3 ms·
I think from a medical perspective, it's between using a ventilator to give them a 10% chance of survival or letting them just die. No doctor can ethically just
by tootie 7y ago
I think from a medical perspective, it's between using a ventilator to give them a 10% chance of survival or letting them just die. No doctor can ethically just not even try to save a life.
- jgalt212 7y agoI think that's the decision they are making now, but I think in earlier days, when less was known, ventilators were seen an extreme, but still necessary tool.
- gedy 7y agoBut my understanding is also that current ventilator protocols are/were maybe too aggressive with COVID? E.g. blood oxygen below some %, they need ventilator.
- malandrew 7y agoPossible. My understanding is that blood clotting is showing up in the lungs in autopsies. Vent settings set too high can rip apart the alveoli.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI was reading just yesterday that clotting was showing up in several places, not just the lungs. Covid seems to do something to make blood more clot-prone, and they were looking at using blood thinners to help that aspect of the problem. So it may not be the fault of the ventilators being set too high.
- Trasmatta 7y agoDo we have any evidence that it is actually giving them that 10% chance, or are the people that survive on the ventilators just the same ones that would have survived without it?
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoIs there any possible way we could test for that? I suppose we could look at retrospectives of those who weren't given treatment during triage, but I imagine they probably are given less of the peripheral support as well once the decision has been made.
- kerkeslager 7y agoOn the contrary, sometimes the ethical thing for doctors to do is to not try to save a life. The Hippocratic Oath says "First, do no harm"[1], and sometimes it's harmful to try to save a person's life with interventions that decrease quality of life, especially when those interventions have a low probability of success. [1] Actually, the Hippocratic Oath doesn't say that, but I think not doing harm is more relevant to the modern social contract of being a doctor than the actual Hippocratic Oath is. The original contains promises to not use a knife on someone (so no modern surgery) and to never give a woman a pessary to cause an abortion (technically modern abortion doctors follow this because that's not how abortions are done now, but they're certainly not following the spirit of the oath).
- DanBC 7y ago> No doctor can ethically just not even try to save a life. There's a culture in the US of trying all treatment, even if it's hopeless. That's why "how doctors die" keeps getting discussion on HN. Doctors do not want this for themselves, and they don't really want it for their patients, but they're forced into it by the systems in which they work. https://hn.algolia.com/?q=how+doctors+die https://hn.algolia.com/?q=how+doctors+die Some other places don't have that. They have the concept of "a good death". If you're almost certainly going to die then is it better to do so in peace, or would you rather have someone breaking your ribs and maybe puncturing a lung to give you maybe a 1 in 100 chance of living for an extra two weeks? Talk to your family about how you want to die. Create advance directives ("living wills") and make sure people know where it is. In the UK this is a useful site: https://compassionindying.org.uk/making-decisions-and-planning-your-care/scotland/advance-directives/make-advance-directive/ https://compassionindying.org.uk/making-decisions-and-planni... https://compassionindying.org.uk/library/ https://compassionindying.org.uk/library/