4 ms·
> The only data that is somewhat reliable in this pandemic is COVID deaths. I agree,, especially as you included the word “somewhat”. We have pretty good numb
by gumby 7y ago
> The only data that is somewhat reliable in this pandemic is COVID deaths.
I agree,, especially as you included the word “somewhat”. We have pretty good numbers on people who died in hospitals, but people who died at home appear to be seriously under counted.
Additionally, consequential deaths are currently invisible. These are people who died, say, ecause the coronavirus crowded out their access to hospitals. There’s been a drop in ER visits for things like heart conditions. Some of those people would have recovered fine anyway but some may have arterial blockage that will kill them. You don’t Want these numbers in the primary statistics (as they say nothing about control of the pandemic) but you do want these very hard to track numbers to understating future capacity planning, ethical procedures, and long term economic consequences.
- markrages 7y agoYou can get part of that with excess death rates. From the weeks overall deaths subtract the average death rate for this week in past years. That should give both people who died at home and consequential deaths.
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe NYT has been analyzing that. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/21/world/coronavirus-missing-deaths.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/21/world/coronav...
- rckoepke 7y agoI'd reckon it's "doable" but not "easy", putting it in the realm of professional epidemiology. People are also dying less in car crashes, pollution-induced asthma, etc. There's quite a bit that may need to be accounted for. I suspect analyses will have decent error bars a year or so from now, but it's unlikely we'll get precise realtime estimates from this methodology. Would love to be proved wrong.
- autokad 7y agothis is not easy, as death rates are going down because people are not out and about.
- rechristened 7y agoThere are a lot of people not going to hospitals either because elective procedures were canceled or they fear getting corona virus. These will contribute to excess deaths but not be caused by coronavirus.
- _Anken 7y agoMost nursing home deaths are not getting tested either.
- user5994461 7y agoFrance started testing systematically in EHPAD (nursing home for retired fully dependent elders). That's why they have the most dramatic fatality rate out of every country now. Not sure it was a good idea to test and attribute all the deaths to COVID.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y agoIt's difficult because you don't want to use test kits on dead people.
- rechristened 7y agoThe number of deaths may be off but that is likely to be dwarfed by the much higher number of total cases that haven't been confirmed. Between this study, the LA study, and the Santa Clara study there could be 10-80x as many cases. That is more significant that the death count being off by a couple percent when it comes to determining the fatality rate.