8 ms·
Neither does the US. Taiwan is only recognised by IIRC 12 natinos, mostly small island states. This has become another weird internet talking point as internati
by Barrin92 7y ago
Neither does the US. Taiwan is only recognised by IIRC 12 natinos, mostly small island states. This has become another weird internet talking point as international recognition pretty much unanmiously switched to the PRC in the 1970s.
- umvi 7y agoMaybe formally, but Trump has implicitly recognized it[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump%E2%80%93Tsai_call https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump%E2%80%93Tsai_call
- Barrin92 7y agoPretty much all global institutions have informal or de-facto relationships with Taiwan, that's besides the point. Not recognizing Taiwan formally has been the position of just about any institution or country on the globe for 50 years.
- nerfhammer 7y agonitpick: it's been about 40 years. E.g., the US officially switched recognition to PRC in 1979.
- xupybd 7y agoIt's the awkward way they one representative handled a question on Taiwan. Pretending he didn't hear the question. I think it speaks more to the unwillingness of a world health organisation to even discuss politically dangerous topics.
- purerandomness 7y agoHere's a short clip of the interview for those who haven't seen it yet: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tCFPFWsIPmM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tCFPFWsIPmM
- Barrin92 7y ago>I think it speaks more to the unwillingness of a world health organisation to even discuss politically dangerous topics. Which is perfectly reasonable if you understand that these questions are looked at through the lens of international diplomacy and these people don't just wing geopolitical questions because every single answer can cause an international shitstorm (not just in regards to China, but every territorial conflict really). This may look awkward to the ordinary viewer but it's not really. The WHO has a fairly strong interest in staying out of politics and being a health organisation, so whatever diplomatic position they take is mostly just going to be whatever the status quo is. If you think the non-recognition of Taiwan is unethical then you should take that up with your respective government, a guy speaking for the WHO isn't really in any position to make incindiary political commentary.
- afarrell 7y agoIts not that it is unethical But it does support the statement that "The WHO is a political organization with medical leanings". Personally I think that statement puts it a bit too strongly. It would be like saying "PyCon is a feminist organization with technical leanings."
- busymom0 7y agoIt's not international diplomacy when WHO ignored Taiwan's warning emails from December and went with China's lies instead.
- tomp 7y agoBut that's besides the point. I don't look at WHO for geopolitical opinion. I look at it for health advice. And there's where it failed.
- nl 7y agoCould you give specific examples of where the WHO failed to give the best advice possible at the time? Or even any cases where they were wilfully blind?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- GordonS 7y agoI saw that video and was shocked that a representative from WHO would behave that way, pretending not to hear the question and hanging up... utterly childish behaviour. I mean, how the hell am I supposed to take an organisation like that seriously?
- anigbrowl 7y agoPolitics are a fact of international relations. It's childish to think an international organization that depends on its member countries for funding can just completely ignore that or blow it off, rather than eat shit occasionally in order to work around it. Sure, they can make a bold impassioned speech about how science is far beyond petty concerns like national sovereignty and so on, but this isn't a movie where a great speech suddenly brings everyone to their senses. In reality the WHO works through public health departments in nearly 200 countries and also gets its funding from governments, so if they spit int he face of sovereignty, they'll cease to exist in any meaningful way and aggregate health outcomes will definitely be worse.
- GordonS 7y agoStraw man - you're making an argument against a point I didn't make or even insinuate. I didn't say organisations can or should ignore politics - of course, politics affect every organisation, especially those that work across borders. My entire comment was about the childish behaviour of the WHO represenatative when asked about Taiwan[0] - he was literally one step away from putting his fingers in his ears and shouting "na na na na na!". [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tCFPFWsIPmM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tCFPFWsIPmM
- bjourne 7y agoThe mandate of the WHO is to improve world health. Thus avoiding politically sensitive issues is correct if that helps the organization to reach its goals.
