3 ms·
> Unfortunately, in the middle of a pandemic, that's not going to happen with enough speed to prevent a lot of people dying. How are you sure that this method
by gus_massa 7y ago
> Unfortunately, in the middle of a pandemic, that's not going to happen with enough speed to prevent a lot of people dying.
How are you sure that this method is not worse than the ventilator method and will kill even more people during the pandemic?
How many death did they get with this method? How many death would they had got with the ventilator method?
- wbl 7y agoVentilators do lots of damage. If this gets the O2 up it's better since natural breathing doesn't break lung tissue.
- caymanjim 7y ago90% of people on ventilators die. It's hard to do much worse. And with numbers like that, I think it's perfectly ethical to try anything reasonable.
- gus_massa 7y agoWhat is the original source of the 90%? Is it from this article: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2765184 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2765184 From the article: > The study included all sequentially hospitalized patients between March 1, 2020, and April 4, 2020, inclusive of these dates. > As of April 4, 2020, for patients requiring mechanical ventilation (n = 1151, 20.2%), 38 (3.3%) were discharged alive, 282 (24.5%) died, and 831 (72.2%) remained in hospital. If you ignore the 831 patients that were still in the hospital, and consider only the 38 that survived and the 282 that died, you get 282/(282+38)=88%. It is a very short time. What are the odds for people that survive more than 4 days in the hospital? Did the team this post get the better results using the same accounting method? Did they apply this method only to the people that would need a ventilator or to more people because it is cheaper and easier to setup and maintain? (IIUC they used ventilator for the worse cases anyway.) > And with numbers like that, I think it's perfectly ethical to try anything reasonable. Do you want the best possible treatment to each patient, or you prefer that each doctor tries his/her pet theory in production?
- ineedasername 7y agoThis is "decision making under conditions of uncertainty." [0] It's not that your questions are bad, it's that in practice medical professionals have to operate without answers to them. Doing so involves communication with peers about their own observations of what may work better/worse, such as in this article. Double-blind randomized trials are not the only source of actionable information: Case studies also form a significant pillar of knowledge, especially pending results from more systematic studies. [0] https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4757-2068-6_3 https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4757-2068-6_...
- gus_massa 7y agoOne of the lesson of the physics lab is that unless you have calibrated very carefully all the equipment and experimental setup, you can't mix the measurements of one day with the measurements of another day. For example one day we have very weird results trying to compare two measurements of the same day about something related with the speed of sound. After a lot of time trying to understand the problem we notice that one measurement was from 9am when the temperature was like 10°C(50°F) and the other was from 1pm when the temperature was like 25°C(77°F). The following days we tried to take all the measurements as close as possible. The same applies to benchmarks in computers. A few days ago I got an improvement for a program that reduced the runtime from 85s to 59s. Until I noticed that one was with the notebook plugged in an the other with the batteries. I tried again both with the notebook plugged in and the improvement was only from 65s to 59s. Still a nice improvement but not fantastic. Quoting again part of the original comment I'm repliying > Learning is not the same as science, and we need randomized trials to actually be sure of anything. Unfortunately, in the middle of a pandemic, that's not going to happen with enough speed to prevent a lot of people dying. The perfect can be the enemy of the good enough. Without a randomized control group it is very difficult to be sure if a small improvement of the survival rate is real. So you can't learn if the new method or the old method is better.
- ineedasername 7y agoYes, absolutely correct. We just don't always have time to wait: Doctors must take action now. Knowing a majority of people that end up ventilators will die means the balance of risk weighs at least a little more heavily towards novel treatments than in less critical cases. Case studies of those attempts are exactly the kind of data points that can provide a great deal of information and hypothesis generation for more systematic studies.