5 ms·
How was Apple able to get here? What secret sauce does Apple have in it's chip that's beating out Qualcomm, Intel and AMD?
by jayd16 7y ago
How was Apple able to get here? What secret sauce does Apple have in it's chip that's beating out Qualcomm, Intel and AMD?
- tarsinge 7y agoIsn't the current Intel Core line an evolution of the Pentium M (2003), itself an evolution of the Pentium III (1999)? Apple starting a fresh design with up to date constraints may have given them room for improvements I guess.
- jayd16 7y agoThat doesn't explain why AMD and Qualcomm can't keep up either.
- hajile 7y agoSandy Bridge was the last really big architectural change. It seems heavily inspired by the Alpha EV8 design (Intel bought Alpha from HP in the 2001) with of course, a very different decoder section (they wrap the x86 decoder around a RISC architecture). https://www.realworldtech.com/alpha-ev8-wider/ https://www.realworldtech.com/alpha-ev8-wider/
- chillacy 7y agoVertical integration? Even if their chips end up being a bit slower in the end, they'd probably increase their overall profit margins and get increased flexibility aligning their development cycles.
- paulmd 7y agoApple is willing to trade die space (i.e. manufacturing cost) for performance in a way that their competitors are not. Anandtech architecture reviews are helpful, as always. Worth reading for a page or two from the linked page: https://www.anandtech.com/show/14892/the-apple-iphone-11-pro-and-max-review/2 https://www.anandtech.com/show/14892/the-apple-iphone-11-pro... https://www.anandtech.com/show/13392/the-iphone-xs-xs-max-review-unveiling-the-silicon-secrets/2 https://www.anandtech.com/show/13392/the-iphone-xs-xs-max-re... The short of it is: massively wide execution units, massive amounts of SRAM, massive amounts of cache at all levels. There's no real "secret sauce", they're just willing to pay to make an incredibly fat core and Qualcomm and company are not. They have 16 MB of system cache on A13 for 2 high-performance and 4 low-performance cores, which is as much as a 9900K gets for 8 cores and as much as Zen2 gets for 4 cores. Plus another 8MB per big core on top of that (so up to 24MB per core in single-threaded mode), and 4 MB per small core. It helps that they're a vertically-integrated company, they don't have to sell their processors on the open market at competitive prices such that an OEM can also make a profit selling a finished product at competitive prices, they just sell the finished product.
- ip26 7y agoI think you are misreading the L2 sizes. It looks like 1x8MB L2, 1x4MB L2, and 1x16MB system cache. So you are correct that a lone thread could get up to 24MB of cache, but that's not per core. It's a total of 28MB of cache on the die. Zen2 has 2x16MB L3 and 2x4x512KB L2 per chiplet (36MB) so it's not like Apple is throwing down afore-unheard-of quantities of SRAM. It's true a single A13 thread has much more accessible L2 capacity, though.
- fomine3 7y agoIt's intelligible that Apple A series CPU wins to other ARM chips. But I can't find why they're competitive with big Intel/AMD chips even though lower core clocks. x86-64 is really a problem?
- ladyanita22 7y agoThat is somethimg I've been wondering too. Is such a huge difference in perf/watt due to the ISA?
- DeathArrow 7y agoI don't buy it until I see some more well done tests. Something like Cinebench ran 10 times in a row and taking the average of results would be more meaningful. Also, the benchmark has to enable or disable optimization on all platforms. Some people on reddit claim that Geekbench is highly optimized for ARM and less optimized for X86.
- hajile 7y agoTwo reason for x86 (IMO) and 3 reasons for ARM. I've thought for years that the overhead of the extra decoder hardware and legacy cruft was non-trivial (though Intel claims that's not true). The evolution of ARMv8 (where ARM went much closer to it's RISC roots) seems to disagree. This explains the performance per watt issue (and potentially some IPC). That said, scaling IPC (instructions per clock) seems to have a pretty big limit. x86 has basically hit a wall and it's been lots of time and research for small gains. Additionally, the biggest challenges in large systems is that the cost to do a calculation on some piece of data is often less than the cost to move that data to and from the CPU. As Apple increases cache size, frequency, and starts dealing with bigger interconnect issues, I suspect we'll see a distinct damper on their performance gains. Qualcomm (and ARM as the designers of the core) has a very different problem to solve. They can't make money off of software. They make money when they sell new chips and they make more money from new designs than from old ones. This means incremental changes to ensure a steady revenue stream. Since Apple having a fast, proprietary CPU doesn't actually affect Qualcomm or ARM, they most likely don't even see themselves as in direct competition. Most people buy Android or iOS phones for reasons other than peak CPU performance and Qualcomm is fairly competitive with a lot of these (esp actual power usage). A further complication is that they also need "one design to rule them all". They can't afford to make many different designs, so they make one design that does everything. Apple doesn't need to spend loads of time and money trying to optimize the horrible aarch32 ISA. Instead, they spend all that time on their aarch64 work. ARM and Qualcomm however need to add that feature so the markets that want it still buy their chips. Apple shipped their large 64-bit design only a couple years after the ISA was introduced. Put simply, that is impossible. It takes 4-5 years to make a new, high-performance design. It took ARM 3 years for their small design (basically upgrading the existing A9 to the new ISA) and closer to 4.5 years to actually ship their large design (A57) and another year for a "fixed design (A72, though it's actually a different design team and uarch). Though the gap has been closing, 2.5 years in the semicon business is an eternity. A crufty ISA and non-CPU scaling problems seem to explain Intel/AMD. A late start, bigger market requirements, and perverse incentives against increasing performance seem to explain ARM/Qualcomm
- StillBored 7y agoIts hard to buy that the ISA really has anything to do with it. As you mention apple has a fairly narrow market target for their cores. Both intel and AMD are basically building server cores (can you say threading?) and selling them as client devices. Mostly because that is where the real money for them is. Apple OTOH is building a client/mobile core, and they benefit from a number of "features" that they enable, which are known performance problems in the desktop/etc space but continue for legacy reasons. Combined with Intel basically standing still for the last ~5 years, and the tables have reversed as far as who is ahead on process+microarch. Basically a lot of apples advantages are: 1: Complete vertical control of compiler+OS+hardware 2: Plenty of margin to spend on extra die 3: More advanced process @ TMSC 4: Very narrow focus, apple has only a few models of iphone+ipad, where as intel has dozens of different dies they modify/sell into hundreds of product lines. So everything is a compromise. Any of those four give them a pretty significant advantage, the fact that they benefit from all four cannot be discounted.
- blihp 7y agoApple is arguably making some better design trade-offs. This is possible due to them making money on the whole computer/device, and not just the CPU as Intel/AMD/others need to do. So while the others are doing everything possible to both minimize die space and likely keep around a bunch of compatibility cruft that could probably go, Apple is free to go in a different direction. The 5775c (https://wccftech.com/intel-broadwell-core-i7-5775c-128mb-l4-cache-and-skylake-core-i7-6700k-flagship-processors-available-retail/ https://wccftech.com/intel-broadwell-core-i7-5775c-128mb-l4-...) was a good example of a no-compromises (from a cache standpoint) CPU from Intel that just annihilated their other CPUs at the time... it's not that hard to do, provided you're willing to pay the price for it somewhere else.