3 ms·
No it's not. It is the nature of chaotic systems. In chaotic systems, the uncertainty in a forecast increases exponentially with elapsed time. Hence, mathematic
by chrisco255 7y ago
No it's not. It is the nature of chaotic systems. In chaotic systems, the uncertainty in a forecast increases exponentially with elapsed time. Hence, mathematically, doubling the forecast time more than squares the proportional uncertainty in the forecast. This is why, despite our best efforts and 50 years or so of Moore's law increases in computation, we still cannot predict the weather beyond 10 days with any sort of accuracy. Likewise, I have no idea what the Lyapunov time is for the climate, but it's certainly smaller than 80 years.
If human beings had any sense at all, we'd accept that we cannot control the climate and we'd do well to prepare for either a warmer or cooler climate. In other words, we should be adaptable.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyapunov_time https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyapunov_time
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyapunov_exponent https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyapunov_exponent
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chaos_theory
- sfkdjf9j3j 7y agoSo why is it that climate scientists - the most educated people on this topic - overwhelmingly believe that evidence supports a theory of anthropogenic climate change? Is it more likely that they are all wrong, that they are all in on an elaborate conspiracy, or that you are wrong?
- chrisco255 7y agoNumber one they're not all in agreement. Number two, outright, science does not work on consensus. The only reason climate relies on consensus is because they cannot validate their models. They are stuck on the hypothesis step of the scientific method. It doesn't matter how many people you get to agree with your hypothesis. Without empirical experimentation, it proves nothing. You cannot beat chaos theory. The current crop of climate scientists are not being honest about the extremely exponentially high levels of uncertainty in their forecasts. You would do well to read from first principles on chaos theory and ask yourself whether I'm the crazy one for claiming that the future of our climate is unknowable. We understand weather far better than we understand climate. And we cannot predict it more than 10 days into the future. At any rate of you want to hear it from true experts here are a few: Richard Lindzen, PhD Atmospheric Sciences, MIT https://youtu.be/X2q9BT2LIUA https://youtu.be/X2q9BT2LIUA Patrick Moore, UBC https://youtu.be/kHZKo13HV2A https://youtu.be/kHZKo13HV2A Henrik Svensmark, Danish Space Institute https://youtu.be/wU1qg8HceGI https://youtu.be/wU1qg8HceGI Freeman Dyson, Cornell https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=BiKfWdXXfIs https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=BiKfWdXXfIs NASA admitting they have no model for clouds: https://youtu.be/ra9AFNco3lI https://youtu.be/ra9AFNco3lI
- thomas2718 7y agoPredicting the weather is fundamentally different from predicting climate. Let's play a coin game. We'll throw a fair coin 100,000 times. Beforehand, I predict the number of heads +-0.5%. If I'm right, 1,000$ for me, if I'm wrong, 1000$ for you. The probability that my prediction is correct is more than 99.8%. Nevertheless, I can predict a single coin flip only with a 50% chance. A single coin flip represents a weather forecast. Climate, however, is the long term average, represented by the total number of heads. Even if I cannot predict the individual events (like tomorrows weather), I can say something about the averages with high probability.
- briantakita 7y ago> So why is it that climate scientists - the most educated people on this topic - overwhelmingly believe that evidence supports a theory of anthropogenic climate change? Because they are practicing a Pseudoscience with a predetermined outcome. Their job is to cherry pick data (e.g. ignoring CMIP6 particle forcing) to support their predetermined conclusions... Also, the 97% "consensus" study had math errors & has been debunked. Reality is not that simple to have a conclusion of this sort. There are many factors. The definition of a "climate scientist" has been expanding in scope due to more factors being identified, such as X-RAY variation from solar cycles, Ionic particle forcing from the Sun, Cosmic Rays, Electric effects from the Sun, etc.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoFunny how evidence of modern hominid species arriving coincides with extinction of most large animals in any given area. Or oceans suddenly became more acidic with widespread burning of coal. It's almost as if humans can destroy the habitat life relies upon as quickly as natural phenomenon. Humans can control human behavior. Just because other, uncontrollable risks exist does not mean we should just give up.
- edmundsauto 7y agoI think we can assume that climate scientists are aware of chaos theory, considering their field was one of the first to recognize the value in modeling things as dynamic non-linear systems. While there are large error margins due to that non-linearity, literally all of our evidence (including causative models, e.g. grade school greenhouse science experiments) indicates bad things. Those may not come to pass, or they may not be human related -- nothing is certain -- but there's precious little evidence in the other direction. Outcomes may vary, you are right. Yet nearly all available evidence suggests we should accept AGW as the most likely situation, while accepting there may be other, more accurate predictions. We should change our behavior only once new evidence comes in indicating a different conclusion.