8 ms·
Odroid-C4
- tra3 7y agoIs this an exact clone? Why is it cheaper than a rpi?
- beagle3 7y agoAbilities are comparable but it is not compatible (other than using the same CPU architecture, but not e.g. the same GPU family) and definitely not a clone.
- ashtonkem 7y agoIt also appears to be targeted more at micro-server work than the RPI is. The lack of a wifi chip wouldn’t be a factor for me, my RPI lives near ethernet cords, but would almost certainly be an issue for a lot of RPI uses.
- JamesSwift 7y agoJust scanning the listing, it looks like it lacks: - wifi - bluetooth - 1 HDMI port (pi4 has 2 ports, this has 1)
- Koshkin 7y agoNot a clone but a direct competitor.
- eropple 7y agoIt's not an exact clone, and has some nice features: - hardware 1080p60 h264 encoding (the RPi4 is limited to 1080p30 encode) - I know the C4 supports VP9 decoding at 4K60, but I'm not sure that the RPi4 does? - Cortex A55 over an A72; in general usage you're likely to see the A72 beat out by the A55, though it's going to be close enough that you may not care I can see using one of these, for example, to build a much cheaper homebrew NewTek Spark[0], assuming I can get its hardware encode to play nicely. (It doesn't compete with the Spark Plus, which does 4K60, but for my purposes, 1080p60 is sufficient.) [0] - https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1348898-REG/newtek_fg_001775_r001_connect_spark_hdmi.html https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1348898-REG/newtek_fg...
- duskwuff 7y agoNo. It's a similar form factor and uses a compatible GPIO pinout, but the hardware is completely different -- the Raspberry Pi uses a Broadcom SoC; the Odroid-C4 uses an Amlogic part.
- adrian_b 7y agoLike most other ODROID boards, less components are included in the base price, but everything that you might want is available as add-on accessories. For example 4 GB DRAM are soldered, so they are included in the $50, but the eMMC flash memory is on a socket, so you can choose any size between 8 GB and 128 GB, depending on how much you want to pay, or you may choose no eMMC and use just a microSD card. WiFi and Bluetooth are available as very cheap USB devices. I actually prefer that ODROID-C4 includes a 4-port USB 3.0 hub, which RPI 4 lacks, instead of including WiFi in the base configuration, because I always need as many fast USB ports as possible, but I do not always need WiFi. For about $100, you can buy an ODROID-C4 with 4 GB DRAM, 64 GB eMMC, case, power supply and adapters for writing the eMMC on another computer and for the serial console. For a similar configuration with RPI 4, you must pay $55 for the 4 GB variant and then you must buy a 64 GB microSD card, which will be much slower than the ODROID eMMC and you must also buy a case and a PSU. The total price will probably be similar, but the performance will be significantly lower for many applications, due to slower DRAM, slower non-volatile memory and bad cooling on RPI 4.
- kova12 7y agoThere is like 20 pages of reading, yet no mentioning how much RAM is in this thing...
- JamesSwift 7y agoSays at the very top, 4gb DDR4
- Koshkin 7y agoA CPU (Amlogic S905X3) B DDR4 memory (4GiB)
- m1aw 7y agoIt's written right there in the Specifications under Memory. DDR4 4GiB with 32-bit bus width...
- KAdot 7y agoYou can find full hardware specifications at https://wiki.odroid.com/odroid-c4/hardware/hardware https://wiki.odroid.com/odroid-c4/hardware/hardware
- tryptophan 7y agoThe biggest reason to buy the raspi is the software support for the hardware. With lots of these competitor boards, you may get better hardware, but it will be forever stuck on debian of ages long past. Until I am sure that software support for these other boards is good, I will forever stick to raspi.
- artonge 7y agoArmbian is providing good support for a broad range of boards.
- sfreitag 7y agoAccording to hardkernel.com the Odroid-C4 runs Ubuntu 20.04 + Kernel 5.4
- SlowRobotAhead 7y agoIs that “runs” or is 100% without workarounds?
- Fronzie 7y agoIn the past, their Odroid X2 ran fine, but did have a lot of custom patches in the kernel. This made it hard to update to newer kernel version. If I remember correctly, the binary blobs for the graphics driver (Mali) were also hard to get for newer kernel versions.
