9 ms·
That's what some universal systems already do. I was reading up on Singapore. There is a baseline of insurance for hospital stays, but it's in a ward with 6 o
by refurb 7y ago
That's what some universal systems already do. I was reading up on Singapore. There is a baseline of insurance for hospital stays, but it's in a ward with 6 other patients in the same room.
If you want something better (and there are tiers), you pay more. You can buy insurance policies that pay for the more comfortable stay.
- hateMyIdeas 7y agoThat's not how insurance works, expensive insurance has a lower max out of pocket. What you are talking about is that rich people don't need insurance at all. They just pay out of pocket.
- robocat 7y agoThat is how health insurance works in New Zealand. If you want private health insurance for say $50 a month[1], then insurance gives access to procedures more quickly and the rooms are much nicer than the public health care system. It may give access to rare but expensive procedures. If you don’t want insurance, then the default is the public healthcare system, which is paid for by taxes. You will usually be in a ward with other patients. You pay small amounts on use (to prevent abuse, and even those amounts are reduced to nearly free if you are poor). The level of care is reasonable, but can be slow for non-urgent elective surgery, and extremely expensive procedures are not available. The public healthcare system handles ongoing chronic conditions much better than a private system could. [1] You can see a quote from https://www.southerncross.co.nz/ https://www.southerncross.co.nz/ if you give your age, gender and tick whether you smoke. Note that Southern Cross is a nonprofit co-op, most premiums get returned to members (on average, less an approx 10% administrative overhead).
- karmicthreat 7y agoThat system looks terrible for handling cancer and pre-existing conditions.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoAs opposed to one where everyone avoids medical care at all costs to avoid extortionate bills?
- missedthecue 7y agoI don't think there is any system like that in first world countries. The US isn't like that if that's what you're insinuating
- grecy 7y agoPlease look around you a little more. My buddy separated his shoulder snowboarding in Tahoe. He had a full time (40 hours a week) job at the time, but it didn't provide healthcare. He couldn't afford to go to hospital, so never did. I was visiting from Australia at the time and was utterly horrified, having no idea the US worked like that. Now years later his shoulder is still screwed. Of course people in the US avoid going if at all possible, it's horrendously expensive, and medical bills are the number one cause for bankruptcy in the US [1] In a stack of OECD countries (all the other ones?) nobody has ever gone bankrupt from medical bills, because that's impossible. [1] https://www.thebalance.com/medical-bankruptcy-statistics-4154729 https://www.thebalance.com/medical-bankruptcy-statistics-415...
- hateMyIdeas 7y agoPerson doesn't have insurance and injured themselves doing a risky activity, and can't afford treatment. If it's really bad, why not use bankruptcy, I can't imagine this person has anything valuable given the history you described. Or use physical therapy, it's cheap.
- WaylonKenning 7y agoWhat is insurance for? To cover risk of something bad happening. The bigger the pool paying for it, the less impact to any one person to cover all the risk. Now imagine that was scaled up to a whole country. That's New Zealand. Check out the Accident Compensation Corporation. All medical costs related to accidents are automatically covered! But who pays the costs! Everyone, via levies. How much? $2000 on a $150K IT income. But how do you control costs? Who is entitled? Who is at fault? Surprise! It's a no-fault accident insurance system that covers all accidents. In exchange for that, we gave up our right to sue in accidents for medical damages. Why pay a lawyer when they're not required?
- cadlin 7y agoThe most expensive plan for my family (2 parents and a young child) is $367 a month. Equivalent coverage in the US would be thousands of dollars.
- goodcanadian 7y agoI do not know the New Zealand system, but I suspect the base level of care is still covered by public funding and the insurance is only covering optional extras (like private rooms).
- int_19h 7y agoThey still pay taxes, though. Germany allows people to opt out entirely, although there are a bunch of conditions and limitations. Most people don't, so the public system can still pay for itself.
- zaarn 7y agoSadly in germany it's rather difficult to switch between public and private or no insurance. Or rather, it's very difficult to get back on a public insurance once you're private or self-insured. The best you can hope for is pulling it off once, maybe twice.
- AndrewDucker 7y agoThat doesn't seem unreasonable. If you're avoiding paying into a system because you don't want to claim from it then letting you hop back on whenever you need it would destroy the system very quickly.
- zaarn 7y agoIt's not that easy, luckily, if you're self-insured and have to take the service of a doctor, you can't switch just like that. It takes about a year of paper exchange with everyone involved to switch cleanly. Even then, any costs you started paying for from before will still have to be paid unless you're below a certain income bracket (or declare bankruptcy). So if you were self-insured and broke a leg, then decided to switch back to insurance, you'd still be on the hook for the costs of the ongoing physiotherapy until it is healed back up. The insurance doesn't have to actually pay anything that happened before a switch (switching from public to public insurance or private to private doesn't have this limit, private to public and the other way round but you don't pay, your old insurance pays).
- josinalvo 7y agoI'd wager that is by design, and one of the ways they keep people from avoiding insurance when young and healthy, and then getting it when old
- mc32 7y agoAnother place in SEAsia where it’s single payer but while everyone (legally employed persons) people who want good treatment go to private hospitals because of expertise, availability and the ability to get private rooms.
- markdown 7y agoThe same in Fiji. We have universal health care, but anyone is of course free to forego that and pay (or use their private insurance) for a private room rather than a ward, or just go to a private hospital instead. I don't understand the debate about this in the US. It's as if the rich assume that things will change for the worse for them if universal health care is enacted.
- prime_factor 7y agoWhat about middle class people who can't afford private care but fear that the socialized healthcare system will be of worse quality than what they currently have?
- virmundi 7y agoThey have a hard decision. Unlike the US they are allowed to be an adult.
- bpfrh 7y agoYou can look at austria to see that that doesn't happen. An MRI cost me about 0€. A 4000€ test which tests for nearly any rheutmatic diseases markers and the visit to the hospital for that test cost me 0€, both things got done within two weeks. Even if you are poor and want to go to a private doctor it will cost you not nearly as much as in the usa. For me it was about 100€, for one visit and that was on the higher end. Socialized healthcare is always cheaper.
- vxNsr 7y agoI can buy an out of pocket (uninsured) MRI test in the US for less than $500. With a little bit of negotiation I could probably get it down to $300. An insured MRI can be free too depending on the plan. My mom is a doctor, she worked ICU, ER, etc, board certified in 10 states and holds a medical license in 3 countries(yes, she did residency three times, it's a long fascinating story for another time). Eventually she decided to open a private practice for family medicine bec it was less stress, but she's got tons of experience, and is highly regarded, and she charged less than $40 a visit for the uninsured. She would spend ages talking patients out of procedures that were harmful or simply unnecessary. You got high end care from her each time. The gist of this is: you have no idea what you're talking about and individual anecdotes don't prove one system is better then another. I'll just add as food for thought: nothing is free, avg effective tax rate in EU is 50% Avg ETR in the US is less than 30%.