4 ms·
To expand on the unknown method of action. It could for example be removing other pathogens from the blood that lets the immune system focus on covid-19. Alter
by Retric 7y ago
To expand on the unknown method of action. It could for example be removing other pathogens from the blood that lets the immune system focus on covid-19. Alternatively, random cellular damage could clause a useful immune response. Etc etc.
Medicine has often found treatments that works without any real understanding of why.
- klenwell 7y agoIsn't this true of Pasteur and his initial application of vaccines? While he identified the mechanism of inoculation, my understanding is he theorized that it was due to the attenuated pathogen outcompeting the virulent one for nutrients rather than due to stimulation of the immune system. I think I got that from a lecture by a science historian once. This idea seems to be glossed in the Wikipedia article on Pasteur here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louis_Pasteur#Anthrax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louis_Pasteur#Anthrax Do I have that right?
- belltaco 7y ago>While he identified the mechanism of inoculation, my understanding is he theorized that it was due to the attenuated pathogen outcompeting the virulent one for nutrients rather than due to stimulation of the immune system. How could it outcompete the actual virus if the actual virus isn't there yet at the time of vaccination?
- klenwell 7y agoGood point. Maybe the theory was the attenuated pathogen would consume available nutrients thereby depriving the real pathogen when it arrived?