6 ms·
> Click It or Ticket I've always hated this one because there is a significant contingent of people who disagree with seatbelt laws -- even if they themselves
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
> Click It or Ticket
I've always hated this one because there is a significant contingent of people who disagree with seatbelt laws -- even if they themselves always wear their seatbelts -- because it's a central example of a law that shouldn't exist when the role of criminal law is to save innocent people from bad people and not idiots from themselves.
And then the campaign feels like a direct attack on the people who don't agree with the law, which encourages defiance, which is the exact opposite of the intended effect. With the further effect of making people angry while they're driving a car, which dangerous in itself.
The cynic may also notice that such laws are commonly passed in order to generate revenue, in which case stimulating defiance could be fully intentional because more defiance generates more revenue.
- Spare_account 7y agoThere are external costs when someone doesn't wear their seatbelt. First responders are kept busy tending to their needs when they are injured. Ambulances and hospital resources are kept busy when they otherwise wouldn't need to be. Rear seat passengers not wearing seatbelts can directly injure front seat passengers who did not consent to the risk. To argue that the seatbelt law impacts on personal freedom seems shortsighted to me.
- renewiltord 7y agoThis was an interesting hypothesis. I enjoyed the idea so I wanted to see what probability I should assign the idea that the defiance-effect overrules the compliance-effect. Interestingly, there is one state which does not have a mandatory front seat adult passenger seat-belt law which gives us the ability to test what effect that has. New Hampshire: No adult front-seat passenger seat-belt law. Beltedness: 67.6% Lowest beltedness (any law): Massachusetts (73.7%), secondary enforcement (i.e. if you violated another driving law then you can be cited for the seatbelt thing too) Lowest beltedness (primary enforcement): Mississippi (78.8%) Regardless of the paternalism angle (which I'm sympathetic to because I would like drug use to be permitted, etc.) this would appear as evidence that the defiance-effect is overruled by the compliance-effect. Certainly, it is sufficient enough for me to not look further into the subject. Standard HN disclaimer so we don't get into some Internet war: Not attempting to refute anything you're saying. Just sharing my conclusions. Your priors and your weights to evidence may yield different posteriors. I do not require you to convince me and I am not aiming to convince you. The hypothesis I wanted to test may slightly vary from yours due to my interests being different and to aim for easier falsification. The existence of this disclaimer is not intended to be evidence that I believe you will engage in an Internet argument.
- loco5niner 7y ago> to save innocent people from bad people and not idiots from themselves. But you are also saving the idiots fellow passenger from the idiot when the idiot becomes a human missile in an accident. There are SO many scenarios we don't think about when we go about our daily lives that others happen so see on a daily basis. I ended up going to a seatbelt class because I got such a ticket once. It was led by a nurse who got involved because she was sick and tired of having people come into the emergency room absolutely destroyed.
- loco5niner 7y agoI will also mention: I would imagine it's much harder for a driver without a seatbelt to continue maneuvers (and trying to avoid hitting people/things) when they are not properly secured and getting bounced around.
- eitland 7y agoI'll try to help reframe it into a context were it is harder for you to disagree > the role of criminal law is to save innocent people e.g. Law abiding tax payers, companies that hired the people who didn't want to use seat belts, their families and anyome else who would suffer if they were injured > from bad people in this case careless drivers who'd drive without a seatbelt. Not related to you but possibly mildly interesting and somewhat related to reckless driving and reckless behavior generally : Around here I guess we are the spoiled brats of the world, so when quarantine laws went into effect employees in permanent positions who were quarantined still get full pay. Then it turned out a number of people took advantage of even this, crossed the border into Sweden (who has a totally different approach, they still -last I heard - go for "herd immunity now" it seems) After all, food is cheaper on the Swedish side and then you get a paid holiday, right? So we recently changed the rules to make sure that wont work anymore ;-) Seriously: some people amaze me in how little personal benefit they have to have see to put everyone at risk.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYou are using a line of argument that would justify prohibiting meat, cheese, corn syrup, skydiving, mountain climbing, NASCAR, sailing, tobacco, alcohol, pizza, Coca Cola, desert foods and non-procreational sex. They all risk your life for a momentary personal benefit when someone else might prefer you not and then live longer. It's also essentially arguing that no one has a right to intentionally end their own life no matter how much they're suffering if their continued existence is beneficial to any third party. You don't owe the benefits of your continued existence to anybody else, so whether risking your life is bad is a determination you get to make for yourself. > So we recently changed the rules to make sure that wont work anymore Naturally. But there are two problems with that. First, it's not really analogous to seatbelt laws, because if you don't wear a seatbelt then you could die but if you get a virus and spread it to five other people who each spread it to five other people etc. then thousands of people could die. And second, those people are then in a different country which is making its choice in a different way. They may be wrong, but they're sovereign, and it's the people who live there and intentionally go there who suffer the consequences. What you should do is not let those people come back without being quarantined.