- brobinson 7y agoEdit: since people are misunderstanding this post, I am 100% pro-ROC and anti-PRC. I wish the ROC could rename itself to something else without triggering a PRC invasion. Check my comment history. I'm 100% pro-ROC and I support the ROC's continued (since 1912) independence as a sovereign entity. 中華民國萬歲 "Taiwan" isn't a country. It's an island controlled by the Republic of China alongside its other holdings. The ROC is a state that has existed since 1912 with continual international diplomatic recognition since then. Other countries switching diplomatic recognition from the ROC to the PRC didn't magically make the ROC vanish. I really dislike the fact that the media and government in the US refers to the ROC as "Taiwan". It muddies the conversation and I constantly have to explain to people that there are two governments/countries over there, one from 1912 and one from 1949.
- KorematsuFred 7y agoThat is what Chinese claim. I think what Taiwan says matters too.
- rdlw 7y agoThis is NOT what the People's Republic of China claims, the PRC does not recognize the government of the RoC.
- brobinson 7y agoFalse. And don't use the term "Chinese" as it's ambiguous. This is not what the PRC claims. The ROC has existed since 1912 and has only occupied Taiwan since 1945 (some claim since 1952 and the Treaty of San Francisco). The ROC has been an independent state with continuous diplomatic recognition since 1912. It does not need to declare independence. I just take issue with people calling the ROC "Taiwan" as it gives ammo to PRC shills who intentionally muddy the conversation with their claim that "Taiwan is a part of China" where the term "China" is ambiguous or referencing the "One China" principle which the US doesn't even recognize (acknowledges the existence of, but does not adhere to).
- Izkata 7y ago
- ardy42 7y ago> Neither does the US. Taiwan is only recognised by IIRC 12 natinos, mostly small island states. This has become another weird internet talking point as international recognition pretty much unanmiously switched to the PRC in the 1970s. That's misleading. The US de facto recognizes Taiwan, and the only reason it doesn't recognize it de jure is that the PRC would formally cut off relations if it did. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Institute_in_Taiwan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Institute_in_Taiwan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taipei_Economic_and_Cultural_Representative_Office_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taipei_Economic_and_Cultural_R...
- elsonrodriguez 7y agoMore importantly: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_US_arms_sales_to_Taiwan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_US_arms_sales_to_Taiwa... Like, it's ok that we sell Taiwan fighter jets and tanks to defend themselves against China, as long as we say that Taiwan belongs to china. I'll never understand politics.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoMy guess it’s okey to do that because Chinese internal politics is based on PR which is populistic in nature. What is the proportion of people who would go out looking for lists of American exports into Taiwan vs the proportion of people who would hear Taiwan being pronounced by the president of the US?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- outside1234 7y agoThe WHO de facto recognizes Taiwan as well.
- PixyMisa 7y agoIf by "de facto recognizes" you mean they suddenly have trouble with their Skype connection the moment Taiwan is mentioned.
- garmaine 7y agoNope. The US just changed it’s official position to recognition of Taiwan as an independent entity, as part of the TAIPEI Act in response to all this.
- nl 7y agoThe TAIPEI Act doesn't change the US's position on recognition as a country. It specifically says "the US should advocate for Taiwan’s membership in all international organisations in which statehood is not a requirement" Note the statehood is not a requirement thing. I think it would be great if Taiwan had observer status at WHO, and I think the TAIPEI Act should help towards this. But the point remains: Taiwan is an unusual entity, and WHO is far from alone in having trouble with this.
- garmaine 7y agoSection 1(a)(3): "(3) Taiwan is a free, democratic, and prosperous nation of 23,000,000 people and an important contributor to peace and stability around the world."
- appleshore 7y agoAll due respect, but this is lunacy. The way the guy reacted then hung up is unconscionable. The WHO is clearly corrupted by China's money. And the US is still connected to Taiwan and provides them military support. And we have a $250M 'de facto' embassy there. Honestly, I'm so shocked and dismayed by your comment, that I think I want to stop participating on Hacker News. Your perspective is relativism ad infinitum. This is the thing I fight most against. This isn't a community for hackers & painters anymore. Eternal Relativism is impossible to win against.
- nsoonhui 7y agoYou are missing the point entirely; the point is that WHO as an International HEALTH organization shouldn't take sides in geopolitical issues. Bringing the behavior of US-- a sovereign state-- into the discussion is completely inappropriate.