10 ms·
UK’s Investigatory Powers Act is set to expand
- samizdis 7y ago> Taken together, the requests reflect exactly what critics of the Investigatory Powers Act feared would happen: that a once-shocking power that was granted on the back of terrorism fears is being slowly extended to even the most obscure government agency for no reason other that it will make bureaucrats' lives easier. > None of the agencies would be required to apply for warrants to access people’s internet connection data, and they would be added to another 50-plus agencies that already have access, including the Food Standards Agency, Gambling Commission, and NHS Business Services Authority.
- digikazi 7y agoI find this deeply worrying, but among the people I work with and my immediate circle of friends and acquaintances I am in the minority. In my experience, people just don't care that much (a fact which I find very, very sad and troubling). My partner for example who is an otherwise intelligent woman doesn't really care - her 12 year old son even less so. In fact, I'm pretty sure he will be part of the generation that will grow up to regard privacy as some sort of slightly weird, exotic commodity. I grew up behind the Iron Curtain, and for a chunk of my life we lived with this sort of government intrusion - nay, we expected it. We expected letters from abroad to be opened and read, we expected telephone calls to be listened to and so on. Obviously, there was no judicial oversight. I remember we looked at the West with something akin to awe and longing: in the West, they don't read your mail, they don't snoop on your calls and sure as st they don't confiscate subversive magazines sent from abroad. It was like a fairy tale; in the West, they took your rights seriously. 30 years on, I look at the UK, my adopted home like a lover who fell out of love with the object of his desire. It turns out that when presented with the technical means to do so, the West is just as keen to eavesdrop and hoover up all your data: emails, phone calls, text messages, the lot. Freedom and privacy are like a sausage comrades: you keep slicing at it until there's nothing left!
- aivisol 7y agoI share your pain, having similar background. It is probably not technical means, they always existed, the telephones could be listened to, and letters could be always opened. Forgetting the history and not learning from it. The West has lived in more or less peaceful democracy since WW2, two full generations have changed, and the memory has faded. We, easterners are still the generation which grew up in totalitarian regimes, we do still remember it.
- zaarn 7y agoOn the other hand, Poland and Ukraine are currently going down the path of forming a totalitarian regime, so I'm not sure if this holds as much in practise.
- caskstrength 7y agoCan you elaborate regarding "totalitarian regime" in Ukraine? I don't like our current president and didn't vote for him, but I don't see anything totalitarian about him.
- zaarn 7y agoMostly blocking the EU from doing anything about Poland, which is deep in there, and heading there itself (and Poland blocking the EU from doing anything about that). It's not as bad as poland yet but it's getting there, slowly.
- caskstrength 7y agoSorry but it is very hard to understand anything in your comment. Ukraine is blocking EU from doing something about Poland? How? Ukraine is not in EU and can't block anything. Also, it seems you are not willing to expand on "getting there"...
- aivisol 7y agoDoes Poland implement surveillance of their citizens in any excessive way? Just asking, as I do not know. The fact that the government is right-wing alone does not automatically mean it is going down the path of totalitarianism.
- thombat 7y agoA celebrated example was the use of the freshly-minted "Prevention of Terrorism Act" to stop an old man heckling the Foreign Secretary: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1499466/Heckler-82-who-dared-called-Straw-a-liar-is-held-under-terrorist-law.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1499466/Heckler-82-w... Notably in that case the police yet again reflexively denied actually using the power: "At first Sussex police denied that Mr Wolfgang had been detained or searched but a spokesman later admitted that he had been issued with a section 44 stop and search form under the Terrorism Act." which rather suggests that they used as a convenient way to stop the government being embarrassed, as opposed to its proper use of frustrating serious crime (if they really thought he was a terrorist he'd have been processed with more diligence).
- einpoklum 7y agoThis is exactly why the position to adopt w.r.t. government spying powers is that _it should not have any_. Yes, even if that makes it easier for theoretical terrorists or pedophiles or what-not. That threat is far lower than the certainty of oppressive use of this powers by government.
- jstanley 7y agoIronically: > the British government is asking that five more public authorities be added to the list of bodies that can access data scooped up under the nation's mass-surveillance laws: [including] the UK National Authority for Counter Eavesdropping (UKNACE)
- White_Wolf 7y agoSo the only way to keep my data safe is to rent a VPN in a country that don't get along with the "n eyes" countries. Wanna guess how many options are left ?
- naringas 7y agologging out... going offline. unplugging your computer from the internet ?? but then it is not so useful
- sterlind 7y agoUsing e.g. a Slovenian VPN won't help much if you're still accessing sites within the five eyes. You're still using HTTPS presumably.. the only thing VPNs would hide is what websites you visit, and if those are hosted in the US they can scoop up your traffic straight from the beam splitter. The real danger is IC getting at the data in your accounts, which VPNs won't help with.
