4 ms·
> The Green New Deal moves us in the right direction. You can raise questions about the specific form in which Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Ed Markey introduced
by nomel 7y ago
> The Green New Deal moves us in the right direction. You can raise questions about the specific form in which Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Ed Markey introduced it. But the general idea is quite right.
I really wish the "Green New Deal" wasn't mentioned in these pushes for the future. I don't think there was ever agreement on what the "general idea" of it was, and I don't think it deserves any credit for the few good ideas that it did contain. Sure, it's recognizable, but not necessarily in a good way.
- dougmany 7y agoThe general idea is to have large government funded works programs to transform our way of life from fossil fuel based to renewable based.
- hmmokidk 7y agoThe new deal created the middle class in America, rescued it (very lately) from the Great Depression, and set it up for the post war prosperity that made America what it is today. I think the idea of a green new deal is to do that again, as well as save us from the climate grave we are digging ourselves into. In my mind it is poetry.
- valuearb 7y agoThe evidence for the New Deal accomplishing any of those things is virtually non existent. For example, the 1937-38 downturn was nearly as bad as the 1930 one, and the economy wasn’t restored until WW2 started.
- bhupy 7y agoI believe you, but you're going to need to provide some sources for that.
- valuearb 7y agoGoogle unemployment and GDP levels.
- bhupy 7y agoProvide the sources, nobody on this forum is going to jump through hoops to change their minds.
- valuearb 7y agoI’m not jumping through hoops for those to lazy to find easily google-able and commonly known economic history. Any freshman economics books has the statistics too. The 1937 recession almost cost FDR the election. The unemployment rate didn’t reach normal levels again until the US entered the war.
- bhupy 7y agoI agree with you, I'm just giving you feedback here: if your goal is to change minds, it is in your best interest to provide sources directly. Nobody will care that you didn't want to jump through hoops if you've lost the ideological argument in the court of public opinion.
- nickik 7y agoThis is just factually wrong and has no credibly outside of a few extremely left wing economists and those believe it despite the economic research or because they have not studied it. The New Deal has achieved mythical status in the left wing version of history, but that is simply not an accurate depiction of history. If you look at the numbers in detail, you would see that when the US left the Gold Standard, growth immediately came back, industrialist production skes back up. This is pretty clear pattern with all the nations who were under deflationary pressure. Leaving the gold standard (or adjusting the exchange rate) was the fundamental thing that restarted the economy. It is pretty clear that the NIRA actually stopped the ongoing recovery and indsutrial production only outpaced the pre-NIRA level again when NIRA was declared unconstitutional. Why anybody would declare the total madness of this program a success is just unbelievable to me. Massive destruction of food, mass slaughter of life-stock to increase prices. Blue Eagle program to 'keep prices high' were exactly the wrong things after a deflation. Contrary to popular history, New Deal was not some brilliantly executed Keynesian program. In fact it does not fit any economics logic at all. The US had one of the globally worst recovery path from 1931 to 1939 of all industrialized nations. Specially consider how well the came into the situation compared to everybody else. Why this period is hailed as a great success, is because it was an incredible political success as FDR managed to totally rebuild the democratic coalition. That coalition remains to this day. Of course the left and specially democrats hail it as the biggest success in centuries, because it was politically successful. And the claimed that it 'prepared' to US is mostly wrong. Roosevelt to his credit was smart enough to kick most of the New Deal idiots out of his administration going into WW2 and worked with actually sensible people and during WW2 and after the US actually removed the majority of these terrible polices and that allowed the US to recover far better then most other countries.
- hmmokidk 7y agoSorry to break it to you but your analysis is totally wrong. You don’t really put forth any reasons as to why the new deal was a failure, you just say it is. Living people experienced the success of the new deal, which is why it is such a powerful phrase. If you’re going to reject reality you’re at least going to need a source or an argument.
- johnchristopher 7y agoThere's another narrative in Europe about how we actually build our prosperity on the back of the southern hemisphere.
