6 ms·
the covid-19 situation I think really exposes how mad it is that as a society it's normal if not encouraged to live on debt or one or two paychecks away from be
by Barrin92 7y ago
the covid-19 situation I think really exposes how mad it is that as a society it's normal if not encouraged to live on debt or one or two paychecks away from being broke. Of course, a lot of people don't make enough to even save much more, but even among more affluent people in particular in the US it seems common to live a lifestyle that just about only works if you're at 100% income.
Just for my own peace of mind, I started saving enough to be without work for a year or so, use a debit card instead of a credit card and rent. Here in Germany, this is more common than in other places, but still, I wouldn't even want to live with constant debt on my shoulders.
- jhwang5 7y agoYou don't realize that this economy - levered to the hilt - NEEDS the consumer to spend money they don't have to keep it going. If the American consumer started developing financial discipline starting tomorrow, that's incredibly bearish for stocks. (Of course, that's probably a good thing for the long run)
- MattGaiser 7y agoExcept that savings for tomorrow would probably end up in the stock market. Otherwise inflation kills them. So I would be interested to know would happen here.
- ceejayoz 7y agoInflation doesn’t “kill”. You lose a percent or two a year. Put the savings in a no-penalty CD for emergencies and even that gets better.
- karatestomp 7y ago> Except that savings for tomorrow would probably end up in the stock market. For far lower returns. With reduced demand, there's not much for that extra money to do. To the extent investment drives growth it's when it goes into innovation (R&D) or if businesses have demand but are capital constrained (and I suspect even that's more like speeding up than creating growth, exactly—you just get 5% growth now instead of 2.5% over two years, or whatever). Sure maybe you could spend it on advertising and marketing but all that can do is get us back to "people spend too much".
- bgorman 7y agoHow does one draw the line between necessary marketing/sales expenses and unnecessary ones? Even some of the most "innovative" companies like Apple spend billions on advertising. I don't have an MBA but it seems pretty much impossible to sell new products without an advertising budget.
- karatestomp 7y agoRight but if the premise is “there will be lots of investment because people are spending less and saving more” then all that invested money can’t go into marketing or advertising without getting right back to a low-savings society, unless that spending is ineffective. So that leaves R&D I guess since there’s not much else for that extra money to do. Plus lower returns on equities.
- brewdad 7y agoAs the stock market becomes "overvalued" some investors pull their money out and invest in other "undervalued" assets. Real estate has been a major asset of choice over the past decade. Perhaps that will continue or some new asset will come into vogue.
- nostromo 7y agoUS consumers really aren't so bad. Savings rates have been inching up ever since bottoming out around 2005. https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/personal-savings https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/personal-savings
- jhwang5 7y agoNow try 1) plotting that against household debt, 2) and against other countries.
- vonmoltke 7y agoHousehold savings (latest): https://data.oecd.org/chart/5VU5 https://data.oecd.org/chart/5VU5 Household debt (latest): https://data.oecd.org/chart/5VU6 https://data.oecd.org/chart/5VU6 You can play with the charts to plot trends for as long as the OECD have data for each value. The position of the US isn't great, but it isn't terrible either.
- jhwang5 7y agoThese are aggregate metrics - in a country like the US that's in top 5 in terms of income gini-coefficient, I suspect medians will paint a very different picture.
- rv-de 7y agoIt's like a lemon being squeezed harder and harder. As long as people have some money they can spend - no matter where the money is actually coming from - our economy will try to incentivize it and lure consumers into consuming. That's why I find the idea of this system collapsing frankly quite amusing. Actually I hope for a complete break down of our economy. It's a perverted monster which deserves to go down.
- dehrmann 7y ago> If the American consumer started developing financial discipline starting tomorrow...that's probably a good thing for the long run Don't be so sure. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_thrift https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_thrift
- jhwang5 7y agoI think discipline != penny pinching
- kirstenbirgit 7y agoIt's just a reflection on hard it is to survive in USA. For most people, saving up that much money is a total luxury. Plus, having no real safety net from the government when you get sick or lose your job (like we do in EU) just makes it much worse.
- subhobroto 7y ago> having no real safety net from the government WHO pays for that? Is there a free lunch?
- wonderwonder 7y agoI'd be willing to contribute towards it. In fact, feel free to take 80% of the funds I put towards the military into the safety net. In addition, take all of the tax money they take from me and give to fossil fuels as well and put it toward it. Then if you want to create a universal health care, feel free to take my monthly contributions that I make towards health insurance. In addition, who is paying for the trillions we are pumping into boeing and the airlines right now. We always have money for war and well connected companies but never have enough funding for basic human decency.
