4 ms·
Chrome has the same issue. The thing is, Safari is deeply connected to OS X and its internals to save as much energy as possible. Apple can do this and tie the
by mschuster91 7y ago
Chrome has the same issue. The thing is, Safari is deeply connected to OS X and its internals to save as much energy as possible. Apple can do this and tie the code to the specific hardware, kernel, and what else matters that Safari runs on as they control everything. Chrome and Firefox cannot.
I would not be surprised if someone tells me that parts of Safari hook into private APIs in the kernel, the graphics driver and the other parts of the graphic and input stack to achieve the (measurable!) performance advantage over other browsers. For me personally, this is uncompetitive behavior that should be punished, but oh well, anti-trust legislation isn't exactly something that got much use over the last decades :(
- paulryanrogers 7y agoDoesn't Safari also lag in implementing new or battery-hungry features? I suspect that could be a big factor too.
- _startingover 7y agoThe rendering engine is open source. You’re welcome to audit it here: https://webkit.org/getting-the-code/ https://webkit.org/getting-the-code/
- spijdar 7y agoYou think Apple should be punished for creating a vertically integrated stack? Setting aside private APIs as I have no idea what Safari does or doesn't use (although vast portions of it are open source, enough that you can compile modern versions of WebKit and "upgrade" the ancient WebKit on PowerPC Macs), another browser could be just as closely integrated as Safari. Obviously, the cost/benefit ratio is awful for Mozilla and Google, so they won't, but why should Apple cripple their own software? Safari's development costs, as part of MacOS, are funded by profits from Mac sales. Safari is deeply integrated with MacOS which is in turn deeply integrated with the Mac. In my opinion the whole point of the Mac is this vertical integration, and the main value-add of Apple's sphere. If you don't value that, there are cheaper options where cheaper and more flexible software is available. To me, an anti-trust suit would make sense for Safari on iOS, where Apple has locked all competitors out (in practice). Saying Apple should be fined for Safari because it's more integrated and efficient and that's not fair to Chrome and Firefox seems a bit silly, especially given (desktop) Safari's relatively small usage numbers. All IMO of course.
- mschuster91 7y ago> You think Apple should be punished for creating a vertically integrated stack? No, only for not giving everyone a fair and equal level of access. I'm not against Apple deeply integrating Safari into the OS, but they should allow competition to enjoy the same level of performance that their own stuff does.
- acdha 7y ago> I would not be surprised if someone tells me that parts of Safari hook into private APIs in the kernel, the graphics driver and the other parts of the graphic and input stack to achieve the (measurable!) performance advantage over other browsers. For me personally, this is uncompetitive behavior that should be punished, but oh well, anti-trust legislation isn't exactly something that got much use over the last decades :( In the absence of any evidence of this — have you looked at the open source releases? — why is that more plausible than a team employed by a hardware vendor which cares deeply about user experience and battery life prioritizing use of the platform features and talking with other teams at the same company? Part of what makes things like Firefox' compositor work hard is that they support multiple other platforms so the Safari team can easily be ahead without anything underhanded simply by virtue of not needing to support 4 major platforms.
- throwanem 7y agoAntitrust legislation? For a company that has like a tenth of the market, tops? Be serious.