- hmmokidk 7y agoYeah I don’t disagree with that but it’s a separate problem IMO. Americans don’t give a shit because if we lose our job we’re fucked, the government doesn’t give a shit about us, we’re stressed and worried all the time about things Europeans take for granted. The quality of life in the US is horrible. And if it were better people would be more capable of organizing and speaking the truth. But the truth has just been squashed in the interest of the ultra wealthy.
- bigbob2 7y ago> I really wish the "Green New Deal" wasn't mentioned in these pushes for the future. Yes, and what do you personally prefer to see instead? > I don't think it deserves any credit for the few good ideas that it did contain Why would something not deserve credit for any good ideas it contained? > Sure, it's recognizable, but not necessarily in a good way. I'm really not trying to nitpick, but it seems like you're overgeneralizing. To whom would it be recognizable but not necessarily in a good way?
- hinkley 7y ago> Yes, and what do you personally prefer to see instead? That's nowhere near as useful as "What do you think we can reasonably expect at least 180 million (geographically distributed) Americans to accept?" It is time that tech people looked themselves in the mirror and said, "Nobody gives a damn what I want, and I should stop acting like they do." There is no point system. We get nothing for 'being right' but not getting any traction. There is no gold star waiting for you at the end (and we aren't 6). You can't solve policy problems thinking the same way you do about convincing more than half of a room of people to upgrade that library you use. That's four people, possibly including yourself. While success may make my life a lot easier, that barely ranks as an accomplishment. Large groups of people are so much harder to manage than small groups that it's not even funny. "Politics is the Art of the Possible"
- bigbob2 7y agoThat has nothing to do with the parent wishing for the Green New Deal not to be pushed by Noam Chomsky. Also as far as I'm aware, Noam Chomsky is not a tech person so I don't see where your "we aren't 6 and get nothing for 'being right'" argument is relevant there. If anything it's snarky and probably goes against the guidelines of this website. On the other hand, I guess this entire article and thread do as well.
- nomel 7y ago> Yes, and what do you personally prefer to see instead? Since you seem to agree, I'll give this privilege to you. > Why would something not deserve credit for any good ideas it contained? It was a packaging of some ideas, not the source. > I'm really not trying to nitpick, but it seems like you're overgeneralizing. To whom would it be recognizable but not necessarily in a good way? It had no regards for feasibility, and most people noticed. I don't think using the name of something infeasible is good when you're proposing something that you want to be considered feasible. It also contained very significant social programs that are usually unrelated.
- slg 7y ago"New Deal" is synonymous with a program of large and widespread government reform and investment to combat a specific problem. So while "Green New Deal" is the name of a specific piece of legislation, support for a general green New Deal is support for reform and investment to help the environment and more specifically fight climate change. I don't think anyone ever really expected the specific Green New Deal legislation to be passed, but it was meant to kick start that discussion and serve as a rallying point for future efforts. This type of thing is pretty common when a specific piece of legislation is inserted to represent an entire issue.
- 8bitsrule 7y agoAnd here I thought it fairly obvious (for those not covering their ears). The general idea of it was to mobilize some kind of cooperative fight to defeat the very real threat of climate change, and to overcome our addiction to fossil fuel and the consequential CO2 emissions and pollution. Many very talented people have created a lot of good ideas and solutions to the oncoming disaster. I don't think that people realize how much this pandemic is a walk in the park compared to whats coming down the road. I don't think people want to think. I think they want to stick their head in the sand and ignore the fact that there have been many calamities in human history. Perhaps they never heard of the 10s of millions of people who starved to death in Asia less than a century ago. That was a walk in the park by comparison. Finally, I think that people don't realize how many of the technologies that they so happily embrace (without understanding how they work or where they came from) are the result of the same scientific process that has led 11,000 scientists to tell us that our time to act is growing very short. That's the general idea of it. And I feel sorry as hell for today's wonderful kids who will have to pay with a miserable life (those who survive) for the willful ignorance of their parents and grandparents.