3 ms·
One interpretation of that as a strategy is "in a crisis with imperfect information we should centralise all power to popular people". If someone working to ev
by roenxi 7y ago
One interpretation of that as a strategy is "in a crisis with imperfect information we should centralise all power to popular people".
If someone working to evidence (ie, science) can't make good decisions how on earth will strong leadership help? We've seen crisises that led to actual war time situations (pretty much all the wars in the Middle East, particularly when recently the 'strong leadership' in the US when they speculated wrongly that Saddam Hussein had WMDs) where with benefit of hindsight the entire planet would probably have been better off with weaker leaders, more evidence and people just sticking to their normal routines.
Centralising power without a proven strategy is going to lead to more misses than hits. Even now, we don't know what the endgame here is. The lockdowns could still conceivably be failures if they turn out to have delayed all the deaths by 12 months instead of preventing them. We don't know. It is too early to say what did or didn't work.
- EmilioMartinez 7y ago>evidence (ie, science) An abrupt leap. I would move away from a passing vehicle without peer-reviewing its existence. If international and inter-city travel had been shut down in early February some nations would have remained fully functional today. Not to say I agree with current quarantines, but you have to admit there are thresholds for action. I'd like to know your stance on climate change, btw.
- Retric 7y agoScience generalizes into engineering etc, so not everything needs to be peer reviewed. Without the germ model of disease aka science, we would be thinking about Coronavirus very differently. Thousands of years of human history and massive epidemics show how bad following common wisdom based on incorrect models can be.
- cycomanic 7y ago>>evidence (ie, science) >An abrupt leap. Not at all, it seems more that you have a wrong conception what science means. Science is all about evidence, the scientific method is to make observations, then inductive hypotheses that are then tested. All this relies on using evidence. Peer review is one process how evidence can be evaluated, but definitely not the only one. Science is much older than peer review.
- EmilioMartinez 7y agoWe agree on what science means, and my point stands. Swift decisions needed to be made in February.
- roenxi 7y agocycomanic says it better than I; science is not much more than the systematic creation and review of evidence. It isn't easy but it isn't usually very exciting. There would be a scientific consensus that you should get out of the way of a passing vehicle without any need for peer review. > I'd like to know your stance on climate change, btw. * Never seen an explanation that convinced me I, my descendants or anyone I know could be at risk from climate change. Particularly after calibrating expectations on the huge amount of background risk over 100 years. Climate change is less threatening than other alternatives over the century (eg, WWIII US/China for economic reasons, peak oil/returning to a pre-fossil-fuel standard of living, maybe it turns out some sort of 1:100 year solar storm takes out the communications grid, plain overpopulation). * Society could have gone nuclear at any point from around 1970 and solved the coal part of the fossil fuel problem. I've never seen a push for that in a climate demonstration. I don't think the activists are serious about solving problems; they are more interested in making people respect their opinions. It doesn't look to me like they really perceive a threat - they havn't seen anything that scares them enough to try working with their opponents to find compromise solutions. Fukushima vs. the more far out predictions on the climate front are not even remotely comparable levels of risk. * We're much more likely to be able to solve problems if we embrace cheap energy than trying to preemptively guess at and mitigate uncertain threats.
- EmilioMartinez 7y agoI just mentioned peer-review as an absurd example. I never equated it to science in general, and it amazes me that it comes across that way. I still stand by my saying that equating evidence to science is an abrupt leap.