4 ms·
Knowing how long a document is, and whereabouts your current view is, seems pretty fundamental. You may as well argue against page numbers in books.
by Symbiote 7y ago
Knowing how long a document is, and whereabouts your current view is, seems pretty fundamental.
You may as well argue against page numbers in books.
- chrisseaton 7y agoYou just scroll a tiny bit and you can see. Doesn't need to on the screen all the time, taking up space, distracting from the content which is what I care about, rather than whizz-bang user-interface elements.
- noisem4ker 7y agoMe asking myself "how long is this article" before I start reading it is a distraction? Too bad, I can't help but want to know. I could've learned that instantly by unconsciously glancing at the scroll indicator, but instead I have to move the whole content down for it to appear (possibly with a whizz-bang animation, no less), introducing friction and further distracting me from the content. Good job, I guess.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI don't know what you tell you - most people don't think about user interfaces like this. As we can clearly tell by people not designing them like this anymore.
- perl4ever 7y agoMost user interfaces are not designed any more with any intent to provide what's best for the user, because they are part of a product being sold to corporations/advertisers.
- noisem4ker 7y agoIf I were to find a causal relation, it would be the opposite: people not expecting affordances such as scroll indicators would be a result of designers hiding them in the first place.
- Symbiote 7y agoAs far as I'm concerned, the people designing modern user interface styles are not doing it for my benefit. They're doing it to sell adverts (removing the boundaries between content, forms and advertising), track where I'm looking (he's opened the scroll bar! our content is engaging/boring!), adopt fashions to make their competitors appear dated and justify their own careers.
- perl4ever 7y agoMore than that, it's totally adversarial. I don't think the interface on a typical website is just sloppy or badly designed; it's designed to hamper access to information in a very sophisticated way, in order to prevent people from getting what they are looking for and leaving, but at the same time keeping them on the hook with the perception they are almost there.
- ZoomZoomZoom 7y agoThere are margins on the screen 95% of the time, it's a perfect place for a tiny 1-3px scroll indicator.
- Scapeghost 7y ago> You may as well argue against page numbers in books. Actually, yes, when was the last time you looked at a page number in an e-book? They don't make sense anyway when you can resize the reader.
- ZoomZoomZoom 7y agoActually, they very much do: 1. As a relative marker of a current position. 2. As an absolute number when your ebook/reader screws up saving its state.
- Scapeghost 7y ago1. Is solved by "N Pages left in chapter" which is more useful than "Page N" 2. There is no "absolute number" of pages on a e-reader app or device because the window or font size can change, changing all the page numbers. You can have 100 pages or 200 pages.
- ZoomZoomZoom 7y ago1. It's also solved by X/Y where X: page number, Y: total pages. 2. Most users read from fullscreen readers on their phones or ebooks, so the window size doesn't really change. I also strongly advice setting on a font for a particular book and stick to it. From my POV (unbacked by science) it helps with recall. If you don't change the font or other layout settings, the "pages" retain their numeration.
- Scapeghost 7y ago> 1. It's also solved So you agree that there's an alternative solution to page numbers, but you want to go back to page numbers? > 2. Most users read from fullscreen readers on their phones or ebooks, so the window size doesn't really change. Font sizes can change, changing the number of pages.
- ZoomZoomZoom 7y ago