3 ms·
We've been having this argument for several years and there is more trolling than ever. In past email conversation i've given you examples of people organizing
by anigbrowl 7y ago
We've been having this argument for several years and there is more trolling than ever. In past email conversation i've given you examples of people organizing on 8chan to target threads here. You always end up saying you need more convincing examples. Fine, if you want to wallow in toxicity at source go look at kiwifarms.net or /tech/ forums on imageboards for examples of both targeting HN stories directly and general discussions of waging cultural warfare in the social space around technology.
I think your fire analogy is off. An occasional conflagration in a highly-populated city doesn't do anything to promote the quality of the environment. Quite the opposite.
Since I made an explicit analogy to a forest, rewriting it to be about something else kind of makes my point for me.
- dang 7y ago> In past email conversation i've given you examples of people organizing on 8chan to target threads here When? I don't remember that, and I just searched the email archive and didn't find it. I found a mention of 8chan, but not with examples, and certainly not with links to people organizing to target threads here—which is hardly something we would be disagreeing about. Obviously that's abusive.
- anigbrowl 7y agoDo you really need to be spoon fed? Come on, Dan. https://julay.world/tech/res/2387.html https://julay.world/tech/res/2387.html https://8kun.top/pnd/res/62485.html https://8kun.top/pnd/res/62485.html https://julay.world/tech/7.html https://julay.world/tech/7.html https://kiwifarms.net/search/2622647/?q=%22hacker+news%22&o=relevance https://kiwifarms.net/search/2622647/?q=%22hacker+news%22&o=... Here's one where they're having a laugh at how pliable you are. https://kiwifarms.net/threads/open-source-software-community.38130/page-65#post-5542599 https://kiwifarms.net/threads/open-source-software-community...
- dang 7y agoHold on a second. You said you emailed me examples. I ask when, because none of your emails contained anything like that, and your response is "Do you really need to be spoon fed?" That doesn't seem right. I can't find anything about HN at your third link. The others don't seem to contain much, but I'll take another look tomorrow. (p.s. HN's software autokilled your comment for what I hope are obvious reasons.)
- anigbrowl 7y agoI know I've described it to you in general terms, though I don't remember sending you any specific links. Raids on specific threads are usually organized on chat servers and they're not likely to have identifying signatures like a single point of origin. You're not going to find a smoking gun saying 'let's take over this specific thread exactly as anigbrowl described.' I said you should look at it for examples of both targeting HN stories directly and general discussions of waging cultural warfare in the social space around technology. But the link identifying you by name and praising you for restructuring discussions, while invoking a racist trope about policing, ought to give you some pause for thought. You can keep saying 'oh that's not accurate, that's a misrepresentation' but there's an example of a troll celebrating the sort of discussion restructuring that I was talking about when I mentioned your manual move of the top comment yesterday (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22973436 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22973436) - although I had not seen that particular kiwifarms thread at the time. It's not the only mention of your name there. Here's another long-running one about the open source community where HN comments/users are being targeted from the first page: https://kiwifarms.net/threads/open-source-software-community.38130/ https://kiwifarms.net/threads/open-source-software-community... Now sure, there's room for a long philosophical discussion about what is a troll and who is or isn't a troll specifically and so on. I'm citing Kiwifarms as an accessible easily searchable example that's also relatively tame, but I might note that the header on every page there links to an imageboard specializing in nazi and loli media. Draw your own conclusions about what lands on HN from that particular social funnel. To repeat, my point here is not that you should moderate people-i-don't-like more aggressively, but that said people see your existing moderation approach as an asset.