8 ms·
> Smokers are fully aware of the health risks of smoking. But they ignore all warnings from friends, family and outsiders. Because the only voice they listen to
by eyelidlessness 7y ago
> Smokers are fully aware of the health risks of smoking. But they ignore all warnings from friends, family and outsiders. Because the only voice they listen to is theirs. And it tells them things like, "Everything causes cancer these days" or "I can give up whenever I want.
This is not the logic of most smokers I know (myself included). My reasoning, like that of most smokers I know, is:
1. I know how bad smoking is.
2. I know how hard quitting is.
3. I know the mental health effect of a quitting effort (whether successful or not) is challenging and unpredictable.
4. I have a lot of other challenges in life that incentivize putting off #2-3 until such a time as I think I can weather the storm and have a high chance of success.
Most smokers try and fail to quit multiple times before they succeed. It's a strong addiction, with a lot of negative emotional associations.
- chrisandchips 7y agoYou really should read allen carr's easy way to quit smoking. I was a smoker for a long time and would say exactly what you've said here. The main pull for me was always the social smoking as well. The tl;dr is that, for a lot of different reasons that aren't your fault, you've become convinced that quitting smoking is a lot harder than it actually is. If you have any feeling like you would like to quit (or that you think its gross) then go grab the PDF and give it a shot. I dropped the habit two years ago and have never had a slight urge to try again. The text is a little cringeworthy, but if you can look past it you will see the benefits
- fabiandesimone 7y agoThat book is magical. Made me quit cold turkey after 10 years smoking one pack a day.
- exhilaration 7y agoI see the PDF is posted here: https://www.reddit.com/r/QuittingJUUL/comments/d10l69/full_pdf_of_allen_carrs_easy_way_to_stop_smoking/ https://www.reddit.com/r/QuittingJUUL/comments/d10l69/full_p... In a subreddit called "QuittingJUUL", none the less! An entirely new generation is getting to learn about Carr's book.
- darkerside 7y agoI strongly agree. This book is the way. Your might not quit right away, but if you let it, it will infect your mind with a new virus that outcompetes the cigarette meme over time. Quitting smoking is both easier and harder than you think it is, but having done it, I learned a lot about my mind and the way humans think in general. Another step on the path to enlightenment. Good luck.
- chickenfries 7y agoListening to the audiobook while smoking is how I quit. Took me two attempts but it really wasn’t some grueling, terrible ordeal the whole time. Smokers and non smokers alike romanticize smoking excessively. Listening to Carr helped me realize that smoking is actually a huge pain in the ass that makes your life worse instead of something so pleasurable that living life without it seems like asceticism.
- zomglings 7y agoI also quit directly because of Allen Carr's Easy Way to Stop Smoking. This is a fantastic book, and I gladly gift it to anyone I know who wants to stop smoking.
- eyelidlessness 7y agoThank you for the suggestion (and I see all the other praise for this in the sub-comments). I will definitely give this a read as soon as I have time available.
- Vibrelli 7y agoGreat book worked for me!
- rags2riches 7y ago> Most smokers try and fail to quit multiple times before they succeed. There's truth to the joke "quitting is easy, I've done it many times". It's not the quitting part you have to worry about.
- stronglikedan 7y agoI used to say, "I quit every night, just before bed."
- mcny 7y ago> Most smokers try and fail to quit multiple times before they succeed. It's a strong addiction, with a lot of negative emotional associations. I know it will sound too obvious but my thought when I read the above is that the best time to reach people about the dangers of smoking is before they start smoking. I am not so sure that smokers are aware of the risks of smoking, especially when they first start smoking. A big one a smoking friend told me that he could tell himself was decreased lung capacity. I don't know if this is scientifically proven (anecdotal evidence) but he says he used to swim longer when he was younger (and didn't smoke). Just spitballing: How do you feel about a ban on buying tobacco related products without a license/prescription? Like you can buy cigarettes and such only if you have a document that says you need it?
