4 ms·
Way down in the article, it describes some data that was not included in its analysis but nevertheless is quite interesting, where several people in a restauran
by tzs 7y ago
Way down in the article, it describes some data that was not included in its analysis but nevertheless is quite interesting, where several people in a restaurant were infected by one other patron.
This is something straight out of a TV crime show:
> As the authors note, the restaurant in question was air-conditioned on the date in question. Using video footage, they were able to chart the position of every diner in the restaurant, and then map their subsequent infection status in relation to both the single infected individual known to be present at the time and the air conditioning system’s outgoing and intake streams. If the primary transmission mode of COVID-19 were by small, sub-Flüggian airborne particles, the presence of the forced air convection might have made the environment safer (especially since “smear samples from the air conditioner [itself] were all [COVID-19] nucleotide negative”). But the researchers instead found evidence for the opposite: “The key factor for infection was the direction of the airflow,” with downstream individuals being most at risk—a result consistent with the thesis that COVID-19 is transmitted primarily through the ballistic transmission of large respiratory droplets.
I could easily imagine that having been a key insight in an episode of "Bones" or "Elementary".
(If you are looking for something good to binge watch during COVID "stay at home", I recommend "Elementary", currently on Hulu and CBS All Access. It's a Sherlock Holmes set in modern times series. They did a really good job of taking many characters and plots from the original stories and adapting them in such a way that if you read the stories you will recognize them and perhaps even think you know what is going to happen--but they have changed just enough that the ending will still surprise you but also be eminently reasonable in hindsight. The stories that aren't obviously based on any particular original are equally good).
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWait a minute. > But the researchers instead found evidence for the opposite: “The key factor for infection was the direction of the airflow,” with downstream individuals being most at risk—a result consistent with the thesis that COVID-19 is transmitted primarily through the ballistic transmission of large respiratory droplets. If the direction of airflow is the key factor, then the droplets have to be moving with the airflow, and therefore not ballistic. Am I missing something?
- derkha 7y agoI believe the reasoning is that aerosol would have ultimately spread everywhere, including on the AC itself, while ballistics can be heavily influenced by airflow, but are still limited in range.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- uoaei 7y agoI think the definition of ballistic means that gravity is the dominant force governing its path through space. So if it is "heavily influenced" by airflow it is by definition not ballistic. Then again, it's not aerosolized as it didn't diffuse homogenously into the space. It's somewhere in between.
- MereInterest 7y agoEh, different fields can have different definitions for the same word, and that's okay. If I tell a chemist that carbon is a metal, I would get a funny look. If I tell an astrophysicist that carbon is a metal, it is perfectly reasonable. Within the field of astronomy, metals are any element other than hydrogen and helium. There may be a similar difference in definitions here
- tricolon 7y agoFor those who are curious, you can read more here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metallicity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metallicity
- cameldrv 7y agoYou've really got three regimes. Really big things are ballistic in your sense that the dominant force is gravity. Smaller things are also sensitive to bulk air movement. Really small things aren't affected much by gravity, and brownian motion is more important. When these guys are saying "ballistic", they mean that the droplet is big enough that gravity is important, and that it's going to hit the ground in a reasonable amount of time and not hang around in the air until convection/diffusion spread it evenly throughout the room.
- mattm 7y agoThat's almost exactly the description of a scene from the 90s movie "Outbreak" where Dustin Hoffman follows a vent in a hospital to learn that the virus is airborne.
- creaghpatr 7y agoMight even be where they got the idea.
- andy_ppp 7y agoSo droplet size is very important for spreading then, implies wearing a mask will be quite effective at preventing you from contaminating other people...