4 ms·
Art (and music) is not something for endless consumption. Music is something we tie to our experiences, to our life, to times we've known, etc. There's no real
by coldtea 7y ago
Art (and music) is not something for endless consumption. Music is something we tie to our experiences, to our life, to times we've known, etc.
There's no real need to always seek new music, obsessively, unless you particularly enjoy to (or you have business reasons). You're not a bad person, or more shallow, or lesser art lover, for not doing so (in fact many very deep creators of art had a very limited set of artists and works they liked).
Having a set of songs, artists etc that speak to you, and you have grown into -- what most people do --, can be even deeper than endless "crate digging" and collection/consumption approach to music...
- glitcher 7y ago> Art (and music) is not something for endless consumption I strongly disagree, although I would say it is completely a matter of personal preference, so I'm really only disagreeing for myself. I'll admit I'm somewhere in the middle between the 2 ends of the spectrum you describe, but I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss the endless crate diggers as "less deep" as other listeners. Sounds like a personal bias to me.
- meowface 7y agoIn my opinion, this is no different from saying there's no need to watch new films or TV shows that come out, or even older ones that you haven't seen before. Why do that when you can just watch Seinfeld, Breaking Bad, the Godfather, and 2001: A Space Odyssey? Why check out books you haven't read before when you have [insert childhood favorite]? There's absolutely nothing wrong with repeatedly returning to old stuff you like. But I don't see how people can be satisfied doing nothing but that. Fantastic new art is being created all the time, and the amount of people creating art is also increasing all the time. The point of endless digging is to try to find other stuff that you may end up liking as much as, or perhaps even more than, the older stuff. It's not simply to consume for its own sake: it's to discover things you otherwise might be missing out on and would be thankful you found. How can you even know if that'll happen or not if you aren't exposed to lots of new things? Also, what does it even mean to "endlessly collect" music in the modern day? You just listen to stuff you haven't heard and turn it off if you don't like it and save it to a playlist/favorites list if you do like it. There's no cost to trying albums you haven't heard before, like there was in the past. If you do really want a physical copy for whatever reason, it's easy to listen online first and decide whether or not you should get the physical copy. This seems akin to lamenting that people are "endlessly collecting" new shows, films, and documentaries by browsing Netflix.
- coldtea 7y ago>In my opinion, this is no different from saying there's no need to watch new films or TV shows that come out, or even older ones that you haven't seen before. Why do that when you can just watch Seinfeld, Breaking Bad, the Godfather, and 2001: A Space Odyssey? Indeed, why?
- meowface 7y agoIf the people who were around when those shows and films came out had that same mentality, then they never would've seen them.
- saithound 7y ago> In my opinion, this is no different from saying there's no need to watch new films or TV shows that come out, or even older ones that you haven't seen before. Sure, the same argument applies, but that seems to be a feature rather than a bug. There's no need to obsessively seek out new movies or TV shows, unless you particularly enjoy doing that.
- meowface 7y agoI'm not saying obsessing about it. The parent implied they never sought out new things to listen to. Looking for something new to watch every so often is a pretty standard activity, I think.
- saithound 7y agoOn the contrary, the parent's point seems pretty clear about the obsessive aspect: "There's no real need to always seek new music, obsessively [...]".
- meowface 7y agoTrue. But I think they were presenting a false premise, because the parent they were replying to made no mention of obsessiveness.
- fiblye 7y agoYou could easily same the same for movies, TV shows, games, cuisine, parks, or anything. If you like something, there's nothing wrong with enjoying it again. It doesn't mean you should limit yourself to the things you know. Once in a while you find something that's better than anything you've encountered before.
- Funes- 7y ago>Once in a while you find something that's better than anything you've encountered before. Yeah, you can find something new you like, but that doesn't mean that you necessarily have to be looking for it, especially not obsessively.