More people are starting to wonder if there's a viable option between "full lockdown, groceries only" and "free-for-all". Since some states are relaxing restrictions I guess we'll start to find out.
- MattGaiser 7y ago> but they'd at least get to try to save their own business. Right now they don't stand a chance as it's entirely out of their control. True. They are powerless over their fate at the moment and they can't even begin to move online. They probably can re-open. The challenge is just going to be on drawing the line. Furniture is ok, but what about Build A Bear or a mattress store?
- cm2187 7y agoI have seen various reports that discretionary spending online has sunk massively, so not sure that would help. The perspective of a big economic crisis (and job loss) has collapsed the demand. And if your business is a bar...
- CydeWeys 7y agoThey still have a chance to try to do some business: Start an online store. But yes, overall it's going to be very hard for them, as it is for many others, because furniture shopping was always going to plummet during a global pandemic no matter what. There's no plausible scenario of social distancing or no social distancing under which they come out OK. They may have shuttered anyway even if they hadn't been forced to simply because no customers were coming through and it didn't make sense to remain open. Here in NYC a lot of restaurants made the decision to shutter entirely in advance of the official orders, because business had already plummeted substantially to the point that they were losing money no matter what.
- acituan 7y agoExactly this. A new essential & non-essential dichotomy is here regardless of lockdowns. It turned out that most consumption wasn't as essential, and market wasn't all powerful. They have been powerless against most of the fundamental problems the virus created. And it turned out that public health, social security and a competent state was more essential than we thought.
- bedhead 7y agoBut demand for restored furniture wouldn't have imploded without the lockdowns - it's all connected. The government lockdowns (among other things) have whipped people into such a frenzy that you're right, demand is collapsing on its own out of paranoia. I have numerous friends - intelligent people - who genuinely think this is the bubonic plague and if they get it, their whole family is like instantly dead. This was all a major and obvious side effect from the sweeping lockdowns that few in government considered.
- jessaustin 7y ago...few in government considered. This is a commonly-referenced trope, but it is seldom true. Even if those in government really were as dumb as they pretend, the lobbyists and spooks whose orders they follow are not. The normal economy has been destroyed and vast resources have been given to cronies of the Fed in order to produce the sort of nation we'll be suffering in the decade to come.
- MattGaiser 7y agoI saw plenty of projections of what a lockdown would cost. Granted, I am tied to the financial sector, but I'm sure governments can get the same JP Morgan or Bank of Canada estimates I can.
- jessaustin 7y agoThey only need semi-plausible deniability. Just as they called a voice vote with straight faces, they'll be able to feign surprise at all the predictable results of that vote.
- mindslight 7y agoYou're basically complaining that the government helped knock consumers out of their usual state of detached cognitive dissonance.