3 ms·
Don’t believe me? Go to TechCrunch and count the comments on last week’s posts. Better yet, go read the comments. They suck. They’re sterile and neutered. Tech
by comex 16y ago
Don’t believe me? Go to TechCrunch and count the comments on last week’s posts. Better yet, go read the comments. They suck. They’re sterile and neutered.
TechCrunch seems to be pretty happy with the result: http://techcrunch.com/2011/03/06/techcrunch-facebook-comments/ http://techcrunch.com/2011/03/06/techcrunch-facebook-comment...
The problem with tying internet-wide identity to a broadcast network like Facebook is that people don’t want one normalized identity, either in real life, or virtually.
Is there any evidence this is true outside of geekdom?
People yearn to be individuals. They want to be authentic. [...] The nature of commenting on the web needs to feel organic and fluid, just like it does in real life.
But real life rarely includes trolls.
I don't like Facebook comments at all, and as long as TechCrunch uses them I probably won't be commenting, but this article makes too many broad statements, with too little support, for my taste.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- phlux 16y agoI'd be more willing to believe that TC is trying to hedge criticism of their non-existent editing and their over-inflated self importance. TC confuses criticism with trolls.
- pyre 16y ago> Is there any evidence this is true outside of geekdom? Are you claiming that geeks are the only people that sequester information between groups of friends and/or the general public? Are geeks the only people that may represent themselves one way to one set of people, and another way to another set of people? This seems to me like it's something inherent in the human condition. I'm surprised to hear it referred to as a geek-only attribute...