5 ms·
I couldn't find any detailed write up about their selection methods for participants, only the basics of where they found them. Without that, it is very hard to
by ineedasername 7y ago
I couldn't find any detailed write up about their selection methods for participants, only the basics of where they found them. Without that, it is very hard to determine whether or not there's some flavor of selection bias: If it is voluntary, and they do not screen out people who report having had cold/flu symptoms, then they run the risk of attracting a disproportionate number of people who volunteer because they're curious if their prior symptoms were actually coronavirus. That would make it far from a random sample. The fact that they sampled only people actually leaving their house is also a form of selection bias: these are the people more likely to be exposed and may represent a disproportionately high infection rate as well.
So I await further information.
That said, even if it's overall 0.6%, that is still 6x higher than flu, and higher than H1N1 which had a CFR around 0.1 for areas with adequate health care. (much higher when there was not adequate care, but that is not dissimilar to Covid.)
So no matter what, no one should be walking away from this study saying "See it's no big deal! Just the Flu/Cold etc!"
- Retric 7y agoFlu is generally well under 0.1% of those infected on average. If you’re comparing them you want to either include or exclude asymptotic people from both populations. “Symptomatic Illnesses” https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/burden/index.html As to NYC deaths, many people currently infected will die in the future. You can make various estimates to account for this but a reasonable first approximation is to double current deaths based on NYC’s infection curve vs South Korea’s.
- greendave 7y agoAs an asymptotic* person, I resent your hyperbola. (Sorry, couldn't resist).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ineedasername 7y agoFlu rates are based on all known knowledge, population testing, etc. We don't have that for covid-19. If you want a good apple-to-apples comparison of lethality of another pandemic, you need to find CFR numbers that were available during the pandemic. That is what I provided in my post. Here is the source I got them from [0] which gives the CFR at the 10-week mark for H1N1, somewhat similar to where we are now. Here's the relevant quote: >"The overall case fatality rate as of 16 July 2009 (10 weeks after the first international alert) with pandemic H1N1 influenza varied from 0.1% to 5.1% depending on the country." [0] https://www.cebm.net/covid-19/global-covid-19-case-fatality-rates/ https://www.cebm.net/covid-19/global-covid-19-case-fatality-...
- greedo 7y agoThe amount of testing for influenza is nugatory. Most of the CDC data is collected by surveys, not tests.
- ineedasername 7y agoThere are near instant tests for flue in most every urgent care center I've been to (easier and faster than getting a dr appt.) Whenever I have gone or brought my kids when sick, they perform the test to rule out any potential need for antibiotics. When I asked, they said it's systematically reported to the the CDC as part of their flu surveillance system, whether positive or negative. That surveillance network is significantly more robust than a survey.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ferzul 7y ago0.6% this is the estimated ifr. comparing it to the cfr of flu is not right, which is about ten times less than the flu ifr - or about 60 times less than this figure. your conclusion is upheld, but even moreso
- zaroth 7y agoAccording to the CDC, the estimated prevalence of symptomatic flu last year was 45 million illnesses and 61,000 deaths. For NY, assuming it’s evenly distributed, that would translate into 13.8% of 20 million = 2.8m symptomatic flu cases and 3,753 deaths. COVID appears to be significantly more prevalent (roughly twice as prevalent in just 3 months as flu gets all year despite incredible efforts), and roughly 2-3x as fatal.
- hcknwscommenter 7y agoI think you need to rethink essentially all of your assumptions/math. COVID is not more prevalent than the flu and certainly more than slightly more fatal.
- zaroth 7y ago20% infection rates already puts SARS-CoV-2 at higher prevalence than the flu. And we're barely a couple months into the time period of significant spread. Why would you think that SARS-CoV-2 would not be more prevalent than the flu? The fact that we have no natural immunity, combined with how virulent it is, indicates the endpoint infection rate will be significantly higher than an average flu season. "In the U.S., for example, in recent years about 8.3% of the total population get sick from flu each season, a CDC study found; including people who carry the flu virus but show no symptoms, that estimate ranges to up to 20%." The endpoint percentage of fatalities is a multiple of the infection rate times the fatality rate. Both numbers are equally important. We've been hearing the "10% hospitalization" and low-single digit CFR numbers for months. At 20% prevalence, the NYC actually had 1.7 million cases, 36,723 hospitalizations, for a hospitalization rate of ~2.1%.
- vannevar 7y ago
- CodeWriter23 7y agoI argue there is inherently less sampling bias in this study than testing people at the hospital who have shown up due to severe symptoms.
- ineedasername 7y agoThose are the people who constitute the denominator for the CFR. It's a completely different metric. You would never try to impute population exposure from such cases. This study is trying to to impute population exposure. There isn't any comparison between the two in terms of which has more/less selection bias, they are completely different things.
- CodeWriter23 7y agoDidn’t stop the news media from tabulating a death rate based on hospital cases alone.
- greedo 7y agoThat's because all of the statistical reporting is whacked up across the globe. The only thing that can reasonably be measured now is CFR. Without extensive, reliable serological testing with high specificity, IFR can only be guessed at.