4 ms·
So no requirement for parachutes in planes, then? They’ve never been proven in a double blind study.
by taneq 7y ago
So no requirement for parachutes in planes, then? They’ve never been proven in a double blind study.
- heretoo 7y agoThey don't block 100% of the air, so they can't possibly be effective.
- barry-cotter 7y agoProven in a double blind study is not the only method of proof. You can also use model organisms. So you throw goats out of airplanes with and without automatically opening parachute ave see what happens. Or you can have an extremely good grasp on the mechanism of action of what you’re doing. Somewhere on Earth today a complicated piece of machinery is being fabricated and assembled that has never existed before and is going to be 90% as good as the final production version. Multiple methods of proof of varying reliabilities exist.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoEpidemics are something for which the mechanism of action is fairly well understood. The exact response of R to various measures is not known beforehand, but we can make decent guesses about what will reduce transmission.
- makomk 7y agoThe details of the epidemic matter, though. For example, closing schools is a fairly obvious intervention in flu epidemics - kids are really likely to get it and bring it home to their families, especially since they don't have the immunity that some adults might. It may actually be completely useless in this epidemic. Whilst kids can be infected, they generally seem to have very mild cases and there's some evidence they're no good at passing the infection on to others.
- zamfi 7y ago> there's some evidence they're no good at passing the infection on to others May I ask: What evidence of this did you find convincing? From my own digging it seemed like this was a claim from China, which merely indicated that it was rare that, in a family, the child got it first and gave it others. However, when the epidemic really started taking off, it was the middle of CNY and kids weren't in school, which could completely account for why they didn't observe child->adult transmission. I'd love to be wrong about this, though.
- nl 7y agoThe China evidence was fairly compelling (they did contact tracing and were unable to find a single case where the child was the transmitter). Schools didn't close in Australia (although many parents kept their children at home). There have been zero cases traced to child transmission, even in a few cases where a teacher or worker at a school got it from another place and brought it to school and those individual schools had to be closed. There was a single cluster based around a school in Sydney but it was found to be parent-to-parent transmission. Singapore didn't close schools during their early phase (until 2 weeks ago) and contact traced every single case. Zero were attributable to child-to-child contact. It's possible this is all luck though.
- sundvor 7y agoSchools in Australia are closed now, not reopening since Easter break. Kinders (preschool child daycare centers) remain open, and are now free - 100% paid for by the government.
- nl 7y agoIt's the school holidays in many states (I'm Australian). All schools will open for term 2, with Victoria and the ACT saying parents should prefer to keep children at home when possible while the other states are advising there will be more face-to-face[1]. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/apr/13/are-schools-open-closed-term-2-australia-coronavirus-easter-holidays https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/apr/13/are-s...
- marvin 7y agoWell, yes. But there's not enough time right now to do that goat study, and that's what we're advocating if we want to follow science to the exclusion of common sense.
- BjoernKW 7y agoThere’s both inductive and deductive reasoning. A fact can be proven be mere logical reasoning. I don’t need a double blind study in that case because gravity has been proven before and there’s no reason to assume it doesn’t apply to everybody (or rather every body) alike.
- benibela 7y agoThere has been a randomized controlled trial to test if parachutes reduce injuries when jumping out of planes. However, it found that parachutes do not reduce injuries: https://www.bmj.com/content/363/bmj.k5094 https://www.bmj.com/content/363/bmj.k5094