4 ms·
Luckily we do. They’re called the University of California system. At least California banned affirmative action in the 90s.
by alephnerd 7y ago
Luckily we do. They’re called the University of California system. At least California banned affirmative action in the 90s.
- hhsuey 7y ago> UC may choose to advance goals like diversity and equal opportunity using a broad range of admissions that are not based on an individual’s race or gender. For example, holistic review in admissions considers income level, first-generation status, neighborhood circumstances, disadvantages overcome, low-performing secondary school attended, and the impact of an applicant’s background on academic achievement. these things are highly correlated with race, however.
- lawrenceyan 7y agoThere's nothing wrong with recognizing that people in disadvantaged situations face greater difficulties in overcoming systemic obstacles. Being able to overcome these factors are actually generally a very strong signal in determining potential of future success. This is why affirmative action in of itself is not a wholly bad thing. It's just that using ethnicity as the primary proxy is worse at generating a strong signal as compared to > income level, first-generation status, neighborhood circumstances, disadvantages overcome, low-performing secondary school attended, and the impact of an applicant’s background on academic achievement.
- throwUCaway 7y agoPerhaps in theory, but not in practice. I went to a UC for graduate school a decade after Prop 209 passed, and there was blatant affirmative action in the admissions/recruiting process. They literally treated candidates different based on their family's country of origin. The deans were open about the fact that they "pushed the envelope" on affirmative action, despite it being illegal.