3 ms·
And yet there are still a large number of people who disagree with you, take the campaign as an affront and respond with defiance, which still makes use of that
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
And yet there are still a large number of people who disagree with you, take the campaign as an affront and respond with defiance, which still makes use of that campaign instead of a less threatening one inherently dangerous. Notice that this is true even if you're right about the seatbelt law.
> There's a cost to society (we have to clean up the mess) and to the family (if any).
The cost of cleaning up the accident site is de minimis. The cost to the family is an internal family matter -- if you care about your loved ones, get them to wear their seat belts.
- Hamuko 7y ago>And yet there are still a large number of people who disagree with you, take the campaign as an affront and respond with defiance, which still makes use of that campaign instead of a less threatening one inherently dangerous. Do you have figures to back that up or is this conjecture?
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYou can find polls of popular support for seatbelt laws anywhere. The numbers depend on the poll but generally some large plurality of people (e.g. 30-40%) disagree with the law, sometimes more. It's obviously basically impossible to measure how many of them respond to the campaign by not wearing their seat belts, but out of what would be something like a hundred million people who disagree with the law, do you really expect the number to be zero?
- Hamuko 7y agoWell, if I need to guess how many of the 30-40% people who disagree with the seatbelt law would use seatbelts if not mandated, and are now not using them to spite their own face, I am guessing a very low figure (not a large amount of people). Lower than the amount of people who were not using seatbelts and are now using them if for no other reason than to save themselves a fine at least.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoIt doesn't have to be larger than the number of people who use a seat belt because of the law, only the number of people who use a seat belt because this campaign was more effective than an alternative campaign that isn't so antagonistic, e.g. one that emphasizes the risk of death rather than the risk of fine, which you would generally expect to be a bigger motivator anyway. And the better campaign may in particular be more effective at getting the people who weren't wearing their seat belts originally and still don't under this campaign, because they're more likely to be the defiant ones to begin with, so they're more likely to be receptive to a less antagonistic campaign.
- Hamuko 7y agoHow many people disagreed with the campaign then?
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYou're asking for something you have to know nobody has polled on one way or the other. But the number of people who disagreed with the law to begin with is probably a pretty good approximation for the number of people who disagreed with a campaign which is effectively promoting the law.
- Hamuko 7y ago>You're asking for something you have to know nobody has polled on one way or the other. Yeah, since you're arguing that the campaign was bad because people disagreed with it and stating it as a fact. >But the number of people who disagreed with the law to begin with is probably a pretty good approximation for the number of people who disagreed with a campaign which is effectively promoting the law. In what way?
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Yeah, since you're arguing that the campaign was bad because people disagreed with it and stating it as a fact. It is a fact. I've met people who do this. > In what way? There are people who disagree with a law that orders them to do something they think should be a personal choice. There are people who disagree with an ad campaign that orders them to do something they think should be a personal choice. If you had to propose a hypothesis about whether a correlation exists between these two groups, what would it be?
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> The cost to the family is an internal family matter -- if you care about your loved ones, get them to wear their seat belts. That's a nice ideal, but you have to contrast it with the systems-level view: people indeed are idiots, barely a step up from a chimpanzee, and absolutely need to be protected from their own idiocy. We all do, some to larger extent than others. We often don't notice it, because we've been born into a complex world, and have internalized many rules that protect us without even thinking about it. Note that risking the lives of you and other people in the name of hurry is also a form of idiocy; a very common one with otherwise smart people. We're creatures of emotion after all, and the thinking mode that processes impatience isn't good at cost-benefit analysis.