- mercer 7y agoAs a smoker I'd be fully in favor of that. Anything that lets existing smokers do their thing, but makes it significantly more difficult for non-smokers to start, is a good thing.
- jschwartzi 7y agoIn the US we tried a program called DARE that was focused on telling kids about the dangers of harder drugs to try to get them to stay away. That program was later discontinued because it was shown to have no impact. Part of the problem here is that we focus on the negatives of smoking as the reason for quitting. But nobody ever talks about how good it can feel to smoke a cigarette. It's relaxing. The nicotine creates this nice, peaceful feeling. In my opinion if you want people to quit smoking you need to give them the tools to create that feeling without smoking. Otherwise people will seek that feeling out when they're trying to quit and the easiest way for them to get it is to light a cigarette.
- mcny 7y ago> In the US we tried a program called DARE that was focused on telling kids about the dangers of harder drugs to try to get them to stay away. That program was later discontinued because it was shown to have no impact. Part of the problem here is that we focus on the negatives of smoking as the reason for quitting. But nobody ever talks about how good it can feel to smoke a cigarette. It's relaxing. The nicotine creates this nice, peaceful feeling. I don't smoke and I have no intention of learning the nice, peaceful feeling. I was just saying that we already require people to be twenty one years old to buy tobacco. I completely support legalization of all drugs but perhaps there should be some supervision. I thought requiring a prescription/license to buy drugs makes sense. We require a doctor's visit to get birth control pills. Perhaps we could even get rid of the age limit if we require a prescription... Or do you fear the market will flood with unlicensed (possibly adulterated/low quality) tobacco products if we make it too difficult to get tobacco without a license/prescription?
- munk-a 7y agoDo you really think most smokers hit those points over and over? If so, doesn't that mean it's something we should probably ban as a society and provide transitional support to help wean people off of it more gracefully? Even if tobacco itself remains an accessible substance, getting rid of pre-rolled cigarettes would probably annoy a large portion of the population into quitting. I've never been a smoker so I can't really relate, but sugar is addictive as hell and quite terrible for you as well. I try and minimize deserty things and get really annoyed when something I'd like (like a nice dry cracker or a marinated piece of meat) is needlessly slathered in sugar. I, personally, want regulations that would push prepared food back into the realm of healthy because, even if the taste suffers a little, it'll let me relax a bit when trying to consume food healthy while also feeling the time stresses of a full time job & commute.
- stOneskull 7y agoI think it's dangerous thinking to wish the state and its guns to dictate life
- munk-a 7y agoSo here's a fundamental issue I have with this brand of Libretarianism - states have laws, they have laws whether they're prohibitions or allowances. Most humans agree infanticide is bad so that's been illegal for a lot of history. Most of the laws in society aren't just to wag a finger at someone and saw "naughty naughty!" they're there to make sure that people with disproportionate amounts of power don't take advantage of other people. Minimum wages are there to protect workers, not just needlessly increase the bottom lines of companies - contract law exists to prevent private entities with guns from just having whatever they want... We, as a society, have allowed our food supply to get saturated with sugar - fixing that is just as controlling of our lives as allowing it was in the first place. We, as a society, have allowed tobacco smoking to bloom as it has - fixing it is just as controlling of our lives as allowing it was in the first place.
- stOneskull 7y ago
- kodablah 7y agoI know many smokers that have different logic. They know how bad it is, yet for them it is not hard to quit, but they choose to smoke (often only occasionally or "celebratory" as some insurances call it). Many just don't want to quit, don't try, and accept the trade offs of enjoying their vice vs its harms. This choice, like many choices involving vices or other intentional deviations from happiness vs wellbeing, are too often assumed to be made in ignorance. This same misunderstanding also happens when one political persuasion attempts to rationalize the choices of another.
- mercer 7y ago> Many just don't want to quit, don't try, and accept the trade offs of enjoying their vice vs its harms. Unless you've invented a mind-reading device I'm pretty sure you're talking out of your ass. Most people, including myself, might at times express a lack of desire to quit smoking, but it's often not how we really feel about it (especially not in the morning).