- dylkil 7y agoyou cannot verify your data is safe using a vpn
- choeger 7y agoPoliticians and bureaucrats love the stuff that China does. So they want to have the same toys. They will never constrain themselves with stupid issues like human rights. And of course they will use these powers to our disadvantage. Sooner or later people will notice this. But tragically at that point there will be no way back except for violance. I make this sad prediction: The current trend to ever more oppression worldwide will backlash in violence. It might be that we will witness bureaucrats hang.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 7y agoIt's very rare for people to rise up against their leaders when they have food. Since food is so very cheap in todays world, a country has to be in a very dire economic position before the government can't provide the people food and they overthrow it. Even so, most governments will happily use their army against their own people, and with modern weapons being so efficient, even failing to feed your people doesn't necessarily lead to a change in government. Modern governments are very stable, except for outside influence.
- choeger 7y agoI do not think it is a matter of food. I think that an oppressive regime will inevitably decrease the conditions for the poor masses. Look at how poor black people are massively overrepresented in US prisons. I think this is caused by the simple fact that the oppression takes the path of the least resistance. Now combine this with city-wide riots and you have a recipe for a "nothing left to lose" situation that could quickly escalate.
- JoeSmithson 7y agoThe Register has an annoying habit of using very loose language that has the effect of overstating surveillance powers. For example; "And lastly, the Pensions Regulator, which checks that companies have added their employees to their pension schemes, need to be able to delve into anyone’s emails so it can “secure compliance and punish wrongdoing.” The phrase "delve into anyone's emails" here is an absurd mischaracterisation
- 8957a7e865c41c 7y agoYep. Anything that implies 'direct access' or 'trawling' moves from being fear mongering to simply being untrue. 'Rifling through emails' and the like is showing a poor understanding of the legislation at best and deliberately trying to create fear uncertainty and doubt at worse.
- dTal 7y agoWould you care to expand on exactly why you perceive that to be an inaccurate description?
- DanBC 7y agoIn RIPA "Communications data" is explicitly not the content of the messages, it's the meta-data. The Register have a good story if they focus on that access to metadata -- I don't think organisations should have access to meta-data without justification. But they haven't done that, they've said "rifling through your emails" and the implication (see other comments in this thread) is that this means access to the content of the email. That's untrue, it's misleading, and it's yet another example of piss-poor quality reporting from the Register derailing a thread by generating very many comments that miss the point.
- kwhitefoot 7y agoI don't want people reading the metadata either. And what is the definition of metadata? Is it just email addresses and dates or is the subject line included? Does it include any data extracted from email such as the names of other people or links to web sites? Does it just have web server IP addresses or the URLs and if the URLs does it have referrers as well. Exactly where is the line drawn? And yes El Reg is scare mongering as usual, but at least they stirred up some debate.
- Hoasi 7y agoWhat's the official justification behind this? First, it was terrorism, then maybe a pandemic, what's next? It was all so predictable, and yet so little has been done to prevent this. Apathy is a powerful tool, how depressing. What would be some practical solutions since democracy doesn't seem to prevent this from happening?
- JoeSmithson 7y agoThe justification is linked prominently in TFA http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukdsi/2020/9780111195499/pdfs/ukdsiod_9780111195499_en.pdf http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukdsi/2020/9780111195499/pdfs/...
- Hoasi 7y agoYes, and it's very vague indeed: crime, risks and hazards, and fraudulent activities. These are terms that governmental organizations can use as they see fit, depending on the situation.
- thombat 7y agoIndeed it is: "These regulations include the addition of five public authorities who will gain the power to obtain communications data as they are increasingly unable to rely on local police forces to investigate crimes on their behalf." It isn't obvious to me that the proper fix for the police being inadequately resourced for investigating crimes is to grant policing powers to a wider range of departments. In principle the police receive both specialist training and supervision to ensure that their powers are properly used; abusive use of the earlier RIPA legislation by councils became notorious, e.g: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/3333366/Half-of-councils-use-anti-terror-laws-to-spy-on-bin-crimes.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/3333366/Half-of-coun...
- ljm 7y agoThis is likely a consequence of the Conservative government continually stripping police funding over the past ten years. I would presume local police forces could handle these requests if they had adequate resources to do so. They frequently do not.
- Havoc 7y agoFull steam ahead to a brave new world. No guessing involved either thanks to China
- seemslegit 7y agoGood thing this is being tried first in a nation that is pretty much guaranteed to sit and take it.
