21 ms·
One thing is missing from this discussion that needs to be understood: the Swedish government and related agencies generally do not do things based on common se
by kqr 7y ago
One thing is missing from this discussion that needs to be understood: the Swedish government and related agencies generally do not do things based on common sense.
This may sound ridiculous, but in most cases, it's not. Common sense is wrong so often. The view of the Swedish government is that they are not more intelligent than the citizens. Unless things can be scientifically proved, the individual rights of citizens should not be restricted.
This permeates a lot of public policy in Sweden; I recently had reason to investigate to what extent maternal/neonatal care followed the best of our scientific knowledge and it was extremely close. If you think that's a given, think again. Many countries base their maternal/neonatal care on common sense and old wives' tales instead.
Both approaches are valid, but they are different. With policy based on common sense, you accept that you occasionally (often?) force something wrong on the public, potentially against their better knowledge. With policy based on strong evidence, you are more rarely wrong, but you also get way fewer opportunities to force things on the public, simply because there are so few things we truly know to be true. Doubly so during a novel pandemic.
- tpmx 7y ago[Am Swedish and not a fan of the current policy] This evidence-driven decision making process (which is indeed the default here) works remarkably well when things are moving slowly. It kills bullshit beautifully. This is normally something I'm quite proud about. However, it breaks down so badly when you're suddenly facing a one in a hundred years pandemic and you can't act decisively 3-4 months into the pandemic because there's no evidence yet. Sweden is "peace-damaged". We haven't really had to deal with any national-level crises the since the spanish flu about 100 years ago. The last war was in 1814. 500 soldiers died. Note that the above mostly applies to national governance - this is the stuff that really gets set into code and culture over time. At a local e.g. hospital/research unit/private company level, there's fantastic innovation happening on a daily basis, just as in the rest of the world.
- davidw 7y agoThis whole thing is kind of like driving a car, except that when you turn the steering wheel, nothing happens, and then two weeks later the wheels start to turn.
- simonh 7y agoThey admit thus in the article, when they say there’s no point closing the schools. The time when doing that would have made a difference was a month ago and they didn’t do it, so the damage was done.
- wyager 7y ago> it breaks down when you're suddenly facing a one in a hundred years pandemic What if you're not actually facing such a thing and you only think you are because the initial non-scientific estimates from government "scientists" are 2 orders of magnitude off the mark, just like the last few times? https://mobile.twitter.com/amasad/status/1252824592453742598?s=20 https://mobile.twitter.com/amasad/status/1252824592453742598...
- henrikschroder 7y agoMost countries are seeing excess mortality compared to previous years, much larger than could be explained by a bad flu year, which means that covid-19 is absolutely a real threat, we haven't seen anything like this in a hundred years, and countries should absolutely take measures to protect the population.
- makomk 7y agoThe peak mortality in the UK from this might still beat the 1989 flu epidemic, and it'd probably have done so already if it wasn't for all the lockdowns, but it hasn't officially achieved even that much yet. And our lockdown was relatively late and lax compared to a lot of other countries, so much so that it's probably still a little early to see much effect on the total mortality figures. (If you're wondering "what 1989 flu epidemic", it probably wasn't well known outside or even inside the UK except amongst people who lived through it.)
- jnbiche 7y agoI agree. The 1957 Asian Flu pandemic is widely considered to be the worst pandemic since the 1918 Spanish Flu pandemic. Most figures I see for UK deaths from the Asian Flu in 1957 range from 3500 (for just England and Wales) to 30,000 (which looks at just excess death in the entire UK). Most estimates I see for 1989 flu epidemic in the UK are around 30,000. COVID-19 death toll in the UK will almost certainly exceed the both of those death tolls. You're at 18,000 already, and you're likely not even at the peak of the curve yet. And almost certainly, we'll see a second wave come late fall and winter (sadly).
- dmurray 7y ago> Sweden is "peace-damaged". The last sort of national crisis we had besides the spanish flu was the Swedish–Norwegian War of 1814. The second World War was definitely a national crisis. Huge military mobilisation, disruption to the iron and shipping industries including thousands of sailors dead, rationing, accidental bombings...even though Sweden was neutral that was a far bigger deal for her than the coronavirus has been.
- tpmx 7y agoBesides the deaths of those sailors it was a big meh.
- cycomanic 7y ago[Am living in Sweden but not Swedish] I disagree with you that this is about a "slow evidence based decision process" (paraphrasing). That is actually the most infuriating about the policy. I have encountered this quite often here, it's a "we know better than everyone else" attitude. The thing is the story they give is "we are evidence based, rational...,have the best methods", but completely ignore scientific evidence from outside Sweden. Example 1.: asymptomatic spread, despite several countries having evidence to the contrary the story here is, it's not important (in fact they slightly changed the tune is used to be negligible or nonexistent) Example 2: the chief epidemiologist has repeatedly said he "believes" the spread will go done in summer, without significant evidence. Example 3: sometimes the statements even contradict themselves. Example masks, the story (and there is actually a lot of propaganda around this) is still they don't help, because non95 masks are not completely closed. On the other hand the recommendation from the public health agency, (same who gives advice about the masks) for health workers treating covid19 patients is either goggles +mask (often there are no Googles) or visor without mask. How can a surgical mask which is not 100% tight not help, but at the same time a visor which is open to the sides is sufficient.
