3 ms·
That's a terrible analysis, for reasons well-covered all over HN and elsewhere. This is a whole different thing from 'another flu'. We have to address it head-
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
That's a terrible analysis, for reasons well-covered all over HN and elsewhere.
This is a whole different thing from 'another flu'. We have to address it head-on. Throwing people (a million people?) under the bus is not going to fly, not politically and not morally.
- centimeter 7y ago> for reasons well-covered all over HN and elsewhere. I've yet to see a compelling argument that LY or QALY analysis is the wrong approach. > This is a whole different thing from 'another flu'. We have to address it head-on It sounds like you're not actually offering any relevant response to the parent comment, but just repeating the taglines we all saw in the article. > Throwing people (a million people?) under the bus is not going to fly, not politically and not morally. Every political action has victims and beneficiaries. At the moment, we're hurting billions of people (almost the entire world population) to buy (on average) a few expected life-months for a very small section of the population. Your model of "people dying is bad" is true but not sufficient to make rational decisions.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoBecause, its well-covered all over HN and elsewhere. I suggest reading and thinking, before posting throw-away pseudo-analyses.
- marcell 7y agoEvery year around 3 or 4 million people die in America from a variety of causes. This is sad, but at some point, everyone has to die. Data is showing that the infection fatality rate is around 0.5%-1%, and is concentrated in older people. [1] is one study, but there are many others. Given this data, it's clear that our current response is out of proportion with reality. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/COVID19/comments/g4tqvk/dutch_antibody_study_of_blood_donors_reveals_3/ https://www.reddit.com/r/COVID19/comments/g4tqvk/dutch_antib...
- johnnyo 7y agoSo if all of America (330 million) gets infected, and we’ve got a 1% fatality rate, that means deaths (3.3 million) would be up there with all the other things that kill us combined!
- greedo 7y agoWe hopefully would reach herd immunity far before that point, but even with herd immunity only requiring 70% of Americans to be infected, we're looking at over 2m fatalities. And that's not even counting the hospitalizations that will be over 20M. What we need to hope for is an unlikely vaccine, or a therapeutic treatment to mitigate the worst of the diseases effects.
- astrophysician 7y agoAlright so lets unpack this argument, because (1) this is a pretty extreme oversimplification, and (2) the unstated suggestion you make is to quite literally let millions of people die world-wide who wouldn't have otherwise: > Data is showing that the infection fatality rate is around 0.5%-1%, and is concentrated in older people. right, "old" (65+?) people are going to die anyway, lets just let them die sooner. How much sooner? Years? Decades? Does this really sound like a cogent counterargument to not letting people die? Let's ignore the morality aspect of this, which I don't think is in your favor, to put it mildly. I don't really like people suggesting that millions of people should die because "this is sad, but at some point, everyone has to die." Yikes. But lets pretend we live in a very nauseating reality where older people don't really matter very much. You should still want society shut down to prevent this spreading out of hand because this will easily and thoroughly overwhelm all of our healthcare resources, which will mean hundreds of thousands of people you actually do care about (i.e. non-older people) will also die from lack of medical care either from COVID, pre-existing medical conditions, new medical conditions, etc.
- marcell 7y agoThere's a bit of gish gallop and vitriol here. First, the .75% mortality rate is a one-time hit. It likely pulls some deaths forward, so the incremental death rate is maybe .5% in a single year. Again, this is terrible, and sad, but we should be mindful and accurate with numbers. Second, people make lots of choices that increase their mortality risk by .5%. For example, lots of people eat at McDonald's on a regular basis, which certainly increases your lifetime mortality risk by .5%. And other people don't exercise at all. 30 minutes of jogging a day will lower your mortality by at least 1%, likely a lot more [1]. But we don't pass laws to force everyone to jog for 30 minutes a day. With the new data, which is showing that mortality rates from covid-19 are not like smallpox 2.0, we should adjust our response to be more in line with responses to comparable risks. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/nov/04/any-amount-of-running-reduces-risk-of-early-death-study-finds https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/nov/04/any-amo...