4 ms·
I think it's less of a tale of "vaporware" (I mean, Magic Leap has something that actually exists, even if it's not successful) than yet another cautionary tale
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
I think it's less of a tale of "vaporware" (I mean, Magic Leap has something that actually exists, even if it's not successful) than yet another cautionary tale of startups taking WAAAYYY more money than they need.
There was simply no reason for them to need this much cash before they proved market fit. I mean, has there ever been a successful company that gorged on funding before they needed it that eventually became successful? So many of the Vision Fund companies are in the same boat here.
If Magic Leap couldn't find at least good market fit with a couple hundred million, I don't see how they were going to get there with a couple billion.
- azinman2 7y agoThe issue is the problems they were trying to solve required boiling the ocean. They did manage to boil a good bit of it, but didn’t see it thru all the way — their tech was very expensive and not that good in the end.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- slg 7y agoDo you remember the whale demo[1]? This isn't close to anything they released and I don't see how that is the result of taking too much money or not being able to find a market fit. This product simply didn't exist. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GbpqwUUfMAQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GbpqwUUfMAQ
- modeless 7y agoThis is exactly right. They have some impressive technology and if they had found some non-consumer niche applications they could have had a decent business while continuing to develop the display technology to something suitable for consumers, which is probably 10 years away. They were killed by too much ambition and too much money about 10 years too early.
- dustingetz 7y agoMagic Leap was founded in 2010, it was a different market for capital back then. The market is the market, you can't fight it or it wipes you out, plus you don't ever have complete information until 5-10 years later.
- taurath 7y agoOr: It doesn't matter how many billions you spend on a problem if the core technology isn't there. Scientific discovery advances based on curiosity and open experimentation. That even includes when we "know" how to do the things but its not miniaturized enough yet. Imagine being a company tasked with inventing the walkman 10 or 15 years before it was possible. You'd end up with some crazy designs.
- Bud 7y agoSee also: Apple Newton versus iPhone.