- FullyFunctional 7y agoYou are implying that the consequence of not wearing a seat belt and having an accident hurts only the idiot? That's not the case. There's a cost to society (we have to clean up the mess) and to the family (if any). It's incredibly selfish and irresponsible to take such completely pointless risks.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoAnd yet there are still a large number of people who disagree with you, take the campaign as an affront and respond with defiance, which still makes use of that campaign instead of a less threatening one inherently dangerous. Notice that this is true even if you're right about the seatbelt law. > There's a cost to society (we have to clean up the mess) and to the family (if any). The cost of cleaning up the accident site is de minimis. The cost to the family is an internal family matter -- if you care about your loved ones, get them to wear their seat belts.
- Hamuko 7y ago>And yet there are still a large number of people who disagree with you, take the campaign as an affront and respond with defiance, which still makes use of that campaign instead of a less threatening one inherently dangerous. Do you have figures to back that up or is this conjecture?
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYou can find polls of popular support for seatbelt laws anywhere. The numbers depend on the poll but generally some large plurality of people (e.g. 30-40%) disagree with the law, sometimes more. It's obviously basically impossible to measure how many of them respond to the campaign by not wearing their seat belts, but out of what would be something like a hundred million people who disagree with the law, do you really expect the number to be zero?
- Hamuko 7y agoWell, if I need to guess how many of the 30-40% people who disagree with the seatbelt law would use seatbelts if not mandated, and are now not using them to spite their own face, I am guessing a very low figure (not a large amount of people). Lower than the amount of people who were not using seatbelts and are now using them if for no other reason than to save themselves a fine at least.
- Hamuko 7y ago>it's a central example of a law that shouldn't exist when the role of criminal law is to save innocent people from bad people and not idiots from themselves. Do these people also disagree with drinking/smoking age laws?
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoSome of them do. Some argue that that's different because then it is someone bad (tobacco company) hurting someone innocent (child who doesn't know any better).
- Reelin 7y agoAdding to that, age laws are also a far more complicated topic than it might seem at first glance. Young people will generally lack education and experience, while chronic exposure to some chemicals can have drastic effects on physical development. Worse, developmental issues appear to overlap extensively with the previously mentioned "bad people" that criminal law is hypothetically supposed to protect us from. Personal liberties aside, there would be significant consequences to society if we couldn't reliably produce at least marginally functional and healthy adults. Related to that, in many countries there seems to be some expectation of the government looking out for younger people to at least a limited extent. Compulsory education and foster care come to mind among other things. I guess what I'm getting at is that raising healthy children seems to be much closer to a serious public health threat (ex pandemic) than to engaging in a risky activity (ex white water kayaking) when placed on a continuum.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoSmoking, drinking and driving without seatbelts all cause health risks to third parties (in form of second-harm smoking, crime&domestic violence, and bodies flying around the vehicle during an accident, respectively). I think it would be better to discuss the "protecting idiots from themselves" angle using activities that harm only the people engaging in them.
- MaulingMonkey 7y ago> it's a central example of a law that shouldn't exist when the role of criminal law is to save innocent people from bad people and not idiots from themselves. Seatbelts increase the chance of remaining in your seat - and thus in at least partial control of your vehicle - mid-accident. That protects more than just the idiots - it protects any passengers, and it protects the pedestrian wheeling a stroller on the sidewalk, when the idiot's car goes flying towards them during an accident, by giving the driver a chance to steer elsewhere. > And then the campaign feels like a direct attack on the people who don't agree with the law, which encourages defiance, which is the exact opposite of the intended effect. With the further effect of making people angry while they're driving a car, which dangerous in itself. Wikipedia has references suggesting it's done more good than harm on at least seatbelt wearing rates: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Click_It_or_Ticket#Success https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Click_It_or_Ticket#Success This doesn't measure anger induced traffic accidents, but anyone that easily angered on a regular basis will probably find some excuse to be angry no matter what if you ask me. At least if they direct their anger at a billboard instead of a fellow driver, they might be slightly less likely to get our of their car and start a fistfight? > The cynic may also notice that such laws are commonly passed in order to generate revenue This resonates with me, though, especially when prosecutors are... lax with evidence requirements.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Seatbelts increase the chance of remaining in your seat - and thus in at least partial control of your vehicle - mid-accident. Is this just speculation? Without a seatbelt you get thrown from the vehicle when you hit something, but by that point it's by definition already too late to avoid it, and then you're just in butterfly effect land. Maybe having someone in the car helps because they keep their foot on the brake and the car stays where it is, maybe that's bad because another car that hits the smashed car has to absorb a harder impact when the other car is held in place by the brake instead of being pushed away. > Wikipedia has references suggesting it's done more good than harm on at least seatbelt wearing rates This is not the right comparison because the thing to be compared is not seatbelt use prior to the campaign, it's seatbelt use under a different seatbelt campaign, e.g. one that emphasizes the risks to your life rather than the risk of a ticket -- which may actually be more effective regardless, because dying is a lot worse than getting fined. > This doesn't measure anger induced traffic accidents, but anyone that easily angered on a regular basis will probably find some excuse to be angry no matter what if you ask me. That's just a rationalization. Volatile individuals exist. Removing triggers for their volatility while they're engaged in a dangerous activity is an advantage.
- helsinkiandrew 7y agoThe UK used fear to spread the message, with great effect. The thought of being in a car without a seat belt terrifies me: https://youtu.be/mKHY69AFstE https://youtu.be/mKHY69AFstE