4 ms·
> Everyday consumer cars haven't offered anything interesting to the consumer for nearly 20 years, and I'm not sure what they could possibly offer. If you look
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> Everyday consumer cars haven't offered anything interesting to the consumer for nearly 20 years, and I'm not sure what they could possibly offer.
If you look back to the days when cars were less utilitarian and more sentimental, the key difference was that people would modify them. They'd put on bigger wheels and performance parts, cut them up and turn a truck into a camper or add aftermarket features to the interior.
You ever see that show about Count's Customs? People used to do that at home. But basically every car on that show is 1980s or earlier for a reason.
Modern cars are unibody, they don't have a separate frame so you can't put on a different one. Everything is not only done by computers but done by opaque undocumented non-standard computers. You can't so much as replace the entertainment system in your car because it's integrated with the climate controls and everything else.
Some of that (like unibody) is for a reason, but most of it isn't. It doesn't have to be this way.
And when it wasn't was when people actually cared about their cars. That's how you get people to pay you all of these maintenance dollars -- get them to push their cars hard on the track or off-roading or on cross-country road trips but then care enough about them to pay you the money to repair them when they wear out. Get people to love them because they have hundreds of hours into them and brand loyalty means something because all your spare parts and systems knowledge are for Chevys and not Hondas or vice versa.
They all think they want to be Apple but more phones run Android and more servers run Linux and Tesla is already being Apple. Be something else. There are a lot of customers looking for something else and not a lot of competitors providing it.
- nickik 7y agoYou really can't get around the Unibody when producing more then 50-80k cars. Trucks of course are the exception as you have to go with body-on-frame and in that case we do see a much larger modding community and a huge after market.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoRight, but why aren't they publishing RFCs for the APIs their different computers use to talk to each other, and releasing most of their code under a license that says something like "modify or distribute this code however you want and use it on any vehicle you have a license for (which all of ours come with)"? There should be third party forks of your entertainment system on github or you're doing it wrong.
- ironman1478 7y agoThere are a ton of trade secrets in the interesting parts of a car (ECUs) that will basically never be released. But for infotainment, there are competing efforts to standardize on that front but it's slow from what I've observed. Decisions about components + software are made way in advance of the car being made, so softwarey type things are outdated by the time they come out. That is changing though
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThe trade secret argument is silly. As if it really matters if it takes your competitors a month to reverse engineer it from disassembling a binary instead of a week if you publish the source code. You can't mass produce something with a secret in it and expect it to stay a secret. > Decisions about components + software are made way in advance of the car being made, so softwarey type things are outdated by the time they come out. They're doing this wrong. You have an infotainment system which is basically a PC/tablet built into the dash. It should be completely open. Like you should be able to rip it out and replace it with an actual PC or tablet running entirely third party software and it should still be able to do everything. Then it should talk to all the other parts of the car over ethernet using published standards, no secret APIs. Not publishing the code for the ECU is silly but that allows them to do it and not have that infect everything else in the car, because its internals can be a black box but all the public interfaces aren't. Then it doesn't matter how outdated your infotainment system is because anybody can install the latest version after the fact or replace it with an entirely third party one and all you need is a "driver" that translates the API version used by the ECU and other vehicle components into something that infotainment system can work with.
- ehnto 7y agoThere is already a standard for this called CANBUS, we just need auto manufacturers to use it more extensively so aftermarket devices can talk to it.
- ironman1478 7y agoYou actually can mass produce tons of stuff with trade secrets! A lot of systems aren't easy to access and wouldn't necessarily be debuggable with normal tools, depending on th age of the car. For new cars, they are work on basically building devices with no interface except the communication channel, and to access it you'd have to reverse engineer the protocol, which is not trivial I can assure you. For infotainment, its not actually as easy as you think. Its definitely rated QM or maybe ASIL-A because it can do things like control climate or on some cars put it into different modes. Failures in these systems might not be catastrophic, but they need to be correct to some degree and failure or poor design, can lead to this https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-remotely-kill-jeep-highway/amp https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wired.com/2015/07/hackers-r... Granted, should they have connected everything the way they did? No, but car companies are barely engineering firms, they are just basically assembly firms that contract out all their components except for things like the ECUs. If they don't know how to specify security requirements to a vendor, it won't happen. They are learning though and it takes time.
- ehnto 7y agoIt's interesting to see the EV market getting excited about modularization of EV's. I think it really is a new opportunity to implement more standardized, modular and personalize vehicles. I think the biggest reason people don't modify their cars anymore is simply that they aren't allowed to. Fewer people outright own their cars and their loan and insurance terms and conditions won't let them modify the car, as it would void the vehicle warranty. For what it's worth, there's still a huge car modifying culture where I live, and no car I've owned stays stock for long. But you're right, as soon as it hits around about the late 90s year models, you don't see as many of them modified. While OBDII was a great improvement for ECU diagnostic standards, there are still dozens of smaller proprietary microcontrollers within most new cars. The manufacturing and materials also play a role in making them more difficult to modify cleanly. It's just hard for the hobbyist to keep up with design and manufacturing processes.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> I think the biggest reason people don't modify their cars anymore is simply that they aren't allowed to. Fewer people outright own their cars and their loan and insurance terms and conditions won't let them modify the car, as it would void the vehicle warranty. I don't buy it. The average car in the US is almost 12 years old. The warranty is up and the loan is paid off. It also doesn't make sense for the warranty to be affected by things like software changes to the entertainment system which anybody could revert in five minutes if they were causing problems. They should practically want that to happen because it gets people to show up at the dealership with a non-problem you can fix in five minutes which gets them into the dealership where you can upsell them on something or show them all the new cars. The problem is everybody wants to be a gatekeeper and what they don't realize is that they're Samsung and not Apple. They're much better off to have more and better third party software for their cars by publishing standards and not locking everything down, so more people buy their cars, than to have a walled desert full of nothing because they're trying to control everything.