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoIs Raspbian 64Bit yet? Otherwise i don't follow, because then you'll use your PI4 in some sort of emulation for the older crap.
- samfisher83 7y agoIts not really a clone its a different single board computer. A72 on pi4 is more powerful than the a55 on c4. GPU might be better on c4.
- adrian_b 7y agoCortex-A72 is faster than Cortex-A55, but only when it is well cooled, which will never happen on a credit-card-sized computer, unless you use either a noisy fan or a passive heatsink larger than the board. ODROID-C4, as delivered, with only a small passive heatsink, can run indefinitely with all cores at 2 GHz, without overheating. Therefore a Raspberry Pi 4 without improved cooling will be in many cases slower, due to throttling, despite the larger Cortex-A72 cores. Moreover, Cortex-A72 implements an obsolete instruction set, while Cortex-A55 implements the ARMv8.2-A instruction set, which for certain applications, e.g. for the synchronization of multiple threads (i.e. for atomic instructions), has significant improvements.
- pizza234 7y agoThis is not a clone. The C4 is based on the Cortex A55 (A5x models are typically the low-performance/power Cortex models), while the Pi 4 is based on the Cortex A72 (A7x are the high-performance/power ones).
- artonge 7y agoTheir CPU benchmarks indicates better performance for the C4 compared to the RPI4 though. Is it due to the A55 being more recent ?
- adrian_b 7y agoThe better performance is due mainly to faster flash memory (eMMC), faster DRAM memory and bad standard cooling on RPI4. For benchmarks that depend only on the CPU, using an improved cooler on RPI4 would increase the sustained performance above Cortex-A55, except for some custom programs that could be written to take advantage of the newer extra instructions available on Cortex-A55.
- adrian_b 7y agoI want to add that for a fanless credit-card-sized computer, a quadruple Cortex-A55 is the correct CPU choice. A quadruple smartphone core like the obsolete Cortex-A72 or any of its successors, Cortex-A75, Cortex-A76 and Cortex-A77, requires a smartphone-sized board, unless you use a noisy fan for cooling. There exists also the fanless ODROID-N2, with a quadruple Cortex-A73, which, being well designed, has a larger board, which has an area similar to a smartphone or NUC. The RPI4 has a too large CPU for its size, unless fan noise is considered acceptable.
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y ago12nm vs. 28nm process for the cpu...
- deagle50 7y agoCoreELEC with 4k HDR and audio passthrough. This may be the new Kodi box.
- Koshkin 7y agoCoreELEC on an N2 works extremely well, I expect this one to be no different.
- m-p-3 7y agoMore like an alternative than a clone. You can't take the MicroSD card with a RasPi OS and make a drop-in replacement as if it was the same components and expect everything to work.
- tomc1985 7y agoMy friend and I have messed around with these. He is a big fan of them, I'm more lukewarm. One of my complaints was that the OS and driver support always had something wrong out-of-the-box. Tried with the provided Ubuntu image, also with Odrobian (its a debian build for odroid), always some random problem. 2D video acceleration worked but 3d didn't, or maybe 2D drawing was busted but Kodi would run at 60fps. Maybe the audio worked, maybe it didn't. It was almost always fixable with enough time and effort but eventually I gave up on them. Also build quality is a bit suspect, we've each had one or two of these things die on us. Ended up replacing it with an Nvidia Shield. On the upside, they're cheap and the metal case you can get for them is pretty cool. They don't run too hot and they're reasonably fast. For a while they were the only option with USB3
- ohelabs 7y agoNeat... While Odroid has been around for a little bit offering an alternative to RPi the issue is always support and adoption. A lot projects are built on RPi and porting them over to other platforms while sometimes easy other times adds another layer of abstraction and random issues. the other problem is if I need more Processing power I just move to an x86 platform... if I can't run it on a low power board.
- jbverschoor 7y agoSo it's $5 less expensive, but it's slower, doesn't offer cheaper versions or other configurations. Please remind me why I'd ever go for this one?
