5 ms·
In 10 days of operation, they have 200 3lb bags of flour. Each would be worth $1.50 in walmart, and due to anti price-gouging laws, it would be illegal to char
by londons_explore 7y ago
In 10 days of operation, they have 200 3lb bags of flour.
Each would be worth $1.50 in walmart, and due to anti price-gouging laws, it would be illegal to charge more than that.
So after 10 days operating, with presumably at least a few people on-site, they have produced goods which can sell for $300, or a revenue of $30 per day.
I think this is more a publicity excercise than a commercial operation...
- starmftronajoll 7y agoYes. This is a charming story of kindness, community, and cultural heritage. It is not a business story.
- dv_dt 7y agoNot that there aren't serious questions, but it's common for prototypes and early production runs to easily cost 100x vs optimized production runs. And if it's meeting a need, I would suggest that the immediate cost isn't the primary concern or benefit here.
- pjc50 7y agoI suspect they were selling it for a higher price before the emergency as a souveneir.
- tomxor 7y agoThankfully this is in a tiny village in beautiful Dorset, England with a modest local population, and no there is no Walmart... so none of that applies.
- rjsw 7y agoTechnically there is Walmart in Dorset. Walmart owns the Asda supermarket chain and there are branches in the larger towns in Dorset.
- tomxor 7y agoThere is no asda in Sturminster Newton... even if there were US consumer law does not apply.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoAt the moment, they have been trying to offload it for some time.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoNor do we have price gouging laws.
- hinkley 7y agoNo, in 10 days they have sold 200 bags of flour. > In its first fully functional 10-day period, they milled a ton of wheat; under normal circumstances, that would've been a year's worth. As a result, it has already been able to deliver 200 three-pound bags of flour to local stores and bakeries. Assume that the ramp up was bumpy. Maybe they can do half a ton a day (5x), and they have >3x as much product as they've sold... they might be able to do $500 a day until the equipment breaks down. For a tourist trap that could be pretty respectable.
- blihp 7y agoI think it's more a public service that happens to provide some publicity rather than the other way around. People want/need flour right now with various supply chain issues, and this mill can help produce some locally. Of course it makes no business sense (which is probably why the mill shut down 50 years ago)... that's not the immediate issue.
- bhhaskin 7y agoAnti price gouging likely won't come into play here.
- sio8ohPi 7y agoPrice gouging laws won't generally prevent them from continuing to sell at the price they've been selling at. It's fancy artisanal flour with a story, so they charge twice that for a bag. [1] [1]: https://sturminsternewton-museum.co.uk/theme-content/uploads/2017/12/snmms-the-mill-2.jpg https://sturminsternewton-museum.co.uk/theme-content/uploads...
- ghaff 7y ago$1/pound or so is pretty typical for even relatively mass-market "artisanal" flours in the US. That's about what Bob's Red Mill and King Arthur go for. (For their regular white flour. More specialty items are more.)
- happytoexplain 7y agoHoly crap - what information do you have about these people that makes you think they are engaging in a publicity exercise, rather than simply trying to help?
- qqssccfftt 7y agoWhen your brain is so poisoned by capitalism you think that there is nothing other than either making a big profit or virtue signalling.
- throwaway373438 7y agoThe information we have is the scale of their operation. If they were trying to get flour to people in the most efficient way possible they'd be using that manpower to repackage from wholesale distributors. There's no shortage of flour milling capacity -- the shortages are distribution related. This is touched on in the article. As it stands, they're really producing a negligible amount of flour. A nice gesture, but not the kind of thing you'd do if you're earnestly trying to address a problem. It's very clearly a stunt -- not that there's anything wrong with that.
- floatrock 7y ago> millers Pete Loosmore and Imogen Bittner decided that, due to the current demand for flour and the loss of income from visitors, this would be a good time to re-embrace the mill's commercial production capabilities. I mean, I wouldn't call it a publicity exercise, but they quite explicitly say they need to make up for lost tourism income. Call it an operational pivot. The lesson here is it's good to have a diversity of offerings. Some of their budget probably comes from historic site funds and maybe they also offer weddings or events, but the point is there certainly is a commercial interest in this.
- josinalvo 7y agoThe useful content of his(her?) reply is that the so called "price gouging laws" can not only have good effects, but also bad ones. This flour could be selling higher, and creating more incentive to produce. But I agree, that publicity stunt bit is needlessly agressive
- timthorn 7y agoThis is a heritage charity and most certainly not a commercial operation. There are many old mills around the UK, many still in working order, of multiple types. Most are registered with the SPAB: https://www.spab.org.uk/mills https://www.spab.org.uk/mills
- vanilla-almond 7y ago"Each would be worth $1.50 in walmart" This is stoneground flour produced in small batches which will almost certainly be sold at a premium price. Flour in the UK is commonly sold in 1 or 1.5kg packets in supermarkets and this would be priced anything from £2.00 to £4.00 ($2.5 to $5 / €2.3 to 4.6)
- Mediterraneo10 7y agoIs it really legal to sell stoneground flour in Britain or on the continent in this day and age? It is known from both archaeological excavations and studies of Third World populations that tiny little bits of the millstone flake off into ground flour, and gradually, over time, these stone fragments cause severe damage to people’s teeth. I would have imagined that there would already be legislation to require the use of metal milling.
- timthorn 7y agoYes, it's legal. After all, sweets haven't been banned and they cause lots of tooth decay.
- londons_explore 7y agoDon't modern flours have little bits of granite sand in to make an "authentic" texture?
- renewiltord 7y agoFascinating. Another example of the HN community's "Assume Bad Faith" in action. If I had to come up with a list of values for this community based on popular comments, I think it's a photo finish for the top between: * Assume Bad Faith * Be Pessimistic
- throwaway_pdp09 7y agoI know what you're saying but it's not HN, just a sizeable minority of misery-guts who can't tolerate success or decency in others. And if I may add another bullet point to yours + It's all hopeless so why bother trying to change it.
- polynomial 7y agoOut of curiosity, how is gouging calculated relative to profit? At one point does profit become gouging?
- ctdonath 7y agoWalmart sells premium flour (which this limited production product would count as) for much more than $1.50. And it’s something for the limited staff to do while otherwise unemployed.