- marvin 7y agoThere is a dark side to this. Scientific consensus follows certain rituals and heuristics. Even if you can assume that the scientific consensus is the closest to truth you can get (this is debatable), the approach will fail in some situations. In particular, in war-like situations where there is little published science, data is scarce, data changes fast and there are policy considerations to be made across a multitude of disparate fields - fields that can not all be quickly evaluated with the scientific method. IMHO, as I've been saying throughout this crisis, many institutions that do well in peace-time are in a terribly dangerous situation when they follow their normal heuristics and routines today. Strong top leadership (political or otherwise) can mitigate this danger.
- godelski 7y ago> the approach will fail in some situations. Well... yes. Everything does. Treating this as a non-starter could be used in literally anything. > In particular, in war-like situations where there is little published science, data is scarce, This is actually probably one of the most well researched fields in existence. I'm a little confused about this statement. What do you think they do at places like Annapolis?
- tome 7y agoI presume marvin is talking about a particular war when in progress, not the phenomenon of war in general.
- kqr 7y agoYet most strong top leaders I can name have (a) gained power during some sort of crisis, and (b) turned out to be on the wrong side of history.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoGiven that Scientific consensus has limitations, what do you propose is better in situations where data is scarce? How does a strong leader mitigate this danger? Is the leader making choices by following their intuition? Does the leader make choices based on public sentiment?
- heretoo 7y agoHowever, dealing with the novel corona virus isn't necessarily a scientific problem, but more of an engineering problem (as opposed to a problem to be solved with common sense). Science tries to remove inprecise assumptions. Engineering accepts inprecise assumptions and works around them, e.g. building in a safety factor; using masks when there is some evidence they lower R0.
- taneq 7y agoSo no requirement for parachutes in planes, then? They’ve never been proven in a double blind study.
- heretoo 7y agoThey don't block 100% of the air, so they can't possibly be effective.
- barry-cotter 7y agoProven in a double blind study is not the only method of proof. You can also use model organisms. So you throw goats out of airplanes with and without automatically opening parachute ave see what happens. Or you can have an extremely good grasp on the mechanism of action of what you’re doing. Somewhere on Earth today a complicated piece of machinery is being fabricated and assembled that has never existed before and is going to be 90% as good as the final production version. Multiple methods of proof of varying reliabilities exist.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoEpidemics are something for which the mechanism of action is fairly well understood. The exact response of R to various measures is not known beforehand, but we can make decent guesses about what will reduce transmission.
- makomk 7y agoThe details of the epidemic matter, though. For example, closing schools is a fairly obvious intervention in flu epidemics - kids are really likely to get it and bring it home to their families, especially since they don't have the immunity that some adults might. It may actually be completely useless in this epidemic. Whilst kids can be infected, they generally seem to have very mild cases and there's some evidence they're no good at passing the infection on to others.
- zamfi 7y ago
- TomMckenny 7y agoIt's not really true vs false, it's a matter of deciding what level of evidence is convincing. One point is that we already know the approximate effectiveness of social distancing from many 1918 data points and its epidemic with similar contagiousness. Some places in 1918 did it and some did not, like San Francisco vs Philadelphia where the difference was stark. Maybe the effect will be less this time for some inexplicable reason but I would not want to run the experiment in my country.
- lonelappde 7y agoDeferring decision making from experts to the common people is exactly what "common sense" is. And it's a pretty bad idea to use common sense to solve a problem that zero people alive today have ever encountered. None of have endured an unvaccinatable pandemic.
- yongjik 7y ago> Unless things can be scientifically proved, the individual rights of citizens should not be restricted. Sorry, but this doesn't make, err, common sense. If you have a huge fire, would you put off evacuation order until it is scientifically proven that an area will burn down? By the time you are sure, it's usually too late.
- mistermann 7y agoIt is not logical either - numerous exceptions can be found, including in this pandemic.
- zepto 7y agoWe already have a lot of scientific knowledge about how fires burn that we can apply to firefighting, so this is a non problem.
- dkdk8283 7y agoBut it’s exactly the kind of country I want to live in. It’s my life, my right to do what I want within reason. Within reason should err on freedom.
