7 ms·
"Note, due to the extensive changes required for the shift in desktop environments, the Lubuntu team does not support upgrading from 18.04 or below to any great
by zamadatix 7y ago
"Note, due to the extensive changes required for the shift in desktop environments, the Lubuntu team does not support upgrading from 18.04 or below to any greater release. Doing so will result in a broken system. If you are on 18.04 or below and would like to upgrade, please do a fresh install."
Is quite a surprising note for an official Ubuntu flavor.
- bgorman 7y agoHonestly the only Linux distros worth trying are Gentoo, Arch, Fedora and RHEL/Oracle/CentOS. With anything else you are just wasting your time with amateur hour attempts to cobble together a Windows/Mac OS competitor without a good understanding of how all the components fit together.
- weakfish 7y agoCare the back that claim up?
- bgorman 7y agoSure, Ubuntu and Debian change the source code/setup of upstream packages, and generally add very little value compared to just using Gentoo/Arch/Red Hat based distros which actually use upstream components with much less touches and provide a more sane way to install your own packages, run docker container etc. In addition, Ubuntu does not do any real work pushing desktop linux forward. Ubuntu focuses its efforts on ill-advised efforts like writing its own compositor (Mir) and Desktop environment (Unity). Currently, most work to advance the Linux desktop is focused on a new project called Wayland (Used by Fedora for last few releases), yet Ubuntu has decided to double down on X11, a legacy project that clearly has no future and has issues like screen tearing that are basically impossible to fix. Another tangible example related to developers: On Fedora/Arch you can run docker containers without requiring root due to Red Hat's work pushing podman forward, however you cannot do this on Ubuntu/debian because they lag behind upstream
- Jonnax 7y agoI feel like I've gone back in time to 2013 reading your comment. What was wrong with unity? Plenty of people preferred it. Also Mir was ill-advised back in 2013 and was dropped in like 2017. Wayland has been around as long and is only just becoming usable. Or are you saying that Ubuntu should have funded Wayland development? Any proof they're "doubling down" on Wayland? If Ubuntu isn't pushing desktop Linux forward. Gentoo, Arch or Fedora sure ain't. Also lol. Podman seems to be an alternative to docker. Why should I use that? Why isn't that ill-advised? Is it because Red Hat made it? What's wrong with this? https://docs.docker.com/engine/security/rootless/ https://docs.docker.com/engine/security/rootless/
- bgorman 7y agoPodman is a technical superior implementation to docker. No background daemon is required to run. See details here: https://developers.redhat.com/blog/2019/02/21/podman-and-buildah-for-docker-users/ https://developers.redhat.com/blog/2019/02/21/podman-and-bui... I'm not sure what you mean by Ubuntu doubling down on Wayland. They have no plans to migrate to Wayland.
- Jonnax 7y agoThat article told me nothing useful. Honestly it seems like a clone of docker selling the slight advantage of root less. Which docker already does. I don't understand why I should care that it's a Daemon. In fact that blog post says that they won't go into why it's bad. Just that they do things different. In fact it seems like it's a "Not invented here" implementation from Red Hat. Searching Hacker news there's not many posts on it. Seems like it'd be as silly as using Mir to run this in production. Also on my doubling down, I misquoted you saying they're doubling down on X11. There doesn't seem to be any evidence of this. I wasted time googling it and it looks like they decided not to use Wayland by default in 20.04 because of certain bugs they didn't deep acceptable. But it comes with Wayland out of the box, and you select it on the login screen.
- msla 7y agoIf you choose a distro based on default GUI, I question your Linux knowledge.
- Aaronstotle 7y agoI think having a MacOS/Windows competitor is a good start, a lot of people try a Linux distro and choose a flavor that's familiar (Linux Mint is very similar to windows for example).
- Koshkin 7y agoHow is Debian different from all of those in this regard?
- ebiester 7y agoOr, we've been using Linux for a long long time and have no time for compiling from scratch, and like it or not, Ubuntu is the best tested out there for the desktop/laptop. Fedora isn't bad either, mind you. I'd never run Ubuntu on the server by choice, mind you, but servers are constrained by other considerations.
- sudosysgen 7y agoSince we're talking about compiling from scratch, I spend about a third of the time compiling since I've got Arch on my machine (albeit a fairly powerful Ryzen). The vast breadth of the AUR saves me a lot of time having to figure out how to compile version z of software x.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- znpy 7y agoMeh. I see a lot of people in IT who don't directly do systems-related work (think of QA people for example). Without Ubuntu they'd be either running mac os or windows. Ubuntu lowers the bar of linux-on-desktop accessibilty by a lot. For a lot of people it's okay not to have a good understaning og how all the components fit together.
- the_af 7y agoAgreed, but also: it's important to know that some of the "hardcore/tunable" distros don't provide a good understanding of how components fit together either. I don't know how it is now, but many years ago it was a running joke that most Gentoo users hadn't the faintest idea of how anything worked, but felt "hardcore" because they could pass many command line flags to the build and felt they were "optimizing" their system -- actual gains were not demonstrably noticeable, but they "felt fast" -- and they had no understanding whatsoever of gcc flags for example. Experienced users had to patiently explain that no, you shouldn't pass that experimental flag to gcc or everything would break. "Hardcore" Gentoo users believed that by "installing from source" they somehow magically ended up with a faster system. No empirical evidence, of course, just a heartfelt belief compiling source code was magical. This kind of "hardcore" Gentoo users was very, very, very annoying. Users of Ubuntu were better off: they understood what they worked with regularly and didn't pretend to understand what they didn't need to understand.
