4 ms·
> someone will show up and say Music is not essential Depends on your definition of essential, I'd argue 100% of the world population would survive just fine w
by lm28469 7y ago
> someone will show up and say Music is not essential
Depends on your definition of essential, I'd argue 100% of the world population would survive just fine without music or flowers. Food is essential, water is essential, medicine is essential, shelter is essential. Some tulips imported for 2000km away aren't. I mean, do we really have to debate this ?
If we go there, sooner or later, someone will show up and say Ketchup is essential.
- mns 7y agoUp until someone decides that food is also not essential for the majority of the population and we will just need to drink some sort of universal soy and lentil based smoothie. :)
- anigbrowl 7y ago100% of the world population would survive just fine without music or flowers No they wouldn't, they'd get depressed and eventually become either withdrawn or violent. I'm not arguing for a wasteful and environmentally destructive flower trade, but against your notion that mere maintenance of the biological organism is sufficient. Universals like music and flowers serve an important role in social cohesion.
- gherkinnn 7y agoIf you’re only concerned about the lowest layer of Maslov’s pyramid, then you might be right. Few things are “essential”. But that’s hardly the point.
- elwell 7y agoThe word "essential" by itself is ambiguous. GP didn't posit "Music is essential to survive." Anyways, is love essential?
- londons_explore 7y agoAre all those people really essential, or could we perhaps do with fewer people too?
- brain5ide 7y agoCan I decide what is essential to me and you decide what is essential to you? And then if there are not enough of me, maybe I have to pay more? And maybe if there are not enough of you, you pay more for those that provide those essentialities? Hm... This reminds me of something.
- adrianN 7y agoIf only there wasn't such a thing as externalized costs...