- lisper 7y agoYou need more than scientific knowledge in order to make policy, you also need a quality metric against which to measure the desirability of outcomes. Science can tell you what is likely to happen if you pursue a certain policy, but it cannot tell you if that outcome is good or bad, or more to the point, whether the tradeoffs inherent in any complex policy decisions are worthwhile.
- friendlybus 7y agoThis has little to do with common sense vs Science. You can easily make the scientific case towards controlling the borders and isolating, it simply hasn't been done in Sweden's case. Handwaving away the necessity for scientifically vetting the idea of closing the borders, behind the idea that every country in Europe is already infected isn't good enough to claim a meritious victory for science over common sense. The four debates Jordan Peterson did with Sam Harris about the reduction of information down to science and the necessity for building value structures and behavioural interpretations of facts proves to me that Science can't tell you how to behave. It can show you what facts will prevent death and what won't, but we never have enough resources to sciencetifically test every single decision tree outcome, there are an infinite number of objective facts. We make best guesses about which idea to follow based on value structure and gathered information we build over time. Sweden's version of common sense is to follow what the scientific signallers are telling them, their reaction to the virus is an expression of culture and law that has little to do with the facts. They can't lockdown even if it was better. Australia locked down and followed the norms for great success with double the population to Sweden, despite having similar issues with aged care facilities. Finland is performing well. I don't see the evidence to support the Swedish solution, nor it as virtous example of science over common sense.
- Mirioron 7y ago>I don't see the evidence to support the Swedish solution, nor it as virtous example of science over common sense. The strong point of Sweden's response is that the Swedish economy is going to suffer much less. Other countries will have to piece their economies together after their lockdowns end. Furthermore, Sweden can keep things going as they are for a long time. How long do you think Australia could keep its lockdown going? If there's going to be evidence to show that Sweden was right then it'll likely take a few years before we can measure the economic impact and all that brings with it. I'm not saying they are right, I'm just saying it's too early to tell that they're wrong.
- friendlybus 7y agoI'm all good with Sweden doing what it wants, it's nice to see a country stand up for it's own values and culture and laws in the face of a deadly virus and find an outcome that works. Pushing a weak argument about the virtues of science as a reasoning for doing so seems a bit much. Australia will go as long as necessary, it is taking this opportunity to do the largest economic reform in 30 years. Australia relies on reform to stop itself from becoming the 'poor white trash in asia' (Lee Kuan Yew). Reductions in corporation tax, strengthening of unions and many more changes. Retail had been slowing down pre-covid and the mining is out of it's boom cycle. There has been rumblings for change coming for a while and all this lockdown is a great way to rejig the setup. We are setting up our agriculture to boom in the 30s so in the long term we should be okay.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoThat's an attractive thought, but I'm less than convinced it's true. For example, I doubt there's much scientific evidence behind Sweden's zero-tolerance drug policy that literally equates heroin with cannabis [1], or their policy of criminalizing all sex work [2], with the admittedly unusual twist of making buying, not selling, illegal. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_Sweden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_Sweden [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_Sweden#Current_legal_status https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_Sweden#Current...
- claudiawerner 7y ago> with the admittedly unusual twist of making buying, not selling, illegal. The twist is probably based on the supposition that for selling to be illegal would mean endangering the the lives of sex workers, who (I assume, as the reasoning goes) are likely to be financially vulnerable. When selling is illegal, there is more risk for the person rendering the services.
- valuearb 7y agoWhen buying is illegal, it still imposes risks on sex workers. First, it hurts their income, meaning fewer sex workers are available, meaning it’s more likely victims will be coerced. Those who participate willingly can be put at risk from their customers when those customers are prosecuted.
- barry-cotter 7y agoA concern for the lives or welfare of sex workers may be among the points used to sell the Nordic model but based on the Norwegian experience they don’t actually care about them. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2016/05/amnesty-international-publishes-policy-and-research-on-protection-of-sex-workers-rights/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2016/05/amnesty-inter... > “If a customer is bad you need to manage it yourself to the end. You only call the police if you think you are going to die. If you call the police, you lose everything.” > --Sex worker in Norway > Amnesty International heard how some sex workers who have reported violence to the police in Norway have been evicted from their homes or deported as a result of engaging with the police. > Under Norway’s laws, sex workers are at risk of forced evictions as their landlords can be prosecuted for renting property to them if they sell sex there. > A representative of a Norwegian sex workers’ rights organization explained: “If landlords don’t evict, the police will launch a criminal case against them...The police are encouraging landlords to take the law into their own hands and enforce it themselves.” > People who do sex work are also unable to work together for safety, or hire third party support like security, as this would likely qualify as ‘promotion of prostitution’ under the law.
- networkimprov 7y agoI think the term you're looking for is conventional wisdom vs common sense. Agreed that conventional wisdom is often wrong.