- joesb 7y ago> Unless you've invented a mind-reading device I'm pretty sure you're talking out of your ass. You may feel that. But you can't know what other smokers feel, either.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Tijdreiziger 7y ago> This choice, like many choices involving vices or other intentional deviations from happiness vs wellbeing, are too often assumed to be made in ignorance. Smoking happens to be a vice that has particularly noticeable side-effects on the rest of society. If you lived alone, had an adequate ventilation system (which does not distribute your smoke to your neighbors), and only smoked in your own house, I doubt there would be many complaints. The problems start when you have a family, or when you go outside where others now have to deal with your smoke.
- eyelidlessness 7y ago
- 0x8BADF00D 7y agoAnecdotal, but many smokers I’ve known are using nicotine as a cognitive enhancer.
- stronglikedan 7y agoYup. I've solved many a perplexing problem over a five minute cigarette break. Now that I've quit, I find a brisk five minute walk is a suitable substitute, but not quite up to par with the nicotine. I consider it a good compromise though, considering the health risks.
- alexilliamson 7y agoWhat's your caffeine intake like? I'm wondering if drinking an extra cup of coffee can help cognitively or if the caffeine stimulation just makes the nicotine craving worse.
- yiyus 7y agoI don't think there is a general answer. I have to quit coffee when I try to quit smoking (it reduces the craving and helps me to sleep at night), but I know people who have quit substituting the tobacco with huge amounts of coffee. You will have to find what works better for you. Good luck!
- stronglikedan 7y agoVery high. I only stop when I start getting the jitters. although, back when I smoked, I was never one that had to have a cigarette and coffee together, but I hear it's very common.
- eyelidlessness 7y agoFWIW, if you find nicotine (or caffeine as suggested in nearby comments) helps you cognitively, that's a potential sign that you have a dopamine deficiency (i.e. ADHD).
- 7y ago
- hestipod 7y agoIs caffeine any different? I went 40 years without it but started when I had a need for some energy as life was so bad. I tried to quit after two years and had 30 days + of migraines that never left of abated so I went back on it. I want off but I am not in a position to have MORE pain and headaches now as life has collapsed. I wish I had never had a coffee. The small boost and bowel regularity are benefits, but the dependence is miserable. Even getting off a cup a day is super painful for me and I have read I am not alone...but people who aren't as affected think its ridiculous.
- notatoad 7y agoyes, it's very different. the health impacts of coffee are significantly less than the health impacts of smoking. Coffee doesn't cause cancer or heart disease. ~480000 americans don't die every year of caffeine-related illnesses. being dependent on anything sucks, but a dependency on something that's not really even bad for you is a lot different than a dependency on something that has a decent chance of killing you.
- TylerE 7y agoThe relevant question would be the health impacts of caffeine vs the health impacts of nicotine. Smoking is a horrible delivery mechanism. There are others that seem to present far fewer downsides.
- driverdan 7y agoTaper down, don't quit cold turkey. Reduce your intake by 10% a day. Eventually you'll be at a low enough level you can stop and the side effects will be minimal.
- ta1234567890 7y agoIt's not about logic at all. Addiction makes you crave something in an irrational way. Logic and thinking are not the proper tools to make you stop the craving. Look at the 12 steps program of AA, there are no "thinking" or "logic" steps. Recovering from addiction, as well as getting addicted, are mostly social and biological processes. You might want to read about the Rat Park experiment, here's a quick link: https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/substance-use-disorder/what-does-rat-park-teach-us-about-addiction https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/substance-use-disorder/what...
- refurb 7y agoIt's not logic goes entirely out the window when you're addicted.
