3 ms·
With a total energy output of 10^44 Joules, it seems odd to exclaim over "500 times brighter!" I guess supernovae all exist in a very narrow band of energies?
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
With a total energy output of 10^44 Joules, it seems odd to exclaim over "500 times brighter!" I guess supernovae all exist in a very narrow band of energies?
- ben_w 7y agoOne particular class of supernova is used as a standard candle for determining the distances to other galaxies.
- SiempreViernes 7y agoYeah, but that uses carefully calibrated relations with the time evolution at different filters to significantly decrease the the observed spread in luminosity. Also, here they don't report on a Type Ia supernova (the ones useable as standard candles because we ain't got anything else).
- SiempreViernes 7y agoThat statement means that range of energies extends over two orders of magnitude at least, I'm not sure if I'd call that a "narrow" range...
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoAfter 44 zeros... On a log scale, which seems sensible to use for things like this, one is 44 and the other 46.2? or something like that.
- enkid 7y agoWouldn't brightness have a cube root relationship to energy, because it radiates into space? That would make it 125 million times more energetic. Edit: Rereading the article, it seems it's only one order of magnitude higher than a normal explosion? I clearly am out of my depth on this one, because that doesn't make sense to me.
- btilly 7y agoWouldn't brightness have a cube root relationship to energy, because it radiates into space? No. The light actually expands in a 2-D wave. So it falls off as the square of distance. But if we consider 2 sources near each other, they both spread out the same amount by the time they get to us. Therefore there is a linear relationship between energy and apparent brightness. (On top of the inverse square relationship to distance.) Hopefully this helps!