- eitland 7y ago> If you think that's a given, think again. Many countries base their maternal/neonatal care on common sense and old wives' tales instead. Not a general attack on what you write, just a warning against taking this too far. As both a father of small children, and as someone born in the early eighties I recently found reason to take a closer look at SIDS which peaked around here around the time when I was born: Turns out it was explained by doctors and nurses telling people to let their infants sleep upside down instead of on their backs which is what has always been done. And they had good reasons for what they did as well, at least thats what they said: - sleeping upside down was supposed to strengthen the kids neck and improve early development - another argument was that it would protect them from being choked if they vomited Once people went back to allowing their kids to sleep on their backs, SIDS almost vanished over night. Turns out Chestertons fence is there for a reason. Same goes for a number of other BS ideas that doctors has pushed even around here like the idea that mothers should use wipe their breasts with antibac before allowing infants to drink milk.
- nostrademons 7y agoI wonder what the long-term effects of the "put them to sleep on their back" advice will be, though. Our son hated (and continues to hate) sleeping on his back. We put him down that way because that's what medical advice recommends today, and if he died of SIDS because we didn't we'd feel terrible. But as soon as he learned to roll over, the first thing he did was start sleeping with his butt up in the air. I'm told this is very common, and most infants don't like to sleep on their back, and will avoid it if possible. Are we going to find out in 20 years that we've raised a generation of kids with lower cognitive abilities and poorer emotional control because they didn't sleep well when they were newborns? That they have asthma and sinus problems from mucus dripping down their throat while asleep? That there's some other unknown risk factor we're not accounting for? That's certainly the case with a lot of common parenting wisdom from the 80s. Oftentimes both sides of Chesterton's fence suck, but they suck for different reasons. And humans have a bias toward fixing problems they see, not being grateful for problems that were silently averted. That's why we perpetually tear down fences and generate new stocks of problems.
- specialist 7y ago
- jariel 7y agoExcept that the article gives evidence to the contrary. There is nothing very 'scientifically more accurate' about Sweden's approach to COVID. This is the 'Swedish Model' narrative which borders on propaganda, promulgating an exceptional view of the Swedish government. More often than not, bureaucrats take decisions they think are right, but which can just as easily be base on the arrogance or myopic view of the local institution. Every response in this COVID article illustrates that: - 'Closing borders' has been imminently successful in slowing the spread of Covid in almost every case - either giving more time for officials to prepare, aggressively suppressing it (Korea), or - locking out the disease almost completely (Taiwan). - The 'trust-based' Swedish approach is irrational - because the issue is not 'trust'. The issue is literally physical distance. If Swedes are 'going to restaurants and school' and 'restaurants are a serious vector' - then COVID will spread, it's that simple. - "What evidence was this approach based on? It is difficult to talk about the scientific basis of a strategy with these types of disease, because we do not know much about it and we are learning as we are doing, day by day. Closedown, lockdown, closing borders — nothing has a historical scientific basis, in my view. " This is not true! We have historical data from pandemics, particularly from America which demonstrate cities that went on lockdown were able to recover more quickly from the Spanish flue. Moreover - the issue is risk. The more 'unknowns' there are, the more likely we err on the side of caution, not risk. - "We do not need to close down everything completely because it would be counterproductive" we're 100% certain that lock-downs prevent spread - the issue then becomes one of value vs. cost, but it's not fair to them to indicate it's 'counter-productive'. Even his testimony about 'asymptomatic spread' is strongly challenged by some evidence. Yes, we don't know for sure, but to assume the negative, given the consequences, does not fit this 'we use science not common sense' pragmatism. It's just plain risky. "I recently had reason to investigate to what extent maternal/neonatal care followed the best of our scientific knowledge and it was extremely close. If you think that's a given, think again. Many countries base their maternal/neonatal care on common sense and old wives' tales instead." This is only anecdotal and it's not substantiated. ... The media perspective is mind-blowing: everyone seems to give 'Noble Sweden' the benefit of the doubt with respect to their measures, talking about the supposed effectiveness of it ... but if a Republican Governor were to suggest literally the same measures, they'd be mocked mercilessly on CNN. This is happening literally, today on CNN: governors/mayors wishing to make limited openings of their states, remaining still more closed than Sweden, and wherein they have fewer cases than Sweden, are getting the harsh treatment. I do think they all need to get hard questions from the press, but let's not pretend there's anything more magical going on here with respect to the policy or behaviuor, and treat these groups more 'in kind'.
- danielscrubs 7y agoThat's one way of looking at it. But the one that decides seems quite sure of the opposite of what is considered common sense. https://tegnellcitat.se/ https://tegnellcitat.se/ He's not a humble man.
- throwaway894345 7y agoI can imagine a wild in which the US pursues science based policy, but it swiftly results in the corruption of science to provide evidence that fits certain conclusions. I think this already happens to a degree in certain fields, and especially among think tanks. This isn’t a reason to avoid science based policies, but just a potential snare along the way.