7 ms·
We really know only what they have chosen to let us know; and much of what we think we know is false. Getting people to believe falsehoods about the programs wa
by ncmncm 7y ago
We really know only what they have chosen to let us know; and much of what we think we know is false. Getting people to believe falsehoods about the programs was a big part of them, and it worked way better that they had hoped.
Jon Ronson's book Men Who Stare at Goats is a terrifying exploration of what these programs were really about.
Make no mistake, these programs were prototypes for still-ongoing attacks on the American public.
- jariel 7y ago"these programs were prototypes for still-ongoing attacks on the American public." Needs evidence.
- rmrfstar 7y agoOne of many examples [1]. These tactics would be familiar to the Romans. They are as old as the hills. They are apparently common enough that HBGary proposed a collaboration with Palantir to use them against Glenn Greenwald [2]. [1] https://theintercept.com/2014/02/24/jtrig-manipulation/ https://theintercept.com/2014/02/24/jtrig-manipulation/ [2] https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20110209/22340513034/leaked-hbgary-documents-show-plan-to-spread-wikileaks-propaganda-bofa-attack-glenn-greenwald.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20110209/22340513034/leake...
- jariel 7y agoThese have absolutely nothing to do with said 'mind control' programs.
- nl 7y agoThese aren't mind control at all! Saying "the intelligence community is horrible" isn't the same as "these programs were prototypes for still-ongoing [mind control] attacks on the American public."
- rmrfstar 7y agoWe don't really know what took place in the "mind control" program, as the records were systematically destroyed [1]. One plausible interpretation is that these were mainly efforts in coercive control, rather than Hollywood style "mind control". We have extensive records of comparable efforts in East Germany [2], and it is reasonable to suspect that the American programs followed a similar thread of "research". Why wouldn't they? The tactics were apparently very successful. If you buy that argument, then the cited examples are logical successors. It is very easy to dismiss "mind control" programs as a weird vestige of a bygone era, but I think it is unlikely that institutions drew no durable lessons from them. [1] https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study-of-intelligence/kent-csi/vol44no4/html/v44i4a07p_0021.htm https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study-of-intellig... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IWjzT2l5C34 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IWjzT2l5C34
- nl 7y agoThe article was specifically about MK-Ultra style mind control. Saying there are other ways to try to get people to do what they want - especially at a population level as the OP claimed - is a completely different proposition. I've linked elsewhere to IARPA SHARP which is the closest thing to actual mind control. Do I think intelligence agencies try to manipulate public opinion by methods similar to advertising agencies? Yes absolutely! Do I think this this is mind control or anything resembling that? No, and I think it's important to note that despite all the leaks (Snowden, Wikileaks, etc etc) there is no hints that I'm wrong about this.
- rmrfstar 7y agoThe whole point of the comment is that we don't know what "MK-Ultra style mind control" means because the records were destroyed. We can only make educated guesses about what is likely to have survived the program. If you think the guess is bad, that's fair. It's another thing to get hung up on the semantics of "mind control".
- naringas 7y agowhat makes you think they would have stopped?
- fit2rule 7y agoOperation bluebird. MK ultra. Palantir. Keyscore. Have you not been paying attention?
- nl 7y agoOnly MK Ultra (which this article is about!) is anything resembling mind control. Apparently I'm paying more attention to what this is specifically about than you are!
- fit2rule 7y agoKeyscore: social control. Palantir: social control. Bluebird: mind control at scale. I think you're being intentionally disingenuous. No sane person can look at those social control programs and think "well this is innocuous" or "compatible with the free and open society"...
- nl 7y agoI'm not being disingenuous at all. I'm arguing specifically that the statement "these [mind-control] programs were prototypes for still-ongoing [mind-control] attacks on the American public." Project Bluebird was in the 1950s which the article is about. You seem to be just pulling in all kinds of bad intelligence products. I'm not arguing that at all.
- fit2rule 7y agoThese programs are related inasmuch as they revolve around controlling the American public mindset with regards to the military industrial complexes' illegal wars. CIA currently runs 1000+ black ops 'interrogation' sites around the world for the purpose of fulfilling the goals of these kinds of programs. The purpose is the justification of endless war and as we have seen, are quite effective at swaying American public opinion. cf., ISIS, et al,.
- ncmncm 7y agoSurely you recall the US invading Iraq on the basis of fabricated evidence and an absolutely massive propaganda campaign? They harvested five trillion dollars off of that one stunt. Do you imagine they decided to quit while they were ahead?
- nl 7y agoDid you read the article? Propaganda is not the same as the mind control they are talking about or the OP claimed is being used at the population level.
- ncmncm 7y agoPropaganda was and is a big part of it. Lying about what was done is a big part of it. The Big Lie is that the program ended. Most people believe it, although not for any defensible reason.
- nl 7y ago> Men Who Stare at Goats is a terrifying exploration of what these programs were really about So an enormous waste of money that achieved nothing? > Make no mistake, these programs were prototypes for still-ongoing attacks on the American public. Take your conspiracy theories elsewhere.
- Super_Jambo 7y agoThe Snowdon leaks made it clear that US and UK security services are still happy to use psychological manipulation on their own public. Never mind that we already knew this since COINTELPRO.
- flipcoder 7y agoWhat is worse: a nuclear weapon or a psychological weapon? Nuclear weapons sound more dangerous, but they cannot be used invisibly without triggering a catastrophic response, meaning their power is largely from the leverage they give to the owner. Psychological weapons can be hidden and used without detection, can be approved of by secret courts, and directly benefit governments in far more scenarios with far lower risk. They are also cheaper. So what is more dangerous to the public?
- nl 7y agoLinks, please. Specifically to the mind control, since that is what this is about. Psychological manipulation includes things like advertising and PR, so that isn't the same thing at all.
- fit2rule 7y agoThe use of the phrase "conspiracy theory" belies your ignorance. This term is too often effectively used against an inquisitive public, to shut down criticism of these agencies..
- nl 7y agoAu contraire! I've studied conspiracy theories a lot! This is a great example: take something that did happen (experiments 40+ years ago), combine it with something more recent people know about in passing ("Men who state at goats" - which I'd note was exactly about how it didn't work at all), and then use it to project into the idea that it must be more advanced today and mysterious forces are using it. Indeed, the idea of taking something that did happen, and then weaving it into lots of other random things to hide it in the noise (like this comment does) is a tactic often used by intelligence operatives. There's a conspiracy theory for you to think about! I'd note that there is no evidence given at all. The OP could have spoken about the recent IARPA SHARP brain stimulation program[1] which is probably the most advanced research in this area. But clearly they didn't know about that or they'd also know how hard it is to make work and how far away from mind control it is! [1] https://www.iarpa.gov/index.php/research-programs/sharp https://www.iarpa.gov/index.php/research-programs/sharp
- fit2rule 7y agoWe know a little bit that they didn't want us to know. The CIA wasn't as complete as possible with covering its tracks, and quite some independent research has been done on the remaining evidence. The trouble is the CIA and other nefarious intelligence agencies have worked very hard to discredit this, clearly because they committed crimes against humanity in their work. However there is still a healthy segment of society that are critical of these criminal agencies. There is still a lot more to be revealed.