5 ms·
Not sure they were massively more empathetic either. The reality is that because it's an isolated island whose countrymen aren't regularly jetting back and fort
by notahacker 7y ago
Not sure they were massively more empathetic either. The reality is that because it's an isolated island whose countrymen aren't regularly jetting back and forth it had relatively few cases in mid March and found it completely practical to quarantine everybody who had been overseas for 14 days at that point. Fiji's doing pretty well apart from the tourist industry too, and I'm not sure their government is also outstandingly scientific or empathetic.
Certainly, some countries have done much more counterproductive things than NZ and some countries would have had better capacity to respond if they listened to epidemiologists more. But for all the UK government has legitimately been criticised for being slow to respond and poor at communicating, it went into lockdown on exactly the same day as NZ. It just likely had at least two or three orders of magnitude more cases at the time.
- ghaff 7y agoI strongly suspect that by the time this is done we will have some handle of things that could have reasonably been done differently in different places without the full benefit of hindsight. And some of the policies that were clearly counterproductive. I also suspect we'll probably find that some things that people have very strong and strident opinions about don't strongly correlate to results across regions. And that the reasons why things were so different between a lot of country or state As and country or state Bs will either be unclear or be the result of factors that couldn't really be mitigated.
- im3w1l 7y agoI think "correlates" already is the wrong way to look at this as it implies a kind linear model, but we know it's much more complicated than that. You can't look at a single policy in isolation, you have to look at it as part of a strategy. Then there is also flawed implementations of fundamentally sound ideas to take into account.
- ghaff 7y agoOh, I don't disagree. And even if you look at policies, the cultural response to a given policy can significantly affect the overall effectiveness. Things like density matter too. I can leave my house for a walk and not see a person. Hard to do in Manhattan.
- timClicks 7y agoThere are a few facts missing from your first paragraph. It might look like an "isolated island whose countrymen aren't regularly jetting back" from the outside, but New Zealand is much more connected than that. Inbound, international students, migrant workers (mainly horticulture) and tourists are huge. Outbound, LAX is only a single flight. The quarantine was only imposed fairly recently. Until late March IIRC, self-isolation was require because it would have been impossible to quarantine ~100k arrivals for 2 weeks.
- notahacker 7y agoSure, before they extended quarantine to everyone and barred all foreign nationals from entering, people who exhibited no symptoms and could demonstrate a 'viable self-isolation plan' were allowed to voluntarily quarantine themselves instead of being put into government approved facilities. That's still something which is considerably easier to impose in New Zealand after only six known cases of a disease than in Western Europe, where people take day trips or even commute to other countries. Sure, NZ isn't [usually] cut off from the outside world, but it isn't a transit hub, somewhere you expect to visit to conclude a business deal or watch the away leg of a football match or a stop on a busy itinerary either. For related reasons NZ only had six known cases by mid March when they imposed that restriction. Italy had 21k cases and 1400 deaths at that point, with a few hundred more dying every day from that point onwards.