- luckylion 7y ago80% of the military budget won't cut it though. Social safety nets cost a lot of money. Yes, the US spends ridiculous amounts on the military (though on the other hand: that military is what gives them global dominance, which also is worth a lot of money), but just cutting that back won't give you a European style safety net. You'll have to increase taxes by a lot for everyone making more than the median, increase sales tax etc, essentially: pay more, not just reshuffle what you pay now.
- wonderwonder 7y agoThat's fine, increase taxes. Universal health care would also lead to greater bargaining power in regards to drugs, drastically reducing cost. Maybe insulin wont cost 10 times in the US what it costs in other developed nations. I already pay a large portion of my check towards health insurance, so does my employer. Route those funds towards Universal Healthcare. We can just call them taxes. This should not really be an argument. We are discussing whether it is appropriate for us to pay a bit more on taxes or to allow people to die. I fall into the more taxes side of the debate. I have good health insurance right now. Maybe a little TMI so be warned. I took my 7 year old kid to get something looked at a little over a year ago. He was experiencing burning when he urinated. They measured the flow of his urine and took a look at his genitals. Whole thing took ~15 minutes. I am still getting bills for it. Turns out he just needed to go to the bathroom more. Every couple months I get another bill for ~$40 for some other doctor or company. Its crazy. The whole system is designed to bleed people.
- jorblumesea 7y agoWhile holding debt encouraged, I would argue the lack of a progressive social system is why people need to dip into credit cards at the rate they're doing. In a country where a medical bill can bankrupt you or you need to work x3 min wage jobs to get by, it's hardly surprising that it's the case. Saving up $500 / month is out of reach for a significant number of Americans. So debt is the only way to do basic things such as car repairs or handle emergency expenses. You can even see this with the COVID response, where European countries are paying 80% of salaries, whereas in the US you get a flat $1200 check, once. The entire system is just skewed towards the wealthy.
- luckylion 7y agoEverybody got $1200 though, and those that are laid off or furloughed get federal assistance as well if I understand correctly. Those 80% you read is for those furloughed in Europe, but nobody (at least here in Germany) just got "free money to stimulate the economy". And the so called Kurzarbeitergeld (literally short worker money) is part of the unemployment insurance which is about 2.5% of gross income (half is directly deducted and paid by the employer, half is paid by the employee). There's no charity state here. Just pay for insurance, you can have that as well.
- soared 7y agoI don’t think it’s mad. We are just properly leveraged and operating with an acceptable amount of risk. Someone who leverages credit/debt and has proper but not huge (1 year) safety nets will be far better off over their life than someone who doesn’t leverage credit and has large or no savings. It’s the same as choosing invests - risk (stocks) is better than low risk (bonds) for most people. If you can tolerate risk you should if you want more returns.
- 0xff00ffee 7y ago> We are just properly leveraged and operating with an acceptable amount of risk. I think that's OP's point. Every word in this sentence is subjective. Throwing around concepts like leverage debt and risk exposure is a way only a mid/well-off person would frame the discussion. For the other 80% of the US, this statement is madness.
- soared 7y agoThat is fair. Good perspective check.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago>Someone who leverages credit/debt and has proper but not huge (1 year) safety nets will be far better off over their life than someone who doesn’t leverage credit and has large or no savings. This is only be true because the US government keeps borrowing from the future to inflate today. But I agree, you don’t bet against the house, and the house is dead set on making sure asset values stay high.
- subhobroto 7y ago> use a debit card instead of a credit card and rent This only helps those who cannot read or write spreadsheets, don't understand cashflow or otherwise are not aware of finance 101. Credit is a tool and knowing and putting leverage to use is critical to success in life. I save an average of 5% and sometimes upto 25% of my expenses through the judicious use of credit card rewards and promotions. Credit card companies are willing to take losses to have me as a customer and sign me up. > how mad it is that as a society it's normal if not encouraged to live on debt or one or two paychecks away from being broke This is a design parameter and not a coincidence. A majority of current work is busy work - if the people doing it had some savings, they would stop doing that busy work. The employer knows it, the employee knows it and they continue to do it. Encouraging "money in, money out" keeps the hamster wheel rolling and the economy pumping money through the system.
- jessaustin 7y agoCredit card companies are willing to take losses to have me as a customer and sign me up. No, they are desperate to pretend they've shored up a failing business model, and so they must constantly lure in more potential victims. You are temporarily subsidized by these schemes, but don't come crying to us when you end up behind the curve in confusing and changing credit terms. I agree with your claims about busy work and hamster wheels.