- d4mi3n 7y agoAA is also pretty well known for having very mixed success rates [1]. I believe the truth of the matter is people form addictions for a wide variety of social, psychological, and physiological reasons. 12 step programs work for about 40% of the people who participate, and a large portion of that success is attributed to the availability of such programs. [2] I believe logic has it’s place. Like a 12 step program, it won’t work for everyone, but there is a place for rational approaches to treatment of addictions. 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effectiveness_of_Alcoholics_Anonymous https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effectiveness_of_Alcoholics_... 2. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/evidence-based-living/202003/the-evidence-alcoholics-anonymous https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/evidence-based-livin...
- the_af 7y agoExcuse my ignorance, but is there an atheist form of AA and similar 12-steps programs? My knowledge of them is very limited to pop culture (like its depiction in TV shows such as The Wire, Breaking Bad and Grey's Anatomy), but their depictions always seemed annoying to me because they are all about god, submission to a "higher power", and "the original sin"/"flawed humans" in one way or the other. If you are actively atheist, you will find this approach off-putting and it won't help you.
- contingencies 7y agoIt took me dozens of attempts. Find three days. Use the next long weekend. No excuses. Cold turkey on Friday afternoon, drink yourself to sleep, self-isolate until Monday afternoon, incorporate endurance exercise (long distance cycling is very good) if at all possible. Try not to schedule critical family/business meetings on Tuesday/Wednesday. Exercise Tuesday/Wednesday. If you are a positive reinforcement type of person, keep a "money and time I didn't spend on cigarettes" and "days of life saved to spend with my kids" counter as a reinforcement every time you log in.
- algon33 7y ago"Drink yourself to sleep" is weirdly phrased. Could you clarify? Also, thanks for the positive re-inforcement idea.
- binarytox1n 7y agoIt's a common phrase that means to drink enough alcohol to pass out. Presumably because otherwise sleep would be difficult to find, due to withdrawal symptoms.
- driverdan 7y agoI downvoted you because these are terrible suggestions. Tapering down is a far easier way of quitting most addictions. Drinking yourself to sleep is always a terrible idea.
- nwienert 7y agoActually I’ve seen variants of this work in many different ways. Listen, you got yourself already onto a powerful drug. People use drugs to come off other drugs all the time, and it works. In fact I think it has a high success rate if done properly. High dose NAC with a couple night’s of Xanax to sleep would probably be better.
- driverdan 7y agoI never said it couldn't work, I said it was a terrible idea.
- jcampbell1 7y agoIt think you are right, and I explain the same concept as: rational people don't quit smoking. The logic is simple and entirely correct. Quitting tomorrow has the roughly same health benefits as quitting today. Quitting today incurs a lot of pain, so it is better to quit tomorrow. By induction, never quit smoking. When one accepts that the rational choice is to continue smoking, then it is much easier to deal with the emotions that come with quitting. That being said, I am a huge fan of nicotine. Gum, patches, vape, snus, are all great. If you want to explore your subconscious then a nicotine patch before bedtime is diving straight into the deep end.
- slim 7y agoI quit smoking in 2013. Before that I tried more or less every month for 2 years till I succeeded. The logic was : 1- every day I'm not smoking has a positive impact on my health. Even if it's a few days 2- I had to make it as easy to quit as it is to restart smoking. Because restarting smoking is too easy and there is nothing I can do about it 3- my environment can make it more easy or more difficult for me to stop. So I had to be ready to stop when the conditions were ideal. For instance, my partner was a smoker too, which made it more difficult for me stop. So when she finally decided to quit smoking, I was able to immediately stop too. We encouraged each other and succeeded together
- nyjah 7y agoQuitting smoking is attainable.. Sure there is some uncomfortable days, but its completely tolerable. The greatest marketing tobacco came up with is how difficult it is to quit. Its a mind fornicator.
- alexilliamson 7y agoIt's definitely attainable, but I feel like there is quite a bit of variance in how painful it is for various people. But I totally agree that quitting has been marketed as more challenging than it is.
- brainzap 7y agoone day you will realize that your body was prio #1
- eyelidlessness 7y agoThis is purely condescending and unhelpful.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]