3 ms·
Honest question: why do you need ethernet onboard a laptop? USB-C ethernet interface adapters are cheap; could you not simply get a few and leave them on the en
by sneak 7y ago
Honest question: why do you need ethernet onboard a laptop? USB-C ethernet interface adapters are cheap; could you not simply get a few and leave them on the ends of the ethernet cables to which you regularly attach?
These days, for most users (you and I included), very rarely if ever is wifi inadequate. If, for speed or security reasons physical ethernet is needed, the adapters are small and cheap.
I don’t understand the dongle hate.
- bobthepanda 7y agoDongles are annoying for moving about and they are One More Thing to worry about.
- munk-a 7y agoI'm also personally unimpressed with USB-C port stability, unlike USB-A connectors USB-C seems to have a lot of natural wiggle in it and the weight of dongles can wrench the cable out.
- mikepurvis 7y agoI'm on a Dell XPS now, and formerly a MBP 2015, so I haven't had a physical ethernet port in a really long time. I still miss it— I work at a robotics company, and a lot of my job revolves around the installer workflow (pxe, kexec, that kind of stuff), driver development (lasers, PLCs, and other devices that all speak Profinet and similar ethernet-based protocols), not to mention general fault investigation for when a robot "falls off the network" but can still be accessed over a wired last-ditch rescue interface. So yes, I have dongles at my desk and there are stashes of them around the office, but it's still a source of frustration when they go missing, don't work, etc. I know I'm a bit of a special case, but I would definitely still appreciate a computer that was 50% thicker with a proper ethernet port.
- xnyan 7y agoMy wife’s HP laptop has a spring loaded full sized jack that pops out. It adds no thickness and the laptop cost $300, there’s no ethernet jack on the Mac not because they can’t but they don’t want one.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> USB-C ethernet interface adapters are cheap Well, I know what you mean, but... I have a macbook for work and when we all converted to work from home, I needed to buy a USB-C ethernet adapter, thunderbolt adapter, and a USB-C to "old" USB adapter, and was shocked to find out that each one was $30-$40. I guess that's cheap in the grand scheme of things, but it would be nice if this stuff was still bundled into the computer.
- Domenic_S 7y agoMy company provides them, but we buy off-brands and I assume in bulk. I asked IT about it once - could it really be that much cheaper? - and turns out yes, it's substantially cheaper, especially at scale. I guess my point is, don't be afraid of off-brand dongles!
- trynewideas 7y agoWe need(ed) them extensively for lab hardware access in the office. It's accessible over wi-fi and VPN but we often need a wired connection to directly test hardware functionality and performance. So last year after people kept losing their dongles we starting keeping USB-C dongles always plugged into the cable ends. Adds $20-$40 to every person-facing ethernet outlet, but nobody ever lacks one, and we noticed more people using Ethernet as a result because of how much faster and more stable it is than our wi-fi. If anyone not new or transient to the office took the dongle off the cable, they got shamed very, very deeply. YMMV (we are a very shame-effective group) but buying 15 dongles once ended up being cheaper than buying 10 dongles, then 5 a few months later, then another 5, then oops we found the 5 that we thought were lost...
- jiofih 7y agoWith those $800 you could have a bought a really good 802.11ac WiFi router for the lab?
- munk-a 7y agoWith all this remote work happening due to Covid-19 I think video conferencing is making clear the issues with trying to push a high amount of data through a congested airspace. Even at home in a concrete building I have plenty of channel interference and regularly get dsyncs from spotty wifi when gaming over my LAN with my wife.
- drusepth 7y agoA friend of mine works in an office where you need a hardline for the network and there's one coworker always leaving his USB-C adapter on the hotseat cat5s, and always complaining when others in the office take them off and repeatedly lose them. I imagine it's probably as much of an inconvenience for everyone who has the port to take off the dongle and worry about losing it as it is an inconvenience for people who need the dongle in the first place. The solution to both seems to be "only distribute laptops that have the ports your business needs for daily work", but unfortunately companies don't seem to agree.