5 ms·
I never understood why Intel gave up on smartphone chips. I remember thinking at the time how that would bite them in the next 10 years. I had an ASUS ZenFone
by dangus 7y ago
I never understood why Intel gave up on smartphone chips. I remember thinking at the time how that would bite them in the next 10 years.
I had an ASUS ZenFone 2 powered by Intel. It was fantastic! I didn’t notice any problems or major slowness compared to a Qualcomm chip. To me it seemed like they had a competent product they could iterate on. And they just canceled the program, how short-sighted!
I mean, maybe I’m wrong here and there isn’t really money in that business.
- wolfgke 7y agoIntel was actually subsidizing smartphone vendors who wanted to use Intel chips. Unluckily hardly any smartphone vendor wanted to react to this offer (except some small experiments like the mentioned ASUS ZenFone 2).
- stonemetal12 7y agoI get thinking phones were to small of a market or margins were too thin back then. But you would think when the smart phone market got bigger and prices went up someone would have re-evaluated that decision.
- sgerenser 7y agoPeople also forget that Intel had a pretty decent line of ARM CPUs right before the time the iPhone was released (XScale). And they gave up on those too, just in time for the market for smartphone CPUs to explode.
- pavlov 7y agoNot only pretty decent — XScale was the best and fastest ARM for PDA-size devices. The only reason Intel killed XScale was that it wasn't x86, it came through an acquisition, and they were afraid to cannibalize their own x86-based mobile plans. Turns out it would have been far better to disrupt yourself rather than let others do it.
- DeathArrow 7y agoWeird since Intel tried themselves to kill x86 with IA-64.
- saagarjha 7y agoIntel tried to replace x86 with Itanium. XScale was just a thing they did on the side.
- btian 7y agoBecause they won't have to share IA-64 with AMD. ARM has many other licensees so Intel didn't want to continue
- baybal2 7y agoIA-64 is the "INTEL Architecture 64", xScale is the non-Intel architecture. A childish NIH driven decision that destroyed their future.
- gok 7y agoTheir hearts were never really in XScale. Intel only ended up having that group due to a bizarre legal settlement with DEC, and pawned it off to Marvell in some misguided attempt at corporate streamlining.
- aidenn0 7y agoShould also point out that the lead on the DEC StrongARM (which became Intel XScale) was Dan Dobberpuhl, who founded PASemi, which Apple bought to help their own chip development work. In between he also co-founded SiByte which made some of the best MIPS chips ever made.
- ksec 7y ago>I never understood why Intel gave up on smartphone chips. Margins. They were far too focused on margin they didn't realise their moat were cracked once they let go of it. 1 Billion+ of Smartphone / Tablet SoC, Modem and many other silicon pieces are now Fabbed on TSMC. None of these exist 10 years ago. Just like the PC revolution, while Sun and IBM were enjoying the Workstation and Server marketing booming, x86 took over the PC market segment, and slowly over the years took over server market. The same could happen to Intel, this time it is ARM and will likely take 10 -15 years. And I keep seeing the same thing happening over and over again, companies were too focused on their current market and short term benefits and margins they fail to see the bigger picture. Both Microsoft and Intel are similar here. ( And many other non tech companies. )
- DeathArrow 7y ago>Both Microsoft and Intel are similar here. ( And many other non tech companies. ) Microsoft kind of moved from their traditional market. Now they make more money from services and cloud.
- _bxg1 7y agoThey missed the boat on mobile, though, by focusing too much on Windows
- DeathArrow 7y agoThat's a big list of those who missed the mobile boat: Microsoft, Intel, RIM, Nokia, HP, MIPS, Sony, HTC And this are just the few of the big players. And even if Microsoft lost with Windows on phones, they still try to make apps. I am currently using Edge on Android because its built in ad block is quite good.
- DeathArrow 7y ago>I never understood why Intel gave up on smartphone chips. They didn't sell enough. Phone makers, software developers and users settled on ARM.
- Grazester 7y agoSoftware developers? A large percentage of those developers would not have known the difference since these phones ran Android and the VM abstracted this away. Only for games and some other apps that use the NDK would this have made a difference.
- kube-system 7y agoARM was well established for smartphones and handheld computers well before the HTC Dream ever existed.
- Grazester 7y agoI don't understand this comment. Who is talking about when ARM was established? Android runs on the vast majority of the world's smartphones and smart devices TODAY and was compatible with intel's(x86) mobile processor. That would have been enough of a market. edit:// I am commenting on the ASUS ZenFone 2 which has the intel processor running ANDORID, fyi.
- ashtonkem 7y agoExecutives are regularly incentivized to focus on short term profits over long term company survival. I call this process “bonuses today, layoffs tomorrow”.