3 ms·
Yeah, no... I'm not jumping down that rabbithole of thought-terminating cliches. HN is already replete with countless tiresome retreads of the same slippery slo
by krapp 7y ago
Yeah, no... I'm not jumping down that rabbithole of thought-terminating cliches. HN is already replete with countless tiresome retreads of the same slippery slope arguments around freedom of speech, censorship, social media policies, whether truth even exists, Voltaire quotes and Orwell references. Feel free to browse if that's what you're looking for, they all devolve into the same unproductive quagmire.
- subhobroto 7y agoAn echo chamber sure feels good. This is what I know - SARS-COV2 is novel and not even highly trained, world renowned infectious diseases experts know how it behaves and how to treat it. I don't, for a second, believe Youtube has figured that one out. Now whether you have decided to reject all competing hypothesis to something you have already decided to be the truth so you can move on with your life and be productive in areas you find valuable - that's your call but if I see you foisting your opinions on what kind of content I get to see, that's you infringing on my freedom and we have a problem.
- viridian 7y agoThere's some irony in you refusing to engage with thought terminating cliches when your original post that kicked this sub-thread off was "Yes. But liars, cranks and con artists should be oppressed."
- krapp 7y agoMaybe it is, but almost no one who asks "but who decides x" in these threads is actually interested in debating the matter. They typically already believe no one should be allowed to decide, and they have no intention of actually engaging you in conversation beyond lecturing, berating and snark. Learning when to step away from such fruitless pseudo-debates before wasting hours on the online equivalent of beating one's head against a brick wall is a valuable survival skill here. Sometimes it's best to simply state your opinion and move on.
- subhobroto 7y ago> almost no one who asks "but who decides x" in these threads is actually interested in debating the matter. They typically already believe no one should be allowed to decide I take you up on that offer. Let us, for a moment, discuss this. To disconnect us both from the exact matter at hand, because we are likely at this point pretty attached strongly to our biases to it, let us step aside, choose a completely different topic and hypothesize that our debate is on "should the government be allowed to track crimminals moving about in society". I propose, that yes, murderers should be tracked at all times, as they move about in society, with tracking devices embedded onto their ankles. You propose, no, no one, including murderers should be tracked at any time. I then propose that murderers should be given a choice between been tracked, or have their pictures and descriptions published on a public website where anyone interested in staying away from murderers can check in. What's your next move?
- throwaway2048 7y agoContext matters, removing context entirely and grafting it onto an almost entirely dissimilar situation is stupid.
- joshuamorton 7y agoTo echo the other response: When did YouTube become a government? The context is different. No matter what YouTube does, I can still host my own video.
- subhobroto 7y ago> I can still host my own video Youtube has become so large precisely because this is a very difficult problem to solve. Putting up content on a webserver is not a Youtube competitor.
- joshuamorton 7y ago> Putting up content on a webserver is not a Youtube competitor. Is anyone preventing me, by force or law, from hosting video on my own website? If not, you cannot compare government mandated anything with market forces. All you're saying here is that youtube is a really good product. That doesn't make obvious competitors "not count".