- non-entity 7y agoI see similar issues from a lot of Arch users tbh. There seems to be a lot of posturing of being a more advanced user, when thats not always the case. I once saw someone confidently explain that their drive device was /dev/nvme instead of /dev/sda because its an arch thing. I've tried one such "hardcore" distro once (Crux to be exact) and while it was fun for a while, I also wasted a lot of time. Nowadays, I just stick Ubuntu Flavor (am actually running Lubuntu right now) because everything works mostly out of the box. Yes, I know it has its own set of problems, but I have different priorities. I dont particularly care if I get labeled a noob for it.
- bgorman 7y ago
- connorgutman 7y agoUnder no circumstance should anyone listen to this user nor should they run Gentoo or Arch on a production machine. I use Arch on my personal computer but for work I find Debian testing to be the perfect distro. Stability is a trait which matters.
- mfontani 7y agoDo you find debian testing to be stable enough compared to debian stable, for servers? For similar reasons (stability), I always go for the current stable (although I've a couple machines on oldoldstable, because it takes a while to upgrade...).
- leeoniya 7y agofwiw, i run debian unstable in production for 6+ years, updating every few weeks, with 0 issues. i would assume that testing should be rock solid.
- edoceo 7y agoI've been super happy with Gentoo in production for at least a decade. I don't see the issue? I have Gentoo on my desktop+laptop too. But, I also run loads of Debian server systems too. My worst upgrade experience has been Ubuntu systems
- mekster 7y agoDoes that mean, you compile updates elsewhere and load the binaries on production?
- sudosysgen 7y agoI run Arch Linux for work even though we're a Debian shop, and it has a great many efficiency advantages. I think in hours they are more than worth the three hours of productivity loss it would take me to repair my machine in case something bad happens. Indeed, AUR and the extreme adaptability of Arch probably saves me 2-3 hours a week.
- 7y ago
- acqq 7y agoIt has a long tradition. It happened to me many years ago: I've upgraded from one version of Ubuntu to another doing the "upgrade" but I had more and more problems. Then I've reached for help over the internet. The answer was "oh you upgrade to the new version? We never try this, we backup our home and install from scratch." Another interesting point from these times: it was even then often written that the Linux and Ubuntu are better for the use of older computers compared to Windows. That wasn't true either. With every new version less of my hardware worked as expected. The memory demands only for the GUI installer were bigger than the demands of Windows, forcing me to attempt to install from the text mode, and still having the issues later. Windows just worked on the same machine (with the existing drivers). I've also lived through my (other) old hardware breaking on Windows too: my notebook on which all the hardware worked as expected on Windows 7 was declared by the Windows 10 as "totally would work" and it totally didn't -- the Intel devices on it never got the drivers that worked on Windows 10, neither by Microsoft nor by Intel who simply stopped supporting them. No OS is immune from the scenario (or even the company claims) "it will work" which than turns out not to be true with a new version. Long story short, in this case, backup your /home, install from scratch. Backups are good anyway. Any other attempt will probably give more pain. Also don't expect the newest OS to always work with the old hardware. Be prepared for these kinds of events too. For a real long term, there's Red Hat.
- jlarocco 7y agoHopefully people realize it's an Ubuntu problem, and not a general Linux problem. I pin my Debian machines to the "Testing" branch and "apt-get dist-upgrade" once a month, and I've never had a problem, except once or twice when NVIDIA drivers needed to be re-installed. It's worked great for me for 15 years, but YMMV. The CPU/memory usage almost certainly has more to do with the software being used than with the distro. The Linux kernel and GNU system utilities can run on very low resource machines, but most "desktop environments," like GNOME, KDE, and even XFCE, are targeting up to date systems. IME, using old hardware usually means putting in some effort to find and configure software that will run well on it - I'm pretty sure it's the same on any OS.
- Avamander 7y ago
- ilikebits 7y agoThis is the reason I switched over to Arch Linux. I have never been able to upgrade an Ubuntu system without some kind of obscure breakage without a documented fix. I've never encountered this problem with Arch, and archlinux.org both has great documentation and does a great job of alerting users when package upgrades require manual intervention. Arch is like the CI/CD analogue of operating systems. Small upgrades makes breakages much less common, and much easier to repair. This comes as a trade-off of less battle-tested stability than e.g. Debian, but if you're able to make small repairs proficiently then Arch is the way to go. I'd strongly recommend Arch on a personal computer - it makes a good OS for a pet (although Debian, because versioned releases are much more thoroughly tested, makes for much better cattle OS).
- waltpad 7y agoDebian unstable follows more or less that "CI/CD" approach you're describing, but it is called unstable for a reason: sometimes, a significant change is necessary, which may lead to significant breakage as well, but most of the time, you get small breaks here and there, which are usually easy to fix (and hopefully report, so that break can be handled by the package upgrade process directly). I wonder how's Arch in that regard. You speak about breakage less common, but there has to be some significant breakage from time to time: for instance, for a shift as important as moving from traditional sys-v init scripts to systemd, it must be expected that a lot of OS configuration related packages would break, unless every package maintainer is made aware that this change would happen, and that he/she has to prepare its package (if necessary) to that shift, AND that the shift only happens when everyone's ready. But Debian (and I suspect Arch as well) do not follow such a rigid scheme, and so there has to be breakages and fixes to follow.
- Tehchops 7y agoI've encountered far more esoteric, game-breaking issues during Arch upgrades than I ever did with Debian-flavored ones.
- m463 7y agoI haven't encountered a showstopper arch break, but it might be a statistical thing. When you install arch, you install each piece on-demand. So only the pieces you have chosen are dragged through updates. my arch installations tend to be quite lightweight.
- flavor8 7y agoUpgrading from 18.04 isn't supported until July, when 20.04.1 hits. The LTS->LTS upgrade path is handled more conservatively. If you're not on LTS, then you should upgrade every 6 months when the OS tells you a new distribution is ready, and you'll be fine.