5 ms·
> A lot of the Etsy engineers seemed to find this fascinating. I think the main reason for this is that they run in a data center and control their own hardware
by OJFord 7y ago
> A lot of the Etsy engineers seemed to find this fascinating. I think the main reason for this is that they run in a data center and control their own hardware
I'm shocked that Etsy, then or now, is at a scale where that's even close to making sense, that it would even be a discussion.
I wonder if it still is, I don't know how its size has changed over the intervening seven years, but with the explosion in popularity of I/P aaS I think it would be even more surprising today.
- bichiliad 7y agoThis is fairly old at this point; we were in the process of migrating to the cloud for several years and completed the bulk of the effort recently: https://cloud.google.com/press-releases/2020/0219/etsy-completes-migration https://cloud.google.com/press-releases/2020/0219/etsy-compl...
- breakingcups 7y agoDo you have any insights into performance or cost difference?
- bichiliad 7y agoNot strictly, and I'm not sure what's public knowledge and what isn't, but as I understand it the biggest win was being able to scale quickly (especially during the holiday season) without having to put in orders for hardware months in advance. As I understand it, cost wasn't a driving factor in the migration. I think with regards to performance, it's a bit hard; comparing a cloud-native solution to a custom solution running on a VM on a server you manage can be really tough to compare.
- dx034 7y agoOwn data center rarely makes sense. Colocation can work out well for companies with a lot of demand where one location is sufficient. Dedicated servers (where you don't own the hardware) can make sense pretty quickly, the cost of managing that can be lower than cloud offerings even for mid-sized companies. PAAS or IAAS didn't really change that. Once you have a certain size, having your own department to manage hardware isn't that expensive in comparison.
- carapace 7y agoSometime these decision are made because, say, the co-founder/CTO just loves his machines.
- atom_enger 7y agoThis used to be true but we are now 95%~ in Google Cloud.
- trca 7y agoWe're almost entirely migrated into GCP now, roughly 95% done. Here's a CodeAsCraft article from when we started the project in 2018 about how we selected GCP vs AWS or Azure, and what the expected effort to migrate would be: https://codeascraft.com/2018/01/04/selecting-a-cloud-provider/ https://codeascraft.com/2018/01/04/selecting-a-cloud-provide...