6 ms·
This feels like fear talking. As more data comes in, we are seeing more people with no affects. Not just mild, but nigh non existent. It is agreed that somet
by taeric 7y ago
This feels like fear talking. As more data comes in, we are seeing more people with no affects. Not just mild, but nigh non existent.
It is agreed that something gives people severe cases. Severe includes death and recovered with damage. We don't seem to have data letting you know who or what would land there.
- eloff 7y agoI disagree, see my sister comment. Even without data on lingering deficiencies, we can speculate with confidence that it carries a cost.
- taeric 7y agoSpeculation is fine. But we need data to back it. Right now, we don't. Could hypothesize that many being found with damage surviving, had damage going in. Would neatly explain why it hit them so hard.
- eloff 7y agoI'm not speculating about the long term effects of covid19. I'm saying all sickness carries a cost as currently understood according to our theories of cellular senescence. You've missed my point entirely.
- taeric 7y agoAnd you are missing mine. Agreed there could be long term things. Yes, we should study that and watch for it. If that is the extent of your point, then my response is "yes, and?" Your framing, though, begs the question that mild cases have long term damage. We have zero evidence of that. Literally none.
- eloff 7y agoYou're still missing my point. I'm saying all sickness comes with a long term cost. It gives you a shove toward the grave. Covid19 falls into that category, regardless of how much or little we know about it. Now you could argue that sickness and aging don't work that way. I don't think you'd be right, but you can make that argument. Your argument about the long term effects of covid19 is not relevant to the point I made.
- taeric 7y agoYour point feels vacuous, then. Yes, getting sick can have long term impact. Do you have evidence that that is relevant to our current scenario? More so than it would be for any other sickness that is running rampant?
- DeonPenny 7y agoBut you shouldnt do that. Just like when we believe the death rate was 3% it seems we can't be confident in anything we've been told.
- eloff 7y agoYou've missed my point.
- op00to 7y agoDo non-severe cases cause lung damage too? Is the lung damage heal able?
- taeric 7y agoThat is the point of my question. There has been no evidence of damage in non severe cases. Indeed, we are having to get complicated testing to find out many people had it at all.
- op00to 7y agoHow could we even tell? Biopsy? Lol no thanks.
- taeric 7y agoPresumably you could find some evidence. X-ray? Just listening to lungs?
- rootusrootus 7y agoThere have been a number of reports of folks who were diagnosed with otherwise asymptomatic COVID when they had a CT for an unrelated reason that showed their lungs with GGO. And in some cases they have shown no signs of recovery even weeks later.
- taeric 7y agoA link would be awesome. And we would still need to ascertain that they did not have this damage before getting covid. :(. CT scans have a troubled history of seeing damage that preexisted. (See back pains)
- proto-n 7y agoHow about this article [1] (translation at reddit [2]) about german divers who had "mild cases" (no hospitalization, recovered at home) and were found to have suffered permanent lung damage, so severe that they can't dive anymore. [1] https://www.rainews.it/tgr/tagesschau/articoli/2020/04/tag-Coronavirus-Lungeschaden-Forschung-Uniklinik-Innsbruck-6708e11e-28dc-4843-a760-e7f926ace61c.html https://www.rainews.it/tgr/tagesschau/articoli/2020/04/tag-C... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/Coronavirus/comments/g3rv7h/permament_lung_damage_found_in_revovered_patients/fnt1p3e/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Coronavirus/comments/g3rv7h/permame...
- cryoshon 7y agowe have absolutely no clue regarding the long-term impacts of exposure to this virus for asymptomatic people or otherwise. we cannot gamble with our future so carelessly on the basis of preliminary data. here is a vignette to explain why. once someone is infected with HIV, most people experience flu-like symptoms for a week or two which then resolve either with or without treatment. in some people, the virus is cleared so effectively after the initial infection that they will test negative for HIV. then, over the span of months and years, their immune system is silently and entirely asymptomatically destroyed, leaving them none the wiser until they progress to AIDS and get extremely sick. COVID hasn't given us any indication of similar activity. but we know so very little that we can't take the risk, especially not with millions and millions of people. i will also note that we are unlikely to rule out these kinds of hypothetical risks anytime soon. so caution is our only defense against disaster.
- djrogers 7y ago> COVID hasn't given us any indication of similar activity. but we know so very little that we can't take the risk We take that risk with other viruses and bacteria literally all the time. If hypothetical but unlikely risks become thejustification for destroying people's livelihoods and the world ecomony, we're all dead anyway.
- cryoshon 7y agoas a former immunologist, i can assure you that with common viruses and bacteria, we have years and years of knowledge about how they perform, thereby making the risks of exposure calculable. it is this body of knowledge which allows our society to normally function even during a typical flu season. we understand the upper and lower boundaries of the consequences, and we can make an informed judgment about what we should do to navigate the environment accordingly. the idea of throwing open the gates to allow everyone to get infected is a dangerous fantasy. at best, it's taking a leap of faith with other people's health without knowing whether there is a long way down or not.
- taeric 7y ago