4 ms·
I think the idea that there were shared design goals, was their fatal mistake. You illustrate several of these, thank you. The speed difference is another - st
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
I think the idea that there were shared design goals, was their fatal mistake. You illustrate several of these, thank you.
The speed difference is another - streamlining mattered not at all for a car at the speeds they were generally going at that time.
Further, a plane is always headed into the wind; cars are pinned to the road by friction and most often have cross-winds. There were tragic car rollover problems throughout the 30's because of this misconception/failure to recognize utterly different design goals.
Generally the only thing in common was, a factory making chassis and shells. Other than the manufacturing technology, there was almost complete mismatch of design goals.
- csours 7y ago> "I think the idea that there were shared design goals, was their fatal mistake." Yes. If goals were vectors, cars and airplanes have many that align on the direction, but have VERY different magnitudes.
- dredmorbius 7y agoPrime movers and fuels also. Both the automobile and airplane ... took off ... atvirtually the same moment, once petroleum-based fuels and reciprocating, Otto-cycle engines existed. Power-to-weight matters more for aircraft, but it's a critical problem for both, along with range (fuel capacity) and reliability. Body design and aerodynamics aren't the only issue. Though also a bigger problem for aircraft. Materials (duraluminium), controls, aerodynamic theory, infrastructure (airports, navigation, traffic control, safety standards, incident investigations, etc.), are other key elements. Then came gas turbines. Auto engineers tried to apply them but they weren't a good fit.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoControls, maybe not so much? The road-impulse and 16ft lane limits of the auto, apply to a plane not at all. And so many pod-car designers didn't address controls at all. They just took a Ford chassis and made a new (wood!) frame and skin. Further, the auto price-point means the fancy materials were a no-go for a production car anyway. As for traffic control, safety, navigation - different as night and day. Good call.
- dredmorbius 7y agoFor controls: development, and especially, standardization. For aircraft, there's the matteer of movement in three dimensions, with speed, yaw, pitch, and roll controls, as well as communication, navigation, and cabin environment controls. Autos have only two dimensions of freedom and less complex requirements generally, but orders of magnitude more operators with orders of magnitude less training and oversight. Addressing user-base scale is its own complex problem.[1] To be clear, my list of key elements wasn't asserting equivalence between land vs. air craft, but adding them to fuels and engines as crucial enabling technologies. ________________________________ Notes: 1. Arguably, much of the increase in computer processing capacity has gone in to enabling ever less-skilled populations to make effective use of them.