- adrian_b 7y agoWhich of Raspberry Pi 4 or ODROID-C4 is preferable, depends on the application. Neither of them is better for all applications. If the power consumption matters, then ODROID-C4 is better. If the performance of the non-volatile memory is a limitation, then ODROID-C4 is much faster. If the speed of DRAM is a limitation, then ODROID-C4 is faster. If the application requires sustained performance with all cores active, then ODROID-C4 is faster, unless a custom cooler is used with RPI 4, which must be either very noisy or very large (larger than the board).
- adrian_b 7y agoTo be more clear, the list of of advantages mentioned above make ODROID-C4 a better choice for any server-like application, while Raspberry Pi 4 is probably better for a personal-computer-like application. I do not use a credit-card-sized computer as a PC instead of my laptop, but I use such computers in server-like applications, so for my uses, ODROID-C4 is better. After you add all the required accessories, the prices fror RPI 4 and for ODROID-C4 are very similar, for both of them you would reach around $100 for a decent system, but the ODROID shop is somewhat more convenient because you can buy from a single place almost any accessory you might need besides the basic board.
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoNeeds machined aluminum case where bits of case reach down to the surface of the chips with just a small thermal interface pad or thermal grease between them. I don't like plastic with air vents, and fans.
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoAlso 12nm process node vs. 28nm for the Broadcom Videocore.
- ac29 7y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22955077 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22955077
- hinkley 7y agoI like my Pi clones, especially since before the 4 the rasPi lacked in areas that mattered to me. But looking at these charts I see they omitted devices on some tests, especially toward the bottom. And herein lies the case study for the rest of us. As a skeptical consumer of infographics, I smell a rat when the charts don’t line up. And it doesn’t matter if they still win on those benchmarks, what matters is the omission, which looks like you’re trying to hide something. Since I don’t work with these people, and can’t just go ask what happened, the safe bet is to assume the worst. Publish data for all competitors on all benchmarks or people will assume you are lying. That said, they avoided the most common sin: in all charts where magnitude matters, they use a zero origin for the charts, so there is no distortion of relative value between options. They only chopped for graphs where steady state is the point (like thermals and frequency).
- dang 7y agoWe changed the title from "Odroid-C4 for 50 Dollar (Raspberry 4 clone)" since there were complaints about that being inaccurate.
- ex3ndr 7y agoI didn't get. Why anyone claim that this board is cheaper while RPI 4 2GB cost 35 bucks and have much much better CPU? 4GB doesn't make sense and almost always is an overkill. I made a huge research trying to find cheap and powerful board for my prototypes. And RPI always wins in the price. Even Chinese clones are more expensive. Why? It turns out RPI is a non profit.
- rasz 7y agoYou know what else cost $50? 5x faster 2 year old laptop with cracked screen.
- metroholografix 7y agoI have 4 ARM Odroid devices, but I'm not going to buy another one. Even though some are advertised as supporting mainline Linux kernels, in practice none do if reliable operation is to be expected. When you buy an ARM Odroid device, you're tied to Hardkernel's vendor-specific patches and vendor-specific Linux kernel branches. As you would expect, the quality of these patches varies from bad to absolutely terrible. If you visit the Hardkernel forums, you'll see people casually swapping patches to get functionality like USB to "work". The practice of not even trying to merge with mainline is completely unacceptable, and not only leads to fragmentation but erodes any quality guarantees one can make about systems one builds on top of their products. They're literally running code that the mainstream Linux kernel development community has neither vetoed nor reviewed. It's for that very reason that I will not support them anymore. The ARM Linux ecosystem is bad enough without me subsidizing this sort of behavior. It's also disappointing to see the Linux kernel community not coming down hard on such endeavors (Linus in particular could enforce the Linux trademark) since they dilute the entire ecosystem and erode quality. Odroid advertises Linux but it's not really running Linux.
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoNot entirely true. The process is not automagic, because you manually have to search bits from the device tree and put them into the one from mainline kernel. Furthermore fiddling with uboot is often needed. But it's absolutely possible to have rock solid operation with mainline linux. It just lacks the (right) vendor defaults in all sorts of places for now. This is my experience with Allwinner. But since i'm watching that SBC ghetto closely i'm aware of that being the case for the other vendors too, more or less. And when everything is perfect the device is obsolete, EOL. G (edit: reminds me of fiddling with custom ACPI tables because of crappy BIOS on PCs)