- tialaramex 7y agoIn the US a significant fraction of the wealth transfer from the poor via credit happens with these cards. The EU set a maximum limit for interchange fees, you'll notice such "amazing" reward cards do not exist there. In the US what happens is the card company says to Bob's Hardware, you must accept all our cards or you can't accept any cards, and our "Premium Reward" card has 7% interchange fee so when Jimmy presents his "Premium Reward" card for a $1000 purchase, the card company takes $70 of that. Jimmy gets $50 and he think he's a genius for having this card. The hardware store needs to raise prices for all customers to allow for people like Jimmy. So when Sarah, whose crappy job barely is enough to live on buys a product that would be $500 the store charges $540. Sarah's card only has an interchange fee of $10 and Sarah gets none of that, but the shop owner is legally prohibited from charging Jimmy more than Sarah and they're legally prohibited from refusing Jimmy's card unless they also refuse Sarah's.
- christiansakai 7y agoCame from a third world country to here USA, I was really surprised that a lot of people are living paycheck to paycheck and debt is encouraged, even among people who are middle class. In my 3rd world country, we always are encouraged to save and live beneath our means. But then I guess that's why USA economy is better than my 3rd world country's economy because the money revolves quickly?
- m3kw9 7y agoPartly but there are 100s if moving parts that make USA as big as it is. You also have to factor in their history of events that got them here
- dehrmann 7y agoThere's this thing that people have finally been talking about--slack in supply chains. It's basically the same idea as people living paycheck-to-paycheck. 95% of the time, it's much more efficient to run that way because inventory isn't free. The problem is there's no buffer against supply chain disruptions. Companies are always going to try to squeeze out those inefficiencies. This is a place markets will fail, so it's somewhere for governments to step in. Maybe that means government stockpiles, maybe it means governments pay companies to have excess inventory of certain critical products. It's the same for personal finances. It's actually inefficient for people to save for a rainy day because everyone has a rainy day fund when only 5% of people need it in a given year. This is where you want to have a strong social safety net so that people can spend. I don't think the situation's "mad," it's just that the US has a weak social safety net and people are encouraged to spend.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gruez 7y ago> It's the same for personal finances. It's actually inefficient for people to save for a rainy day because everyone has a rainy day fund when only 5% of people need it in a given year. I get why it’d be inefficient to store inventory, but why is it inefficient to save? You get paid for it and you’d want to have money lying around anyways for retirement.
- dehrmann 7y agoRetirement is probably the best example. If you have to save for retirement (so no SSI), you need to plan for your 95th (or 99th?) percentile life expectancy/spend rather than your mean expenses. Since retirement is about doing what you want and not just working for money, that means you have to work extra years so that on the off chance you make it to 100, you still have money.
- tly_alex 7y agoLiving pay check to pay check is considered risky in a lot of country, but due to the high available credits from credit card or personal loads, ppl in US don't feel like the need of saving. This pandemic could be the start of more saving.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThis makes me wonder what the differences are in various countries that help skew those numbers one way or the other. I know in the US, how much debt you have has zero bearing on your ability to qualify for welfare programs, but savings can negatively impact your ability to qualify. So owing less doesn't qualify you for more aid, but having too much savings can screw you out of benefits in an emergency situation. Some countries have programs that provide health benefits just because you exist. In the US, a lot of our benefits programs are "needs based," which means you have to qualify for aid and one of those qualifications is that you don't have savings because as little as $2000 in the bank can disqualify you. I don't think it's as one dimensional as the above comment seems to suggest. But I bet there are inherent incentives in the US to not bother to save for various reasons. It would be interesting to see that investigated in earnest.
- tly_alex 7y agoInteresting. I didn't know the US aid depends on the saving. How does govvernment know how much saving each person has? There's no formal process to report savings. On the other hand, the tax reporting would include annual income, which I thought is how most of the aid looks at. For example, the latest $1200 won't distributed to ppl with high income.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe $1200 stimulus check is something of an aberration. You typically need to apply for things like food stamps, Section 8 housing or Medicaid (our government health insurance for the poor). When you apply, you basically swear this is true to the best of knowledge and if it isn't you can be accused of fraud and potentially charged with criminal activity, or just have the money taken back in some cases. (My knowledge of the system is limited, but I was on food stamps for a while. Having something like $2000 in savings can disqualify you, iirc.)