4 ms·
Localism is rarely the answer. The housing crisis is the primary example of this. The US has one endemic problem, which is local interests successfully lobbying
by Barrin92 7y ago
Localism is rarely the answer. The housing crisis is the primary example of this. The US has one endemic problem, which is local interests successfully lobbying federal government and putting the interests of the few ahead of the interests of society at large.
It's local homeowner associations, the tendency to litigate everything, the inability for large actors like government or business to purchase and develop land. The one person who symbolizes the reason why modern America can't build for me is Erin Brockovich. A person without any formal training in the legal field suing an entire project into the ground, although as it turns out there's actually no scientific evidence for any of the claims, yet she's celebrated as the little guy who stuck it to the man.
Devolving power to the states may only weaken the federal government whose resources and knowledge are needed to provide large scale infrastructure. The deficit here isn't in the billions, its in the trillions.
I'm not in principal opposed to experimenting with local democracy or whatever but it needs to happen on the back of a federal government with sufficient capacity and competence and power to act quickly.
For the "states as laboratories" thing to work you actually need a mechanism to ensure that the things that work actually get adopted. I don't see this happening in the US. There's way too many inmates running their own asylums.
- nickff 7y agoPerhaps the interstate highway system is a federal issue, but a metro subway or bus system isn't. Seattle's mass transportation system has no impact on Miami's; I doubt either has an impact on Portland's. What resources and knowledge does the federal government have that the states don't? If the federal government has such knowledge, it should probably publish the papers, so that state and municipal experts can determine how to apply it to their region. If the federal government lowers taxes, the states can raise theirs, and accomplish whatever objectives they need to. It's a many-billion dollar state issue in many states, which looks like a trillion dollar federal issue when you add up all the states, but there doesn't seem to be any economy of scale which makes the federal government better suited to solving the issue than any given state.
- xxpor 7y ago>Seattle's mass transportation system has no impact on Miami's This is only true if you look at it in the absolute shallowest way. Seattle's increased output due to its subway system helps the entire country. 95% (to pull a number out of my rear end) of the use of interstates in a city are for private vehicles belonging to city residents. I-5 in Seattle doesn't "help" Miami either.
- bhupy 7y agoYou can apply this thinking to the entire world, then. We ought to all be a part of one global country, and London's increased output helps us all! If only cooperation and decision-making were so simple.
- Brendinooo 7y ago>95%...of the use of interstates in a city are for private vehicles belonging to city residents This is probably nowhere close to true. People living in cities have less reason to use it. Interstates near and through cities benefit the broader region economically through commuters. But the bulk of the miles of the interstate system are the boring stretches through Wyoming or wherever, and those stretches tie the nation together economically. Half of all big truck miles are on the Interstate, according to some totally random website I found.
- wahern 7y ago> What resources and knowledge does the federal government have that the states don't? The problem is democracy. Local governments are more democratic in the sense of being directly responsive to community interests, especially since the 1960s-era reforms. But more democracy is not always better, especially when the community makes contradictory demands. Often you end up trading away administrative efficiency. So what does the federal government have to offer? A dispassionate, distant, and non-responsive administrative apparatus. At least in the current political context. Whether it could be effectively utilized is another question as there are also other pathologies at play, such as ideological sentiments that the federal government shouldn't be involved, period.
- toasterlovin 7y ago> Localism is rarely the answer. The housing crisis is the primary example of this. I think you could argue that the housing crisis is caused in large part by the fact that states cannot limit immigration from other states. Which would suggest that, perhaps, localism would be a solution to the housing crisis.
- Barrin92 7y agoHow is restricting freedom of movement within the United States, greatly harming individual rights and damaging the economy of the country a solution to the housing crisis? You've found the one thing that's actually worse than the status quo
- avmich 7y ago> yet she's celebrated as the little guy who stuck it to the man. You're serious? Are you sure she's celebrated as somebody who stopped America from building? Is it really that there are no way more plausible explanations of what happened? Do you think that "the man" can't build in such a way that's detrimental to others - being the man one can afford to ignore them, unless "the little guy" comes up - and, more, that America not building has nothing to do with interests of "the man"? IOW, poor coal company has only public benefits in mind, and can't contribute to progress of society because evil environmentalists prevent it from turning villages of miners into cemeteries of black lungs? Pardon some exaggerations.
- carapace 7y ago> Between 1952 and 1966, PG&E used hexavalent chromium in a cooling tower system to fight corrosion. The waste water was discharged to unlined ponds at the site, and some percolated into the groundwater, affecting an area near the plant approximately 2 by 1 mile (3.2 by 1.6 km). ~https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erin_Brockovich https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erin_Brockovich Are you trolling? Erin Brockovich isn't the problem. Dumping waste is the problem. That kind of "building" just isn't helpful.