- 867-5309 7y agodidn't realise you represented the entirety of the UK. those who wish to remain anonymous will always find a way to do so. those who don't mind herd security / crowdsourced policing will continue not to mind
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoWhat country wouldn't though? I mean, take the US which literally allows people to have guns to rise up against the government, but they don't because they're too busy spreading their attention between the three jobs they need to make ends meet and pay off their student loan / medical bills and the ten streaming services or 24 hour news networks that demand what little remains of their attention.
- 8957a7e865c41c 7y ago>None of the agencies would be required to apply for warrants to access people’s internet connection data This is misleading. All requests for any kind of Communications Data require authorisation [1] and need to outline necessity, proportionality and collateral intrusion, including details of less intrusive means already tried. This is a similar process to the warrant application process - the difference is that a Warrant is authorised by the Secretary of State (the Home Secretary) whereas the CD authorisation is granted by the Investigatory Powers commissioner - previously Sir Adrian Fulford and currently Lord Justice Levison. To say that any agency can get without a warrant is misleading. Also, none of the agencies cited (Food Standards Agency, Gambling Commission and NHS Business Services Authority) will have the authority to request to ICRs [3]. [1] https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/office-for-communications-data-authorisations https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/office-for-commu... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Leveson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Leveson [3] https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2016/25/section/62/enacted https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2016/25/section/62/enac...
- hlandau 7y agoWho do you represent? The "warrants" offered by the IPA are meaningless and undeserving of the name, given that they're issued by the Secretary of State and not a court. The "judicial commissioner" process is equally farcical, since it basically just ensures the SoS filled out the paperwork correctly. What is notably absent from any of this is a judge making any finding of evidential basis for warrant issuance, which is supposed to be the very premise of a warrant. For a particularly amusing example of this, consider the fact that the new UK-USA CLOUD Act cooperation forced the UK to create a new kind of warrant which, unlike all other IP warrants in the UK, requires the involvement of an actual judge. I guess the US looked at the UK's notion of a "warrant" and was having none of it. Ironically, this means the UK is actually holding itself to a higher standard when asking other countries for data than when doing so domestically. The requirement for "proportionality" is equally farcical. This is, as I understand it, a result of the ECHR striking down previous legislation on the grounds that it is not "proportional". The UK's "solution" to this is, AIUI, to add a line to the law saying "any usage must be proportional". It says it has to be proportional, thus it's proportional, right?
- LatteLazy 7y agoI'm not normally a libertarian but... There is nothing quite so permanent as temporary government powers.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoThis is true; the UK has suffered under "temporary" austerity measures for over a decade now as well, in practice it means the poor get poorer and the rich get richer, while the health care system is underfunded culminating now in a pandemic for which they don't have the means to handle. It's been a short-term cost-cutting measure that is now basically killing people and damaging the economy, on top of what Brexit already cost them. But hey, a handful of people made a bit of money off of it, it was totally worth it.
- easytiger 7y ago> This is true; the UK has suffered under "temporary" austerity measures for over a decade now as well, in practice it means the poor get poorer and the rich get richer, while the health care system is underfunded culminating now in a pandemic for which they don't have the means to handle Laughable number of mischaracterisations in there. Focused entirely on oft repeated spurious memetically distributed fake news items. Which no doubt you would Google and paste to support your assertions. Political hatchery 101
- DanBC 7y agoThe Register, as they usually do, have chosen to put the most sensationalist slant on this possible. "communications data" does not mean the content of the message. Communications data is strictly about the meta-data. None of these organisations are given access to the content of messages. And intercepts (the actual contents of the messages) are inadmissible in court.
- monkeynotes 7y agoWhat is concerning about the UK is how apathetic the general public is to all this stuff. They have already accepted they need to opt into adult websites and continue to vote for authoritarian govt. I don't think this is unique to the UK, it's just the UK is at the forefront overt public surveillance. CCTV has been extensive in the UK since the early 90s. Fighting crime with the "if you aren't doing anything wrong, you don't need to worry" Orwellian attitude is generally accepted.
- BTinfinity 7y agoI agree with the second part of your comment, but the opt in for adult websites was dropped over fears it wouldn't be effective. [1] [1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-50073102 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-50073102
- jen20 7y agoAlso, I don’t think this crosses people’s mind when they vote. The U.K. effectively once again has a two party system, and at the last two elections no real choice at all, given the complete lack of functioning opposition. Thinking wishfully perhaps, now the opposition has a reasonable leader again, politics should become about policy again.
- dataduck 7y agoDoes anyone know of a co-ordinated political opposition to RIPA, and how to support it?
- motohagiography 7y agoThere isn't a reasonable argument that will change this. Hate to say it, but you just have to recognize the people who advocate it and socially isolate them. While the police became militarized, the public service have became a cluster of policing agencies, but without any of the limitations of powers or the accountability.