3 ms·
Given that Scientific consensus has limitations, what do you propose is better in situations where data is scarce? How does a strong leader mitigate this dange
by s1artibartfast 7y ago
Given that Scientific consensus has limitations, what do you propose is better in situations where data is scarce?
How does a strong leader mitigate this danger? Is the leader making choices by following their intuition? Does the leader make choices based on public sentiment?
- hansvm 7y agoOne possible mechanism by which strong leadership could be more effective is that inaction and uncoordinated action can be less effective than any coordinated decision, regardless of whether that decision happened to be optimal. I don't know how often this happens in a pandemic or in a political setting, but as an example from software engineering bikeshedding seems somewhat common -- it probably doesn't matter whether curly braces get a new line, but there's probably a benefit to only doing it one way in a codebase. Not that strong leadership is the only path to resolution either, even accepting that some cohesive decision needs to be made, but it does solve that class of problems.
- cycomanic 7y agoStrong leadership and science are orthogonal dimensions. You can have strong leadership that makes decisions based on evidence and scientific arguments, or not. I would argue the first is always better than the second. Again in the current crisis the decisions based on scientific evidence (pandemic models developed previously) was to act early and quickly with lots of testing. Most countries did not follow this, but I would say this had nothing to do with what the "scientific approach" was. Somehow people here conflate scientific with need to wait/establish all information. However in the end science is a method to establish truth/knowledge about the world around us. It can guide our decisions, but it's not a decision making method.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- marvin 7y agoLet me clarify. You can follow a scientific approach, and you can follow Science the ritual. When uncertainty goes up and time is of the essence, the latter is to a large degree subjected to the limitations and blind spots I highlighted. The former might not, if you adapt it to the current limitations. I am a scientist, by the way. What I mean by strong leadership is an intelligent leader that can quickly review evidence from multiple disparate fields and experts (scientists among them) and choose a good approach that takes all available constraints and uncertainties into account. The way a skilled military commander would do. In particular, such a leader does not focus exclusively on a single metric or concern, unless this is warranted by the situation. But that would be an exceptional circumstance in an exceptional situation. You may think that the focus on reducing death rates is focusing on a single metric to the exclusion of everything else, but this is not the case. There are plenty of exceptions to this rule being made in every country with a lockdown. Critical infrastructure, economics, mental health, healthcare that's unrelated to Covid19 and so on.